Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

Posts

Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

#1

Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

Lee Beeden

>I was asked to price up a kitchen, the clients asked for Vertical Grain Douglas Fir doors with a solid wood raised panel and a cope and stile profile on the inside of the doors.

When I gave my initial estimate of the cost of the kitchen I was over there available budget.

So I began to cut costs with the doors.

My first suggestion was to drop the inside profile, but they did not want to do this.

My second suggestion was to use Vertical Grain Plywood instead of solid wood, for the following reasons:

No Raised panel to mill

No need to reinforce the 3/8 butt tenon with a floating tenon because the plywood can be glued in.

And of course no laminating solid wood panels.

We agreed on this and I have just finished milling up all of my door parts.

However,

the plywood arrived today and its 3/16 thick.I was told by the supplier that this was door material. My cope and stile bits have just milled a 1/4" groove................its a sloppy fit.

Now I am wondering if I glue this panel in and its a sloppy fit are these doors going to be strong enough??

A floating tenon is a lot of work, I would have to make a jig etc. And there is the issue of cost.

I thought about reinforcing the joint with 2 screws. 2 x 3/8 countersinks in the stiles and then I could plug them. Perhaps # 10 screws? However i don't like driving screws into end grain.

These are full overlay doors.

Any comments would be appreciated

Lee

Re: Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

#2

Re: Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet,TN)

>You should not have to add anything extra to a cope and stick door. The joints are strong enough by themselves. Unless you are using some really narrow stiles and rails.

Re: Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

#3

Re: Door Integrity Vs Budget Restraints

Charles M

>Agreed. Extra reinforcement of the joints shouldn't be necessary if the joint is a good fit and properly glued/clamped. Seems to me the problem is the gap in the groove. I suggest using veneer strips to fill the space.

Charles M

Freud America, Inc.