Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Dust Collector Purchase Advice

Posts

Dust Collector Purchase Advice

#1

Dust Collector Purchase Advice

mike kula

>Apologies if this is a rookie question but I am seeking some thoughts/expertise/help on deciding what the best DC purchase for my shop is. Here are the facts:

Shop is about 15X20 and currently run a good jointer, TS, Router, chop saw, drill press in it. I would only need to hook it up to one machine at a time, so I am realistic about not over-buying for my needs. I have been making due with a shop vac but my lungs and the mess tell me its time to grow up to a DC. Oh, I do have a rigid planer, but that is in the garage since its such a beast of a mess, and I have no prob leaving it out there w/o DC attachment.

So, I really am limited right now to right around $200 bucks or under and so here are what I see my options are:

#1 The Delta AP 400 (650CFM and 1hp) for 190.00 on amazon now.

#2 The Jet 650 (also 650cfm and 1hp)which is actually 235.00 I guess but doesnt seem worth the price difference.

#3 A unit sold under the Performax label at menards (550CFM and 1hp) on sale right now for 148.00-- cheapest option

#4 The 1hp grizzly model for 190.00 (delivered) that has the same basic specs as the Mendards one

OR #5-- wait, and find a bigger unit, used around here, but since I have an old house w/o 20amps, I cant go too much bigger.

So, wondering what you think would best fit my needs. I would likely also upgrade whatever unit I bought with better filtration bag, but that add on doesnt have to factor into my budget. My wife's preference is to buy the cheapest!

Anyway, wondering what you all would recommend. Any thoughts appreciated!

Re: Dust Collector Purchase Advice

#2

Re: Dust Collector Purchase Advice

Tom

>Penn State used to have one in that price range. It came with the bags you'd end up putting $ into if you bought the other ones too. I had it for a while until I found a larger used one in the paper. Try craigslist for your area. If your electrical can handle it and if you can find one I'd get a larger used one. Otherwise, I'd get the Penn State. Not sure what the price is on that one anymore.

Re: Dust Collector Purchase Advice

#3

Re: Dust Collector Purchase Advice

Dave Parker

>Hi Mike,

I'm also a newbie looking into a dust collection system, more to protect my health than for any other reason. From what I've been able to determine so far, while the cheaper, smaller dust collectors do a good job in picking up all the visible sawdust, they are unable to collect the 0.3 to 5 micron particles, which pose a health hazard with repeated exposure. If you are going to wear a mask most of the time and aren't concerned about the fine dust, then anything should work.

If, like me, you are concerned about the smaller particles, then you need at least 800 actual cfm or more (real world flow through the tubing, not the peak flow without any resistance that the manufacturers typically give) to adequately collect this fine dust. In addition, you need to have a canister filter capable of filtering down to 1 micron or smaller if you will be exhausting the air back into your shop (it's not a problem if you exhaust outside). A bag filter doesn't have enough surface area to keep the air flow up where you need it. Even a cartridge filter needs to be big enough to keep the air resistance down after a little dust gets into the filter.

To keep the canister filter from clogging too easily, you also need some kind of cyclone system to take out as much of the coarse and fine dust as possible before the air goes to the filter. For a budget operation, I'd buy the biggest blower assembly I could afford and build the Thein Cyclone Separator Lid ( http://www.cgallery.com/jpthien/cy.htm ), then either attach it to a good canister filter (such as Wynn) or exhaust it outside. For more money, you can buy or build a good cyclone separator. BillPentz.com has a lot of good information on dust collectors and detailed plans on how to build one.

The more I research dust collectors, the more I realize that this is going to cost me a lot more time and money than I had originally expected. I am concerned about the health effects of wood dust and it seems that most people enjoying this hobby feel a good dust collecting system is worth it. Good luck with your project!

Dave

Re: Dust Collector Purchase Advice

#4

Re: Dust Collector Purchase Advice

Paul Leuba

>The latest issue of Wood magazine has an excellent article on low cost, one machine at a time dust collection systems. The Grizzley and the Delta 750 model came out well.

Paul in Hunt Valley