OT GPS for car
Doug Ridley
>What is the cheapest GPS for my car that will do the job well?
What about buying used off the internet?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT GPS for car
Doug Ridley
>What is the cheapest GPS for my car that will do the job well?
What about buying used off the internet?
Re: OT GPS for car
Ken Romines
>Doug
We have a Magellan. I don't remember the model but we paid $350-400 for 6 months ago (at Fryes in Dallas). I know the price on it has dropped but there are even less expensive models and I wish I had bought one of those. We are doodad challenged so we don't use all the functions that it has.
I used several models before I bought this one and did not have problems with any of them. They will get you there. All you have to do is remember to put it in you car before you go somewhere. (DAMHIKT).
Don't get lost.
Ken
Re: OT GPS for car
Jennifer@Indy.USA
>Doug, I bought the TomTom One Third edition before Christmas for $149. I liked it so much that I got one for a friend of mine too. We just love them. they are easy to use and I haven't had it skip a beat. I'm not familiar with many of the others personally, but I did do a lot of reading up on them on the net and chose this one because of it's cost and reviews. I got one from Dell.com, and then saw the one for my friend at Wal-mart for the same price and grabbed it there.
Jen
TomTom = $149 or Garmin $250
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>I recently bought a Garmin 200W for under $250 at Staples. They also have the 200 (without the W which stands for wide) for about $200. And they also have the TomTom One for $149. All these prices are still in effect this week, I think.
I looked at the more expensive ones, as well as these lower end ones. The only feature I really wanted was the W = widescreen, so that's why I got the 200W instead of the 200 or the TomTom One.
I did my research.... Garmin/Magellen are the two top rated ones and have been for a while. In general, the Garmin has a nicer/easier interface over the Magellens. TomTom is a newer player in the market and look out, I think their inteface is as nice as the Garmins and might threaten Garmin and Magellen.
Buying a GPS can be a dizzing experience. I know. I buy for myself and my clients. You can spend as little as $150 and as much as $1000. For me, most of the bells/whistles aren't necessary. The low end ones do a lot. The low end ones will verbally tell you to "turn right in .5 miles" or "turn right now", and will show you on the display the actual name of the street to turn on, but they won't tell you "turn right on Spring Street" verbally like the ones with text-to-speech capabilities. Also the lower end ones will only talk to you through their own speaker, some of the higher models will talk to you through your FM stereo in the car. Some of them with BlueTooth will interface with your cell phone to help with hands-free driving. But my car stereo already does that.
My low end one, surprizingly let's me add a SD card to increase the memory, to add maps, music, photos, and lots of little things like chaging the car icon on the screen to closer match your actual vehicle. Things I don't need and thought only the higher end ones would have.
Happy Woodworking!
Get a Garmin
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>We have a Garmin 660 that we got for half price ($400) at the black Friday special at Best Buy. It is great. Even locally, it has showed me new ways to get to places Iv'e been driving to for over 2 years that are quicker than the route I was used to.
We used if in Washington DC area a couple of weeks ago and it was flawless and very easy to use.
I have a Garmin GPS in my boat and it has worked very well for over 10 years. I've compared mine side by side with the one in my buddies boat and his Magellan loses signal every once in a while, while the Garmin never has.
Lee
Re: OT GPS for car
Charlie M
>I purchased a Garmin two years ago and it works very well. It is a higher end model (now discontinued of course), but it is far superior in user interface than the one that cost over twice as much that came in my new shivverlay. I'd go with a garmin that has the text to speech capability the "in .5 miles turn right on spring street," rather the "in .5 miles turn right" eliminates a lot of confusion. I've used it in many places in the USA and Canada and the only problem I had was in rural Washington where it tried to route me over a farmer's field road between Mt Rainier and Mt St Helens. I have since updated the map, but I haven't been back there to try it again :-)
Re: OT GPS for car
ScottS
>I'd be wary of buying used from the Internet. I've owned three different in-dash GPS systems (Acura, Kenwood, Pioneer). In all three cases, the LCD appeared to have a limited lifespan getting dimmer over time. After 2-3 years, they start to become very difficult to see if the sun shines directly on them. With a small, portable unit I assume you'd have more positioning options but I'd still be worried that a used unit would have a dim LCD and be difficult to see...
My suggestion would be to buy a new unit and think carefully about the features you'll really use. If you don't need Bluetooth, MP3 playing, or spoken directions you'll spend a lot less money than if you buy a top-of-the-line model.
detailed maps?
