Installed ours 25+ years ago
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I hope the $45,000 for the difference between conventional and geothermal heat pumps was a typo or the guy quoting it was wearing a mask and had a gun....
We installed a geothermal heat pump system over 25 years ago when we decided to heat the unheated addition on our house. We couldn't get gas and didn't want fuel oil. Since then my only maintenance has been replacement of one solenoid valve ($50), one well pump ($350) and the addition of a water flow modulation valve ($100). I heat a ranch style 2200 sqft home w/ basement and workshop to 68 degrees (shop & basement are only heated to 60) day and night with a 50,000 btu unit. Our house is total electric (stove and hot water). Our electric bill averages today, $140 per month or about $1680 per year. Note that McKean, PA is about 15 miles south of Erie PA so we do see really cold weather. We currently do not have A/C.
My system uses two wells and I return the water to the ground it came from and the water basically gets used over and over since the two wells are connected in the aquifer. I figured my pay back over the resistance electric heat that would have been added to heat the addition and cost for heating the house that was already heated was about 8-9 years. Our electric bill stayed at $100 per month after adding 1/3 more heated area to our house.
I just priced a new system this past fall to replace my exisitng one, also using the two well system, to add A/C to our house. The total cost of a complete new system was going to be $6,500 installed and would add A/C to my house. Just adding a conventional A/C unit would run about $3,000.
I highly recommend geothermal heat pumps. They do work and they are reliable. Costs for initial installation can be higher than a gas or fuel heating system but they will pay back the difference in a relatively short time.
Lee