Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Wood Pricing Survey

Posts

Wood Pricing Survey

#1

Wood Pricing Survey

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Over the past few months I have been contacted by two different guys who were starting up small hardwood lumber businesses. Both have bandsaw mills and kilns. Both get logs from area arborists. So they are trying to establish a client base for their wood. That's great because there aren't many places to buy hardwoods in these parts.

Generally I buy a lot of my lumber in quantity from sources I have some distance away. So of course I am interested in finding a decent supplier nearby. The problem is, both of these guys want to charge retail rates for their lumber.

Now I know that they need to make a profit but so do I. With my profit margins I cannot afford to buy lumber at retail prices. Hey, it's their business and they can charge whatever they choose. But I have to be up front with them and let them know that I have cheaper sources that discount to woodworking businesses.

So the guy that called me yesterday told me he charges $6bf for 4/4 rough sawn walnut, $4-5bf for 4/4 poplar and $7+ for 4/4 cherry. That's more than I pay from my suppliers. But those prices sound like retail FAS prices. So he might not get much business from me. But that made me curious......

What prices are you paying for plain rough sawn 4/4 walnut, cherry and poplar? And where are you located?

Tom

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#2

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Baltimore -

unsurfaced plain sawn 4/4 walnut - $1.00-1.50 bf

unsurfaced plain sawn 4/4 cherry - $2.50 bf

poplar - haven't bought any recently.

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#3

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

Sue McLam in Orange, VT

>Vermont -

Walnut and cherry are right on with the prices you gave. 4/4 Poplar is slightly under $2.

However, that's the high end. I'm now buying most of my lumber from a wholesaler and just got home and spent $1.55 for Poplar, $2.85 for 4/4 hard maple and $3.00 for 5/4 hard maple. I asked them last week for their price on 4/4 cherry and they said $4.85. They are my new favorite place.

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#4

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I need to find Mike Schwings supplier. I use a guy who sounds similar to the guys you're talking about. He charges under $5 for cherry/walnut and <$1.50 for poplar. His prices are higher now that he's upgraded his place and started stocking non-local species and some ply. Used to be you'd slog around in the mud to dig through piles and cherry was less than $4, now he's got shelter. The prices you're talking about sound like the nicer places that also stock high-end exotics to drool over while you're there.

Jay

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#5

prices? we dont need no stinking prices

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I buy very little wood as I mostly mill all my own stuff. I am trying to develop a local network of suppliers of urban salvage wood so I can spend less time milling and more time in the shop. I have noticed a few things about some of the local saw guys with band mills.

It is usually pretty easy to spot the guys just starting out as they are trying to sell at retail. I have tried to explain to a couple that what they have is ungraded and unproven wood. By unproven (is that even a word?) I mean that they may or may not have their drying cycles down and be producing good quallity dry wood. I have purchased KD from one and ended up with stuff that was between 12-22%, luckily it was not case hardened. I mentioned it to the guy and he gave me a deal on the next stuff. one guy thinks that if he has wide slabs with the bark on that they are worth more than rough diminsioned clear boards because they are "in demand". SO I tell him to sell them to those that demand them and sell me something I want or sell this stuff for the price I'll pay for what I want, huh?

One of the things that is hard for most of these small sawyers to understand is that much of what they have is worth less because I have to buy way more than what I need because buy the time I get to the point of using it and if I am short one board I am screwed. They don't understand that by not having the same stuff day in and day out that what they do have is worth less to the guy working wood as a business. Retail stuff is only worth those prices if I can sort through a couple hudred bf for the one board I want and then come back in 6 months and find a second board to match.

I have two sources that are decent or with what I think are decent prices. both will sell me green wood or will dry it for me and only one has a supply of air dried stock. I don't know the prices off hand but they are more than wholesale and a bit less than retail. Keep in mind that most lumber prices are higher on the west coast. I can buy green walnut for $4-6/bf and $10-15/bf air dried. but that is a bit like coomparing apples and oranges though and I think those prices are part of why your guys are reaching for the sky with their prices. Those prices are for claro walnut(juglans hindsi) which generaly tends to go for almost 2x what eastern black walnut sells for. generaly I can't get anything for less than $2/bf and that would be green.

All of this is not even taking into account the small sawyers ability and skill as a sawyer. many of these guys don't know how to saw for grade or how to minimize grain runout. it is slice em up and sell em $$$.

This is not to say that it isn't worth a little time and trouble to work with these guys if they are willing to work with you. Most don't know the value of some of the lesser species and try to mill the same stuff they see in the other yards. Some of the domestics we have are exotic in comparison if for no other reason then you rarely see them used in furniture. then there are all the trees grown as cultivars that are from other parts of the world. If you haven't guessed I am a bit of a nut about urban woods.

I have found that many clients really respond positively to my stuff being made from urban lumber. I would gladly buy all my urban wood from somewhare if I could find the quallity at a good price coupled with availability. I am usually very interested to hear about a guy with a band mill, but few ever pan out to become sources of wood for me.