JohnKJordan in East TN
>Does Garmin still charge a lot for detailed maps? I have three Garmins at the moment (have had five) and have purchased thousands of dollars worth of detailed maps over the years. I use a Streetpilot in my truck which comes with base maps but stores highres maps on memory cards. After the first set I declined to pay the high cost of upgrading the maps.
I haven't kept up with the field - are complete maps still hundreds of dollars?
I do like the Garmin hardware. I've used them on 4-wheelers, when flying airplanes, hiking, on horseback, and while wandering around from Alaska to Mexico to Scotland.
JKJ
Re: OT GPS for car
Doug Ridley
>Thanks to all. Good info.
Doug
Re: OT GPS for car
fred in ct
>doug, i got a remanafactured garmin street pilot c340 w/ text to speech last march for $275, now it's down to $214. this unit does every thing i need. one thing to remember is to not leave it on your dash when not in the car. i know around here they are a smash and grab, about 3 a week in the local paper.
Re: OT GPS for car *LINK*
fred in ct
>doug, i got a remanafactured garmin street pilot c340 w/ text to speech last march for $275, now it's down to $214. this unit does every thing i need. one thing to remember is to not leave it on your dash when not in the car. i know around here they are a smash and grab, about 3 a week in the local paper.
garmin street pilot c340
Re: detailed maps?
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>Mine just shows roads and such for all 50 states and all of North America (Canada & Mexico). I'm not sure what you mean by High Res maps. I don't recall seeing them listed on the website either.
You stil have to pay for updates after the first year and for the various travel guides. Mine also has a traffic alert feature, but that is a subscription service also after the initial trial period.
Lee
Re: Get a Garmin
iew
>Dont get a Garmin, they dont include Euro databases. The Euro databases are very expensive. My Tom Tom 900 has all the databases included. We made atrip to the Czech Republic and the Tom Tom was always right on.
IW
Re: Get a Garmin
Howard Norman
>>Dont get a Garmin, they dont include Euro databases.<
That is only a valid criticism if you need European databases, for most of us it is not a necessary criteria.
Re: detailed maps?
JohnKJordan in East TN
>The base maps have the primary roads across the country and through cities. I had to pay extra to get detailed maps with every tiny city street and most small rural roads. There were several different packages - one specifically for selected cities.
It's been several years since I looked - I'll check the web site. The way things go, it will probably be cheaper for me to get another GPS than to upgrade the maps on this one! Well, what else should I expect for $1000.
JKJ
Re: detailed maps?
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>Mine has all the streets in McKean PA a booming metropolis with a population of about 200
Lee
If I could afford....
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>.... a trip to Europe, I'd probably be able to buy another GPS just for the trip ;)
Actually, if I go to Europe, I want to rent a car that has a GPS in it. Better yet, I want to rent a James bond 007 car to drive around Europe.
Happy Woodworking!
Garmin maps
Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie
>My lowly Garmin 200W has the ability to sense that I'm on an exit ramp between roads. I was amazed at that.
Happy Woodworking!
And I'd want
Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA
>James Bond in the car with me! In which case, who cares where we are?! :-)
Psst...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>...that would traditionally be an Aston-Martin. Though, of course, there was the BMW Z3 in one of the Pierce Brosnan iterations.
Jason (who knew BEFORE last night's Mythbusters James Bond Special that you couldn't put a hole in a propane tank with a pistol, much less blow one up--DAMHIKT)
Re: Garmin maps
JohnKJordan in East TN
>>My lowly Garmin 200W has the ability to
>sense that I'm on an exit ramp between roads.
>I was amazed at that.
I remember a new article about a German couple who ran off the road into the water at a ferry because the GPS showed the road continued.
Re: And I'd want
Jennifer@Indy.USA
>Ah, Joanne....thanks for the morning smirk! What would these boys do without the humor of the women here!
I love it :)
Jen
Hum I have a Nuvi 360 now and it
Dustmaker Mike
>has European maps. I have both the US and the European maps for mine. I will see how it works over there in a few weeks and then how well it works in Maylayisa the week after. Gota love a job that lets you buy toys er a Tools to make your life easier while traveling.
Nuvi 360 Friction mount ~$350
Dustmaker Mike
>on Amazon last week. I have the European maps on order now for it another ~$214
Re: Get a Garmin
DP
>Your comment about Garmin not having European databases is not correct as a blanket statement. Some models are loaded only with NA maps but others have both NA and European databases loaded (nuvi 670 and 770 for example). Check out the Garmin website for others. Also in reviews in GPS magazine, http://www.gpsmagazine.com/, Garmin generally outperforms both Tom Tom and Magellan in providing accurate and fast routes, although all their tests that I've seen are in NA so can't say what comparative performance would be in Europe.