Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Soft vs Hard Maple questions

Posts

Soft vs Hard Maple questions

#1

Soft vs Hard Maple questions

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I was just asked if I wanted to take some maple logs. The owner thinks it is a sugar maple (hard), but it may be a silver maple (soft). I did a little digging, and other than seeing one called hard and the other soft, both seem to have pretty good characteristics. Is there really much of a difference in useability between hard and soft maple? Or is this of the "soft maple is still pretty hard, just not as hard as hard maple kinda thing"?

I might finally have some maple on the drying stack soon, though. My oak is nice and dry, some walnut is only a few months into drying and it wouldn't mind some more company. Gotta keep my local sawyers in business!

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

#2

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You're saw (carbide-tipped blade) won't care [although the more sugar the faster the feed rate to keep from burning], but your jointer and other tools may prefer the silver. Harder yet will be Norway Maple which has a nicely pale ground color and some figure but is like rock when dry.

mm

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

#3

hard, soft and softer

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Commercial "soft maple" comes from red maple trees. It is a very nice wood to work, but a bit plain. As far as I know silver maple is not a commercial species. It seemed to me to be softer still when I have cut trees down.

It is very easy to tell the difference from the bark or leaf.

How hard hard maple is, depends on its growing conditions.

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

#4

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

Hank Knight

>Stephen,

I've used hard maple for lots of things and I like working with it. I'm building my first project with soft maple and I've found that I like it too. It's noticeably softer than hard maple, but plenty hard for furniture. It falls somewhere between hard maple and poplar; it's not as soft as poplar by a long shot. It works nicely with both hand and machine tools and it holds detail well. It may well become my secondary wood of choice for drawer sides and such, and some of it looks nice enough for primary use.

My $.02

Hank

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

#5

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>Where I have a challenge is in the color. Doing a kitchen for my daughter in law, I have a wide mix from having purchased various pieces over the months. If you get yours from one tree, you should be all right. In our setup, I can mix in some prefinished maple ply, and some prefinished birch ply, and get away with it.

The red maple does have a sort of pink hue to it, but it's only noticeable when next to other species. Out here in the West, we have Big leaf maple too, a soft maple, with a fair amount of figure.

Have fun with your find!

Re: Soft vs Hard Maple questions

#6

Thanks everyone

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I'm going to take a look at the tree and make sure it's suitable for lumber (not too many branches, burls, embedded bicycles, etc). If it's good, it's going on the drying stack, after a trip through the sawyer.