Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

What's the walnut worth?

Posts

What's the walnut worth?

#1

What's the walnut worth?

Brent

>There's a guy who has (4) pieces of walnut 4"x12"x8' "fresh off the wood-mizer" as he put it. He's asking $200 each. He's close by (about 45 minutes) so no shipping costs. If I'm right, that works out to $8+ a BF. How's that sound price wise? 16/4 stock is tough to find around here, and I want if for either a mantle or turning stock.

Opinions please--

Thanks,

Brent

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#2

That depends

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Kiln-dried 4" walnut ranges from $9-14 here, depending on the quantity purchased. If you plan to use the 4" thickness, your wood will have to air-dry for at least 4 years. So, it's a bargain at $8, provided you can wait; it's not such a bargain if you pay to have it kiln-dried.

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#3

Re: What's the walnut worth?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Brent,

The way I figure it, you are talking 32 bd ft per cant which works out to $6.25/bd ft. However, you are talking green wood. By the time you get it dry, you may have much less than 32 bd ft/cant that is usable in the 4"x12" dimensions. Plus, as was mentioned, you have an investment of time and labor to get it to a useable moisture content.

Unfortunately, I think a lot of people overvalue their green lumber, especially walnut and cherry. One reason kiln-dried wood is more expensive is because of the drying costs, including degrade. Just be aware that it would be a much better deal if it was $6.25/bd ft in the dry state.

Gary

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#4

Lee Grindinger

Compare

Lee Grindinger

>Go to Woodfinder and find 16/4 walnut and compare pricing. Make sure you're comparing ungraded to ungraded or that you're compensating for the fact that the deal you're talking about is ungraded and undried. Drying 16/4 walnut is worth quite a lot, perhaps a buck a board foot in that thickness. Grading could be worth several bucks a foot depending on the differences between your deal and FAS. You haven't seen this guy's lumber and my experience has taught me that untrained eyes see about 10% of the defects in green lumber, it all looks delicious when green but is full of knots, squirrelly grain and sapwwod once dry.

I'll guess you can get 16/4 FAS for around eight bucks a foot which would make your deal pretty lousy.

I used to buy mill run (ungraded) green walnut for around a buck a foot. The fact that it's four inches thick means little until after it's dried.

Frankly, I'll bet you'll do better through Goff and Goff or someone selling leg blanks in that thickness. Check around.

Lee

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: What's the walnut worth?

Dale Lenz

>Around here, it's too much $, at least for me. I'd get it at less than $1 per board foot, at least in the past, max would be $.80/bd.ft. green, rough sawn and #1C & Btr. I'd pass for sure if it had the pith, center of the tree in the cants, or plan on resawing before putting it up to dry.

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#6

Re: What's the walnut worth?

Brent

>Thanks guys - I knew there were a lot of people who knew more about it than me.

Brent

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#7

Air dry and usable in 4 years ???

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>The standard air drying "rule of thumb" of 1" per year is simply not true.

I have no idea where this idealogy came from, but for most species the actual timeframe is around half that ....(depending on drying location and time of the year its stacked and stickered).

Alot of species can be air dried to around 12-15% in several weeks to a few months.

I'm guessing this 1" rule of thumb is more for us northerners, where winter drying is practically nill. Ive experienced it personally and know this to be true.

Re: What's the walnut worth?

#8

Re: Air dry and usable in 4 years ???

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Another factor in air drying is that the thickness vs drying time is not linear. A two inch thick piece will not dry in twice the time a one inch does. I have measured the MC with my meter - two inch takes 3 to 4 times as long. I would guess the 4 years is probably not too far out of line - though may not really be long enough - dependent on the storage conditions. I have some rough sawn 2 ~ 3" thick X 18" 24" wide X 4' ~ 6' walnut slabs, stickered in the wood storage area above my shop. (I paid $5 ~ $10 for each at an auction a couple years ago), I don't expect to be able to use them for at least another year or two. Here in Central Indiana, I would not pay more than $1 a BF for (top grade) green Walnut. I probably have an average of $.30 ~ $.40 in my walnut stash (400 ~ 500 BF) some of which I bought already air dried. I purchase 80 ~ 90% of my wood at estate auctions, mostly from Amish / Mennonite / German Baptist families. Many of these groups make there own building & furniture, several have sawmills. I doubt I have $.35 a bf average in all my wood. The woods I have are Cherry (some pretty highly figured), White oak, Walnut, maple, Popular and some small odd lots of Hackberry, Sassafras, locust, cottonwood & basswood. Most had been air dried to less than 15% MC.