Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Posts

OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#1

OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Barry Irby

>A friend of mine is interested in installing a GeoThermal Heat Pump.

Anybody have any experience with them? What type do you have? What type of ground coupling or source do you use? Any advice on where to buy? Cost? Maintenance? Performance? Cost to operate?

Thanks, I would appreciate any perspective on them.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#2

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Jack Hartley

>Barry,

I have had Water-Furnace geo-thermal heating system for 18yrs. The system has performed great over that time. The unit that I have is a closed loop system. The contractor installed 1950 linear feet of 3/4" pipe in 4 loops in my side yard, with 15kw of back up resistant heat. There are several ways to install the loops. They can be installed in a pond, vertically in a well, and horizontally in the ground. The contractor will design the system to your situration. I would not have any other heating system even if I had gas available. The resistant heat is not used. As far as air conditioning goes we stay cool without having to break the bank.

The installation costs is more than a conventual heating/cooling systems but the operating costs will pay for the itself within 5 years.

I hope this helps

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#3

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

teflon_jones

>Heat pumps are a great way to save money in the long run, plus help the environment. They've been used for a long time in large buildings, but with the environmental concerns of today, they're starting to show up in more and more single family homes. The technology has been around forever and works great so no concerns there. I've had it in one home and it worked wonderfully. My heating costs in the winter were very low. I honestly don't remember many specifics about the system since it was there when I moved in and worked great for the 5 years I lived there.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#4

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Barry,

I've known several people with geo-thermal homes, so when I was shopping for new furnaces for my home, I looked into geo with several potential installers and systems in my area. I was impressed with the systems, but even more so with the companies' honesty in telling me that at my age I would not be able to recoup the $45,000 difference in price through cost savings unless I stayed in the house and lived past 85. They both told me that 95% of their business was in new construction where the cost is invisibly amortised out in the sales price and mortgage. I was surprized to learn that the exchange systems (both closed and open) were not maintenence free, and the thought of having to pull the system for repairs was not pleasant because with my site, it would entail a lot of landscape damage.

In the end, I went with conventional HVAC systems.

mm

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#5

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Barry Irby

>Mark, You are confirming what I told my friend. While the systems are wonderful the payback is abysmal. I have lived in my house for twenty five years and have not spent 45k on energy costs, let alone just the HVAC costs.

My friend has an in ground pool. Wonder if that could be used as a heat source? Wonder what effect it would have on the pool temp?

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#6

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Jim Abplanalp Raleigh/Todd

>I have two of them in my house - fed by well water.

The one in the attic is 26 years old and the one in the crawl space was replaced (I now believe prematurely) about 5 years ago.

The effluent is simply piped away from the house - the well is very deep and 45 gal./minute.

The model is Florida Heat Pump.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#7

Discharge

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>In my area, such systems are prohibited because the water in an "open" system is required to be reinjected back into the aquifer at depth. You therefore need 2 wells drilled, and in my area that means a pair of 450' holes in the ground. Consequently most of the geo set-ups I looked at were closed loops.

mm

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#8

Installed ours 25+ years ago

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I hope the $45,000 for the difference between conventional and geothermal heat pumps was a typo or the guy quoting it was wearing a mask and had a gun....

We installed a geothermal heat pump system over 25 years ago when we decided to heat the unheated addition on our house. We couldn't get gas and didn't want fuel oil. Since then my only maintenance has been replacement of one solenoid valve ($50), one well pump ($350) and the addition of a water flow modulation valve ($100). I heat a ranch style 2200 sqft home w/ basement and workshop to 68 degrees (shop & basement are only heated to 60) day and night with a 50,000 btu unit. Our house is total electric (stove and hot water). Our electric bill averages today, $140 per month or about $1680 per year. Note that McKean, PA is about 15 miles south of Erie PA so we do see really cold weather. We currently do not have A/C.

My system uses two wells and I return the water to the ground it came from and the water basically gets used over and over since the two wells are connected in the aquifer. I figured my pay back over the resistance electric heat that would have been added to heat the addition and cost for heating the house that was already heated was about 8-9 years. Our electric bill stayed at $100 per month after adding 1/3 more heated area to our house.

I just priced a new system this past fall to replace my exisitng one, also using the two well system, to add A/C to our house. The total cost of a complete new system was going to be $6,500 installed and would add A/C to my house. Just adding a conventional A/C unit would run about $3,000.

I highly recommend geothermal heat pumps. They do work and they are reliable. Costs for initial installation can be higher than a gas or fuel heating system but they will pay back the difference in a relatively short time.

