Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Posts

OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#1

OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I pretty much grew up without TV. Friends had Cable-TV but we never did. 40 years and still don't have it.

We bought a VCR when we got married and watched movies and little TV. When we had children we got a DVD player and pretty much sticked to that. We usually watch a DVD movie once a week, but can't remember the last time we watched TV.... oh, yes, usually the Superbowl.... if the signal isn't too fuzzy.

Well, we replaced our old TV monitor with a 47" LCD 1080p TV, and will continue to watch a DVD each week, plus now also surf the web.

But suddenly thought about TV. Don't alot of TV station broadcast digital signals now? I think it would be better than before right. If it's digital, it's either 100% or 0%, none of the fuzzy signals that helped our decision to not watch TV.

The 47" LCD screen has a built in HDTV tuner. Do I need to get any special antenna? We used to have a $10 pair of rabbit ears that I haven't seen in half a decade. Pehaps the kids used it for sword fighting.

So can I just plug in a coax cable and hold the other end in my hand so to make me the antenna? Used to work fine with the old analog signals. Should I invest $24 in one of those Terk (or similar) indoor HDTV antennas? Or $75 on an outdoor one? Amplified?

I saw a video on the web about a guy who made one with wire clothes hangers. I think I'm beyond that as far as living room decor is concerned, and will fork over $24 for one if they work.

So is this a silly question? Does anyone really get HDTv or digital signals from a antenna anymore?

Thought it would be fun to try and thought I'd ask my friends here what they knew about it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#2

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Mark,

I also grew up without TV. We had one for a while and when it broke my mother refused to have another in the house. These days, I watch about an hour of TV a month if I have time.

My son got a large screen HDTV for his room and until we hooked up to the cable (great internet!), he used a small desktop antenna to pick up HD signals. All of the local stations broadcast HD over the air. This worked pretty well and the picture was great. When the signal did drop out, it was as you guessed - the picture was not fuzzy but instead blocky/frozen/gone. We do live on the top of a hill and the TV antennas are only 25 miles or so away so our signal may have been better than usual. I have a friend who lives back in a hollow and he uses an antenna for his HD, but he put an outside antenna with a rotor on a pole.

I think he got a special antenna but it was real cheap. Me, I'd try the making a dipole from two wires first.

JKJ

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#3

Lee Gordon

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna? *LINK*

Lee Gordon

>If the local stations in your area are broadcasting a digital signal (most are), you should be able to pick them up over the air via an antenna. The good news is you don't need a special HD antenna. Any antenna capable of picking up a standard TV signal should be able to pick up a digital signal just as well.

One caveat: the channel numbers you are used to do not necessarily correspond to the actual frequency the station is broadcasting on, so a VHF antenna that currently picks up channels 2-13 or a UHF antenna that currently gets channels 14-72 may or may not be the appropriate device to pick up the station you are trying to tune in.

You can get some of the necessary information by going to the link below and plugging in the pertinent information for your locale.


Antenna Web

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#4

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna? *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Mark - In fact, off the air can provide some of the highest definition programming available. Here's a good, brief article on the subject. As Lee mentioned, antenna web is great. Remember though your home's actual reception can be greatly effected by things like high nearby trees.

The Channel Master CM 4228 8-Bay Bowtie UHF Antenna is a very good choice for many locations: http://www.solidsignal.com/prod_display.asp?CAT=&PROD=ANC4228&xfermeth=directg&gclid=CK_flaHv640CFQXUhgodKnkXwA

Dan


Antenna info

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#5

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Tom

>We gave up on cable about 10 years ago. I just use the antenna I put in the attic at that point. It works fine. You might find some of your local stations broadcast substations that you may not have known about too. The Terk Silver Sensor is a decent $20 indoor antenna. I think I'd stay away from amplifiers though, at first at least. As suggested, go to antennaweb and see what type of antenna is recommended and what direction to aim it. That's the first step.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#6

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Ray, SW Ohio

>Most cable companies send the digital signal thru the cable. Why would you want to get a antenna?

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#7

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Dan Donaldson

>If you don't have cable, it is hard to receive the signal ;-)

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#8

why get an antenna

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Most cable companies send the digital signal

>thru the cable. Why would you want to get a antenna?

Why pay the high cost of cable TV if it would only be used rarely? If my sweetheart didn't watch it, I certainly wouldn't have it in the house.

Also, cable is not available in many locations even for people who want it. My friend who lives 1/2 mile from the road is limited to satellite or local antenna.

I tried for several years to get cable to replace my satellite internet connection. Finally, the cable company upgraded their system and the signal was strong enough to work (and ran an underground cable 600+ to my house for no charge).

JKJ

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#9

I'm on an antenna

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your story replicates mine almost exactly, except we are in the shadow of a ridge and get poor signals. So to get any TV we needed the best antenna that money could buy. So, what antenna you need depends on where you are relative to the transmitters.