Robin

Ps ready for any 3d veneering yet?

Robin

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#6

here in St. Louis *LINK*

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I get $4 for "FAS" cherry, $3.50 for walnut and $1.50 for poplar. Like other urban loggers, I am not a certified lumebr grader, but I have used and bought enough lumber to know what #1C looks like.

The prices above are my "A" price code. #1C gets a B price, and I find that extraordinary material in terms of figure or width deserves a premium price (my A+), which until recently I had too low. When I looked around locally for 14" wide cherry without sapwood, I realized that $4 was too little for what seems to be darn rare material. I am learning.

But I will always have to sell cheaper than retail because I do not offer the convenience of retail. No heated store, no walk in hours to speak of, no suburban location. But at least I have segregated the wood by grade somewhat and those sawyers trying to sell log run at retail prices will just have to learn the hard way.

Wholesale markets and mass retailers treat hardwoods like a commodity, but we all know that special stuff is more unique than "commodity" suggests. That calls for more intelligence on both sides of the transaction.


my Woodfinder page, including prices

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#7

JL

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

JL

>North Georgia - NOT rough sawn - S2S

Walnut - $7.43 FAS

Cherry - $7.46 FAS

Poplar - $2.40 FAS

From the local dealer for rough sawn

Walnut - $2-3

Cherry - $3

Poplar - $1.20

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#8

2 guys around here w/ similar prices

Mike Schwing from Md.

>There are 2 different guys within 25 miles of me who stock cherry, walnut and oak at those really reasonable prices. The retail stores are of course much more expensive, but I don't need to buy from them anymore since I now have a good jointer.

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#9

Lee Grindinger

A year ago

Lee Grindinger

>I was paying $5 a foot for both 4/4 and 8/4 FAS cherry and walnut, no more than 10% sap on worst side.

Lee

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#10

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

Robert Henderson

>I pay less than that retail

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#11

Red Flags

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Robin,

You made so good points. Neither of the two "newbie" mill guys seemed to have much knowledge about the nature of wood, sawing it properly or about their financial relationship to their intended clients (both want business with professional shops and cabinetry places).

The guy who called me yesterday told me that he kild dries his wood to 5-6%. Yeah....right!

I think if these guys don't do their homework then they may not be in business for very long.

Tom

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#12

Green or Kiln dry?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Is this thread comparing dry wood or green wood?

Tom said his suppliers had mill and kilns, so I assumed his prices were for kiln dried.

JKJ

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#13

Kiln Dried

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Good question John. I'm interested mostly in kiln dried 4/4 prices. I'd be interested in either rough sawn or FAS prices as just points of comparison.

I think it's an interesting thing to see the variance of prices, nation wide. While not an absolute, it does seem that living "where the trees are" provides cost benefits for lumber prices.

Unfortunately for me, I live where the corn is!

Tom

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#14

Around in Eastern PA *LINK*

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I just got some lumber, but I'm trying to remember prices without receipts in front of me.

Poplar - about $2.50/bd ft

Maple/Walnut - I think in the $4.50 - $5.50/bd ft range.

I added in the link to Hearne Hardwoods that is a big supplier in the Philly area and lists most prices.

I'm starting to get logs and have the sawn for myself. I'll usually buy lumber when I'm doing commissioned jobs and factor in the current cost. Mills around me are starting to get expensive and I might have to start hauling logs a little farther to get cheaper milling.


Hearne Hardwoods

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#15

air dried, not green

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#16

Re: I'm jealous!

David Hay @ Denver

>When I hear prices in the $3-$5 range for 4/4 cherry, I'm very jealous. The best I've found around here is around $7 a board foot for 4/4 rough cherry.

David

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#17

apples and oranges

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>kiln dried ...rough sawn ...FAS

I think this thread needs to start over. It appears that some are talking green right off the sawmill, some air dried, and some kiln dried. Around here, green is cheapest, air dried is in the middle, and kiln dried is highest.

For air dried, how dry is it? I bought cherry once from a guy who had a wide variety drying anywhere from 6 months to 3 years - black cherry was all $2/bd ft, regardless of how dry. (Poplar, cedar, and pine were $.50) Is it typical to have the same price for barely dried and dried to equibrium?

Also, when you say "rough sawn", that can still mean green, air dried, or kiln dried.

>"where the trees are", ...I live where the corn is!

I live where the trees are. I've got walnut, oak, poplar, and cherry logs that will probably rot on the ground before I get them all sawn, and the sawmill is just behind the barn. Hey, with the lack of rain this summer, if transportation were not so expensive I'd like to trade lumber with someone who lives "where the hay is." Hay here is 500% what it was this time last winter.

JKJ

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#18

Retail won't float their business

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I predict these startups will discover they have a flawed business model. We sold lumber for 20+ years and quit when our wholesale customers died, went out of business, or became so big they bought from our "more" wholesale sources. Retail customers don't buy very much lumber and there aren't many of them to support a business.

