Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

turning to chunky

Posts

turning to chunky

#1

turning to chunky

George Smith

>Hi I have been wood turning for almost 7 years with about a two and half year break. I need some advice please. I have had a comment put into my guest book on my web site, and I was advised to contact you to see your comments, no name given in book.

I am told that my work is quite good, but too chunky as I have using

a lot of driftwood and sometimes it is a little unstable, also because of the size,and shape I often have to make it thicker than I normally wood. I would value your comments taking this in to consideration.

Many thanks for your time, my web address is:www.scorpionwoodcraft.co.uk

Best Regards G Smith

Re: turning to chunky

#2

Re: turning to chunky

Bill White

>I see nothing "wrong" with your turnings if that is your style. I would thin the objects (reduce wall thickness) and make the lines flow more, but that's just me.

Always remember that beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Bill

Re: turning to chunky

#3

JL

Re: turning to chunky

JL

>I would post over on the "Turning Board"

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl

Go to the Messageboards "button" and scroll down to turning. Post a few of your turnings on the board and ask for a critique.

Re: turning to chunky

#4

Re: turning to chunky

charlie belden

>Please take this as constructive criticism - for that is my intent. You've got the tools, some interesting wood, have done both spindle and bowl turning and obviously have a passion for turning. That combination has served you well and no doubt has brought you some joy and satisfaction (and since people are buying some of your pieces - some money). A few modifications to some details can reduce or eliminate the "chunky" thing.

You note that you use found driftwood and it is the reason for the chunkiness. But folks turn all kinds of punky wood - burls with voids, bark inclusions etc., spalted wood that has soft areas and so on. There are all sorts of ways to get around those "challenges". I suspect that much of the chunkiness is attributable to edge dulling and use of dulled tools. Drift wood often has stuff that dull tools pretty quick.

To some specifics

If you're going to turn beads and coves, crisp and clean - off the tool - looks better than those details being lost to sanding. While one curve/shape flowing into another smoothly is nice on bowls, vases and the like, it tends to make spindle work and beads and rim details on bowls and the like, look kind of doughy and ambiguous. If you want to turn a detail - keep it crisp and defined.

On plates, platters, bowls and any other "hollowed" form, thick edges can give the impression of massiveness - and maybe an uncertainty about one's ability to turn thin and delicate. Kind of "I'm not sure what I'm doing, or how far I can take this, so I'll stop here."

Can also look like pieces roughed while green

and never refined when dry.

If you go with REALLY thick walls - the extreme can be interesting. But in between it just looks like you lost interest and quit.

As noted earlier, transitions from one curve to another on bowls, vases, etc., look better if they look continuous - flow, one into another. Breaks in those transition, where it's obvious where one curve ends and another begins are picked up by the eye and seen as something that's amiss / slightly disconcerting.

Obvious tool marks left on a piece indicate either an inability to use the gouge or chisel well or a Close Enough attitude - that quits way too soon. A continuous finishing cut produces and nice smooth, continuous surface and says "I know which tool to use and know how to use it.". If you can't yet make those transitioning cuts then use sand paper to achieve a similar look.

In several of the bowls, the inside transition from side grain to end grain appears rough. If one can't cut or scrape that transition smoothly, one could sand it smoother or even smooth. Doing neither can indicate a lack of skill, or a lack of concern for getting a well finished surface, or both. Same goes for the outside of a bowl or vase - a rough area where there's a transition from side grain to end grain.

Another possible factor is WASTE. The idea of converting 90% of what you started with into chips and shavings seems so wasteful. But with turning that ain't necessarily so. Sometimes Less Is Better - especially with bowls and hollow forms.

And on the subject of waste, getting the BIGGEST piece out of a chunk of wood rather than the BEST piece can be a mistake. A smaller, delicate, beautiful piece will win hands down over a larger, less well proportioned, thicker piece. Go for Best not Biggest. On several of the pieces on your web page, had the diameter been smaller for the height, the result would look less "chunky". Tall and thinner is more attractive than short and squat.

The bottom/foot of a bowl can make a piece more or less attractive. If it looks like you just ran out of space to get a nice shape it will be obvious. Maybe give up some visual height in order to achieve and nice transition from table top to piece will do the trick.

After you complete a piece, look at it cirtically and think "What COULD I have done to make this better?" - then remeber that when you do a similar piece. Search the Web for pictures of similar pieces and see how others did that shape or form - comparing your piece with theirs. Note the diffrences and figure out what you're doing that looks right or wrong and what their piece has you can use.

Bottom line though is it's your preferences and it's your creation. If you like it that's all that matters - unless turning is THE source of your income - then it's the buyer who dictates what is and isn't pleasing enough to buy.

Hope this is taken in the spirit it was given and helps you with your quest.