Lee

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#9

Re: Installed ours 25+ years ago

Dan Donaldson

>One question: What would the additional cost be if you didn't have the wells and had to drill them? Would that cost be a big part of the other quote? Just wondering for future reference.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#10

No Mask

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>No guns either, but with 4,000 sq. ft. to heat & cool in 3 zones, I guess the system was a bit more involved than your ranch. Plus I anticipate with Jersey's regs to satisfy and my iron-acid water the costs were more than in your area. Cost me 10k for 2 new furnaces and a replacement AC condensor unit. The geo guys were obviously talking me out of doing it, so if they inflated their prices to do so, they certainly weren't price gouging to get the job.

mm

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#11

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Howard Acheson

>I live in coastal North Carolina and when I built my house in 2001 I spec'ed a geo thermal heat pump system by Florida Heat Pump. My water source is a well with the used water returned to the aquafer. There is no need for electric strip heaters with a water cooled heat pump. Because the water is 60 degrees year round, there is enough heat in the water to be very efficient in heating unlike air cool heat pumps.

At the time I spec'ed the unit, the difference in cost for the heat pumps was about $4,000 dollar plus the cost of drilling the wells. The wells added another $2,800 dollars. My house is approximately 2,900 square feet.

Oh, by the way, hot water is free during the summer. The unit produces hot water as part of its cooling. This hot water is recovered and routed to my hot water heater.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#12

Re: $45,000? Wow! $45,000?

Peter Gregory

>I have priced out a 5 Ton system recently and it was about $5k more than a gas heat and conventional AC system. Around $6k vs. $11k. Seemed to make sense for us. Payback was around 5 years.

Someone wanted $45,000 additional dollars to install a system? Something seems wrong with this.

I have a friend who did this and he paid around $1,000 extra, per ton of heating.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#13

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Bill in IN

>Don't know where you got the $45K figure, but mine was installed last winter for $15K 4 ton horizontal closed loop buried about 6-8' deep. Highest electric bill has been $143.00 and thats with two hour shower teenagers at home.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#14

Context

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not 45K "additional"

That was for two 3-ton systems with A/C and all the site work. One guy was doing "deep well" systems, the other was a "closed loop shallow (6-8' deep?) ground" system. The "difference" from the conventional gas furnaces was somewhere in the neighborhood of $33,000 which meant to get my investment back in operating costs vs the high-efficiency gas furnaces we bought, it would have taken us nearly 25 years in projected savings of about $1,300 per year. I really liked the idea, but the economics simply did not work out.

Of course, with propane aiming for $4/gal., the economics have changed somewhat.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#15

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Buddy

>We have two Water Furnace units, 3 and 4 ton units, that have been in use for the past 10 years. I have a 1200 feet closed loop system. When cleaning getting ready to move, the water heater was not yet hooked up to the electrical system. We had plenty of hot water to clean everything due to the geothermal units hooked up to the water heater. We have been very happy with our system. We have twice the house that we moved from. Our utilities are now about the same as our former house. We are all electric.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#16

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi Barry.

When we built in 2002, I had a Water Furnace geo thermal system installed. From what I was able to find, Water Furnace is the 1000# gorilla in the industry.

We have 4 300 ft deep wells in the front yard. The depth is required to get down to 60 deg. ground temp. The compressor is a 5 ton unit and the evaporator is a Trane. The Water Furnace part has worked without a problem. However, the "nothing runs like a" Trane evaporator had to be replaced under warranty. And two of the three Honeywell zone dampers failed and replaced.

I can't speak to the month to month cost because this is the first all electric home we have had. Having an electric home is like paying the piper twice. The electric kitchen appliances put heat in the air, the A/C in turn uses electric to remove the hot air.

Would I install a geo thermal system again, ABSOLUTELY.

Happy saw dust,

Ken

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#17

Re: No Mask

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Even with adding a ground loop system around here that would add maybe $6-8,000 worst case $10K to the job. I think that either the people you were talking to didn't know what they were doing or they didn't want your job. Even at 4,000 sqft in NJ the worst you should have needed was 100K BTU or two 50 K btu units and the cost should be only double my quote which was for a Carrier System. there is a 6,000+ sqft house up the road and they heat the whole thing with geothermal and 2 or 3 deep wells. How many BTU's were your furnaces.

Well drilling around here when we did it was about $1,000, but I have no idea what they get these days. Our wells tend to be fairly shallow, less than 50 feet in most cases, mine are 28 feet.

Lee

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#18

Re: No Mask

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Yes, it seemed the guys didn't want the job; actually talked me out of it. Strange because that's all they did, so it wasn't as if they were trying to push me into something else they sold.

Wells here are about 400 feet with the first 100 capped off due to pollutants. Also heavy on the radon.

Re: OT Geo Thermal Heat Pumps

#19

Re: Interesting, wonder if a second quote...

Peter Gregory

>Thanks for the explanation. Seems like they were trying to rip you off. It looks like $1k per ton, for drilling the hole, is the price I have seen twice or three times now. You need one hole per ton. The rest of the equipment costs about the same as a conventional system.

Two 3 ton systems should be no more than $8k or $10k additional in today's market.

If the difference was as much as you were quoted, no one would have one.