Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

More on buying and pricing lumber

Posts

More on buying and pricing lumber

#1

More on buying and pricing lumber

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There are some good points among the discussion on lumber prices going on below. The purpose of this post is to clarify these points. But first some necessary back ground.

On a commercial scale, lumber is graded and priced by grade. Extremely abbreviated, a FAS grade board is at least 83% clear lumber on its worst side. A #1 common board is at least 66% clear lumber on its worst side, #2 common 50% and #3 common at least 33%. ( I just summarized many pages from the NHLA grading book , so expect that some details have been omitted.

As of July 14 the price (FOB at the mill) of cherry lumber in commercial quantities was FAS$2.30(3.00) , #1 common $1.23(1.62), #2 common $0.64(1.01) and #3 common$0.40. The price in (xx) is the KD price.

Now the points:

1. It should be clear that a lumber price with out specifying grade is a useless number.

2. Shipping is not very expensive so ever where in the US should be near some locally wholesale source of this lumber at prices about $1 to $1.50/bdft more than FOB mill. It follows that if you live where lumber is produced you may be able to buy from a mill and save $1-2 per bdft. This saving can be good value if your time is nearly worthless. In rare cases you may be able to buy for less than FOB mill price if you spend some time hunting such deals.

3. The price at Woodcraft or other retail stores is substantially higher because their customers buy piddly quantities, demand clearer lumber than typical FAS, and this lumber has passed through one or more additional middlemen.

4. Retail fact of life-the typical retail customer wants to pick through a stack, buy exactly what they need, when they need it, for a project with no waste. Hence, they demand the clearest grade of lumber available. They pay through the nose for these demands. It follows that if you don't have these demands you can buy lumber cheaper, but you will need to buy from where the cabinet shops buy and how these shops buy.

5. Almost anything you will even want to build can be made from the clear cuttings of #1 or even #2 common lumber. If you have a large stash of such lumber you will be able to optimally pick pieces such that there will be little wasted wood. I get 90+% yield from #2 common poplar so long as I have plenty to choose among.

6. Now here is the problem. Because customers have not learned to use it efficiently and therefore don't appreciate its value, the typical wholesale establishment does not stock the lower grades. It is very had to find the lower grades for sale in less than truckload quantities unless you buy from a mill. This lumber goes to factories and other large volume users who know how to extract its value.

7. If I lived in Arizona, expected to make things from cherry for the next 20 years, and wanted to lower my cost of lumber I would persuade my local wholesale supply to order me a 500 bdft pack of #1 common. At the price I would pay, and valuing my time at something reasonable, I would not be envying the price someone next to a mill in PA might pay.

8. The one undeniable advantage us Appalachian Mt dwellers have is the greater ability to select specially figured lumber by buying logs, or getting access to sort through large quantities of lumber. A nice table was illustrated in the earlier posting. As far as the size of the cuttings it could have been made from #2 common lumber,a nd maybe was. But, one might have ordered 500 bdft of such lumber from a wholesale supplier at $1.50/bdft and not got a figured piece for the top.

Re: More on buying and pricing lumber

#2

Re: More on buying and pricing lumber

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>You have some good points about using #2 common more effectively. I, luckily, have a lumber dealer that lets me select my own boards. He does contractors as well as clients buying for just one project. If I know I'm making handles out of walnut, I'm not going to buy an 8" wide perfectly clear board. A narrower board with some imperfections that I have to work around is just fine. I see too many people using wide, clear boards to cut into sticks, which is quite a waste.

I think every woodworker should have to mill, dry and then use that wood at least once. You learn a lot seeing it from start to finish. I like to have some rough, nasty, still carying bark and wane stuff around. Makes nice looking proejcts when used right. That's not always easy to find, even at bigger dealers.

Along those lines, we should look at a project and our needs and use the materials accordingly. Sure, if I'm just making handles but I need 500 of them, I may look at good clear boards to reduce my cutting time. If I need 5, some #2 or #3 common (or worse) can work just fine.