In addition to the question you asked, you also need to ask how much lumber the responders are buying at what ever price they report, as well as grade. This combined data will provide a more complete view of the market. Nobody working 200 bd ft of poplar a year, a piddly amount, is paying $4/bdft for it. Try making an adequate amount of money selling lumber 30 bd ft ( a big retail order) at a time.

The next issue is that these retail customers expect perfect lumber. How do these hobby mills expect to dispose of their less than clear lumber?

There is so little profit in sawing and drying that huge efficient mills are barely hanging on. The only easy money to be made is "stealing" logs from unknowledgable owners and selling the logs to the mills.

When these start-ups have a mountain of unsold #1 common accumulated make them a deal so they can make payments on their mill.

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#19

Bart Goldberg

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

Bart Goldberg

>Tom,

In my area of western/cCentral NJ, I pay $2.00/bdft from my local sawyer for rough sawn, kiln dried hardwood. That includes Walnut, Cherry, Oak and Maple.

Good Luck

Bart

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#20

Don't agree

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There is very little difference in the wholesale price of lumber because shipping is cheap. On the other hand, if you live where the trees are, there are other opportunities besides commercial sources. You can go to a mill and get $1/bdft walnut that for some reason the mill has not sold to some commercial customer at market price for the claimed grade (this sentence was precisely worded). You can find stacks of ungraded lumber in farmer's barns and buy it for what seems like bargain prices compared to commercial produced lumber. You can wonder at the claim that someone is buying lumber at what seems to be far less than market price. In the end, my experience is you get what you pay for relative to market price, which is readily available from numerous sources on a weekly basis.

I spite of my many contacts at mills and endless ads for bargain barn-loft lumber in our papers, I buy my personal lumber from commercial KD sources, or market price from mills.

A warning to bargain hunters. The most money we ever made was on #3 common walnut back when it was popular in the 80's. We had a source of #3 common KD walnut for 20 cents a bdft. We sold it in 500 bd ft bundles for $1.00/bd ft to people that knew walnut was valuable and had no concept of grade. People hired trucks to carry it off and we delivered mountains of it to woodworkers who dreamed of using it someday. Indeed it was a good deal if one was making small trinkets. If you think you are getting a steal from a knowledgeable seller, it is time for a reality check.

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#21

the wood for this table....

Mike Schwing from Maryland

>the wood for this table, including the bookmatched top, came from my $1.50 bf air dried walnut guy. His son is in the clearing business and they saw the logs and dry them in their giant barns. They have an unbelievable amount of lumber and let me pick through it for as long as I care to in order to find the right boards.

A woodworker unskilled in looking for the right lumber might make a good many mistakes in this guy's woodpile, but there are great deals to be had. Yes, there is more waste than if I bought at the retail outlet for $7 bf, but I'm still saving quite a few dollars per foot this way.

There really are deals like this out there. But you can't just pick the first board out of the pile, and you'd damned better let it acclimate in your shop for a few months at least. He doesn't sell a 4/4 board until it has been drying for 2 years, but you still need to be careful.


Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#22

Just want to add one thing.......

Basil

>....to this discussion. ....and just my personal opinion.

When buying roughcut from your local sawyer, always buy at least 1/3 maybe even 1/2 more than you're going to need. Then you might, might, have just enough to do the job.

Using that rule of thumb, then multiply the # of bd.ft. of roughcut you're buying times the price, remembering that you have to mill it up, and see if it's still a bargain. If not, go to your local wood supplier and buy the good stuff that requires less work and equipment to work it up into useable material.

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#23

Re: 2 guys around here w/ similar prices

pecker

>Being from Baltimore, I'd be interested in their names/addresses.

Care to share?

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#24

Re: Retail won't float their business

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Bill,

I totally agree. In the conversations I had with the two local start-up guys neither of them seemed to understand the market. In fact, both appear to have had the idea to do lumber milling, then bought the mills and built the kilns before they ever canvassed the region for business. I would have suggested they do the market research BEFORE investing in the business.

I'd be happy if they figured it all out, got real with the prices and were successful. Then I would have a good local source. But I fear your predictions are correct. In which case I may end up feeling like a vulture, waiting to swoop down for good deals down the road.

Tom

Re: Wood Pricing Survey

#25

Re: One more thing & Tom from St. Louis

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>I want to throw one other thing in here.

Some of us in the west simply cannot locally get - at any price - some of the things you folks east of us have little trouble finding. Wide stock. Figured stock. Some species.

Otten we can get a number of us together to make a sizable purchase (1,000 BDFT or more). Know sawmills that will bundle and ship? And can be trusted to bundle a worthwhile package? I am talking about "shorts" here. Really needing long stock happens less often than we think.

BTW, Tom, I will be in St. Louis in July. If I can carve out some time, perhaps we can get together and I can see what you have?