We almost never watch the garbage on the network channels but the PBS channels have some interesting stuff like Antique Road show and some movies without interruption by commercials every 5 min. I presume you have NetFicks. Wonderful product.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#10

Cable companies screw up the signal

wilbur

>One other reason to go with an antenna rather than the cable companies is that the cable companies often compress the video signal in order to be able to push more channels through their cable lines, leading to a poorer quality picture than you would get with the uncompressed broadcast signal.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#11

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

wilbur

>My parents get HDTV through a regular antenna. It's true that you don't need a special HDTV antenna to get a digital signal, but your results will be better if you have one. In my parent's case, the antenna can deliver an HDTV signal to their upstairs TV, but by the time the signal runs through the extra cabling to the downstairs TV, it's gone, so the downstairs TV only gets the regular broadcast signal.

As far as antenna size, indoor vs. outdoor, and amplification, the best option is to go with a big outdoor antenna. Like bandsaws, bigger is better when it comes to antennas. An amplified antenna that pulls in a poor quality signal will only give you an amplified poor quality signal.

Of course, how big is big enough depends on how far away you are from the broadcast sources, the quality of the broadcast, trees/hills in your area, the height of the antenna, and so on. Whether you want a big antenna on the roof of your house also comes into play.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#12

No need for a special antenna for HD...LONG

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I'm getting HD in my garage shop (which BTW serves as my personal family room), I have antenna for normal analog TV and also am on DirectTV. Here's what I've discovered:

Almost all local HD signals are broadcast in the UHF frequency band. Which means you only need a little UHF antanna. Try hooking up and holding the little bow-tie or circle antenna that came with your old TV and see how good your reception is. You need to point it in the right direcion.

In the Chicago area, all local channels now broadcast at least one HD channel (some have three or four) and only one network broadcasts HD in the VHF band, so I need a VHF antenna connection for that one station. I simply took an old cheapo TV antenna and cut off the VHF elements (those are the wide long elements at the back of the antenna). That left me with a short V-shaped UHF segment which is the part at the front of the antenna. I mounted it in the garage attic and I get all the HD channels perfectly (except channel 2, which I use an antenna switcher for). I live over 30 miles from the broadcast antennas.

The only reason you would buy an expensive digital HD antenna is to reward an antenna company for spreading false advertising info about antennas.

All my TVs in the house are analog so I have a large antenna in the house attic for that. I have DirecTV in both the house and the garage (separate receivers). I have not made the jump to HD DirectTV (due to cost), but I'm getting close. I can watch Satellite on any TV in the house. I got a Channel-Plus modulator which converts the satellite signal to an unused UHF frequency and reinjects it into the antenna lead-in. I simply tune any TV to channel 55 and I can watch whatever is on the satellite receiver in the family room. I have a wireless remote so I can change the satellite channel from any room in the house too. This is primarily for my wife so she can watch the financial market bradcasts all day no mater where she is in the house. Stock market is one of her hobbies.

Bottom line, you don't need a special antenna for local HD channels. Any decent UHF antenna, even a little set-top bow tie thingy will work just fine. At least that's been my experience. Once you've watched HD for a while, you'll not want to go back to analog.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#13

Hey Mark ...

Mike Farinella

>40 years without a TV? Guess what, you didn't miss a thing!

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#14

Just remember this…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Antennas are related to frequency. They don't give a hoot what modulation or content is received.

The usual TV antenna that you used to see on roofs everywhere is a type known as a log periodic dipole array (LPDA—often just called a log periodic). What it's really good for is to be effective over a wide range of frequencies. In fact, they act as passive amplifiers—that is, they exhibit gain over that range of frequencies. Probably something on the order of 4-5 dB (roughly 3X). Given that the old TV channels (2-13) covered frequencies from 55 MHz to 211 MHz (with gaps for other service allocations and called VHF or very high frequency), an LPDA is a really good application. If the antenna dated from the '50s (and by now is virtually worthless) it was designed (that is, sized) solely for those channels.

Channels 14 and above (commonly in use by the '60s) were in an entirely different region of the spectrum—from 470 MHz to over 800 MHZ, and called UHF, for ultra high frequency (and also with gaps for other allocations)—again, a good application for an LPDA, which is what the 3 or 4" long elements at the front of the antenna were for. In fact, the typical TV antenna is really two antennas—the one cut for VHF and the other cut for UHF. Here's an interesting website for learning about TV spectrum allocations and channel numbers.

Now, having said all that, it doesn't matter what the signal carries—AM, FM, TV, SSB, RTTY, FAX, analog, digital, HD, etc.—the antenna happily carries the intelligence to the receiver where it's all sorted out, as appropriate. If in fact the interim digital channels are all in the UHF range, the UHF part of an old antenna is all you need, and you don't care what the channel numbers actually are—the antenna is sufficiently broad banded to provide at least some signal to your TV (providing you're in a location disposed to reasonable reception in the first place).

Note also that most antennas with gain are directional—that's essentially how they work—they rob Peter to pay Paul, so to speak. The more gain, then narrower the beam width, and thus the fussier to point. But all that is another post.

