Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Stair Rail Finishing

Posts

Stair Rail Finishing

#1

Stair Rail Finishing

Richard Freeman

>I recently installed a J. Smith custom red oak rail system and before I do the final finishing wanted to ask for advice. Before cutting and installing I put a Minwax cherry stain on the pieces. Then I coated each with a single coat of Guardsman urethane semi-gloss. The system is now installed and came out well. Now is the time to do the final finishing, but I am concerned that I will not end up with the hand rubbed smooth finish feel I am looking for if I continue with Guardsman.

A friend of mine tuned me on to this site and had suggested Arm-R-Seal as a top coat. Ideas of how to best proceed are welcome.

Re: Stair Rail Finishing

#2

Re: Stair Rail Finishing

Steve Schoene

>I don't know the Guardsman Urethane. (I've only seen their finish repair supplies, if I'm thinking of the right company.) But I don't quite see how you can expect much different outcome from using one brand of polyurethane varnish compared to another.

Polyurethane varnish wouldn't be my choice for stair rails. I'm just about done finishing some mahogany rails in my new home, and I'm going with a dark shellac with a bit of gell stain as a glaze to give a more antique look. Shellac is faster, I think easier to apply, and rubs out to whatever sheen you want. I also like the feel under hand.

It's also easier to repair if you have cavalry officers riding their horses up the stairs, slashing the railings with their sabers. (Translate to twelve year olds getting rowdy.)

Re: Stair Rail Finishing

#3

two choices

Michael Dresdner

>The Guardsman is fine. That's one of the RPM brands. I would simply apply it by hand with nylon abrasive pads and then wipe off evenly. Wiping applies very thin coats and will keep that low, close to the wood look. You could also switch to Watco Wipe-on Poly, which incidentally, is also an RPM brand, or for that matter, use Bartley or Lawrence MacFadden clear polyurethane gel. All are compatible, and any of them are easy to apply and will allow you to stop wherever you want and maintain the look you want.