Rod

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#15

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Mark, the requirements for the antenna to receive a decent signal are defined by (1) The distance from the broadcast stations you want to receive, & (2) The power the broadcast station is using to transmit the signal, & (3) Your site location IE: If you are on a hill with no major industry or other entity producing a lot of emf (like an electrical substation etc.) VS being down in a valley surrounded by High Tension electrical lines. If you don't have the answers to these questions (and I doubt if you do), I would look in the yellow pages, find a LOCAL antenna supplier and talk to them. Might even get some decent advice from a Radio Shack. Antenna do work well for HGTV if the stations are reasonably close and you don't have a lot of interference. I personally have Cable, but have one friend that has a small "top of tv" antenna receiving a pretty good signal from about 25 -30 mile away. As others have stated, the current frequencies do require a "new" antenna design for good reception.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#16

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

Tony - Memphis

>I'm a non-cable guy too. Before we upgraded our old tv last year(1989 26"), I had installed two of the regular old fashioned antennas I bought from Lowe's in the attic (originally for the old tv's). They get the local digital channels really well. Never had an issue. The picture is really nice and no ghosting, etc. Lowe's had those antennas on clearance - I got mine for $20 or so.

Tony

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#17

Re: No need for a special antenna for HD...LONG

David Hay @ Denver

>Tim covered just about everything I was going to say. One thing to keep in mind, however, is that when the analog signals shut off next February (2009), some channels that are currently in the UHF band will be moving back to their original analog spot in the VHF band. That is, digital channel 7.1 might be broadcasting on channel 55 now, but will go back to channel 7 next year.

David

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You sure about that?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>As I understand it (and I have a friend who is a TV News Director), the VHF channels are the ones going away, so any station currently broadcasting on a VHF channel (2-13) will get reassigned (if they aren't already dual-broadcasting) one in the UHF range (14-??).

Jason

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#19

Re: I'm on an antenna

Frank Orfanello

>Bill,

While I have cable, we also subscribe to Netflix. It's probably one of the best services I've ever seen. I send a movie back on Monday and have a new one back on Wed.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#20

Lee Gordon

Re: You sure about that?

Lee Gordon

>Your friend is not entirely correct. After TV switches over to all digital in the US in 2009, the UHF channels from 52 to 69 will be going away. There are also plans to eventually eliminate VHF channels 2 through 6. But 7 through 13 are not going anywhere and will continue to be used.

Keep in mind, that digital TV's have the capability to "re-map" channels so existing TV stations do not have to engage in costly re-branding in order for people to be able to find them. So, for example, in my area, the station that is currently on VHF channel 3 and is known to the viewers around here as "Channel 3" broadcasts their HD signal on UHF channel 33 and will keep that channel after the changeover, but it will display on digital TVs as channel 3 or 3-1 depending on how the TV is set up.

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#21

Re: You sure about that?

David Hay @ Denver

>Here's where I read about this:

http://www.highdefforum.com/showthread.php?t=60422

It references an FCC document that has the complete channel assignments for the digital switch next year.

http://fjallfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-07-138A2.pdf

David

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

My mistake...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I 'member now. 2-6 go bye-bye, but I was unaware of the higher end of the UHF channels going away as well. I was also aware of the re-mapping, as our only local station is channel 18, but their digital broadcast is on channel 11, I think. It wasn't so much that she gave me details of the switch, just that it is a big headache for their engineering guys (and gals, if applicable).

David, my apologies, but if you look through that doc you linked, you'll see that under the NTSC heading of the table are the current station numbers, then immediately to the right of that are the new station numbers under DTV (digital TV, should probably be "ATSC", as that is what the digital tuner standard is in the U.S.).

I'm kind of bummed, because I had a decent "omni-directional" antenna a few years back, but I junked it once I got cable. I didn't get HD for a couple years, so now I wish I had that antenna again, just to check out the OTA stuff once in a while, since the HD offerings on my Insight (morphing to Comcast) cable are pretty meager.

Jason

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#23

I'm weird

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I grew up without a TV. My Dad had cable so we watched TV a bit when we visted him as a kid, but never had cable at home.

When I was 19 I bought a VCR and hooked it up to my 12" computer monitor to watch movies and a little TV. When we got married we continued to use that. When we had kids we upgraded to a DVD player and 32" TV. Just recently got a LCD TV, but still no cable.

Entertaiment comes via "movie night" where we sit down to wtch a DVD movie. We only watch TV a couple of times a year. Superbowl Sundays and Weather watch during Tornado season. That's about it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#24

Re: I'm weird

Dan Donaldson

>Not too weird. I discontinued cable a couple of years ago because it was causing too much contention with the kids and there was almost nothing worth watching. I have a tv that is hooked up to watch DVD's and tapes, but nothing else. We don't miss it a bit. I do still have the high speed cable connection for the computer though ;-)

Re: OT - Anyone using HDTV antenna?

#25

Re: I'm weird

Mark Williamson

>Netflix is a wonderful thing!!! I love it! I didn't have cable for three years and loved it. I bought my house and the cable company never turned the old peoples service off! I think I watch it just to get over on them now, but I really could go without it! Besides, it takes up valuable turning time! LOL

Mark