Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

Posts

Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#1

Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

Todd Nebel

>Why is the tung oil not drying? I started with a water based dye followed with a single coat of minwax stain. I let the stain dry for 24 hours. I then put on a coat of 100% tung oil. I let it sit for 10 minutes and removed the excess. It has been sitting for 3 days and the tung oil is still not dry. Why? And what can I do now?

Kind regards,

Todd

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#2

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

r payne

>I've never used tung oil but regularly use linseed oil (raw and boiled). With linseed oil, curing (drying) is temperature and humidity dependant and the colder it is the longer it takes to dry.

Did you look on the can to see how long it should take and if it takes longer under some condidions?

ron

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#3

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Was it down with naptha to get rid of as much stuff as you can. Let it dry for a couple days in a warm place. Re-stain with an oil based stain. Let it dry for a couple days in a warm place. Wipe or brush on an oil based poly or alkyd varnish thinned with naptha. Let it dry for a couple days in a warm place. Recoat for desired build. When it's well cured, rub out with 0000 steel wool and Butcher's Wax.

Clint

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#4

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

john l. blue

>Hope the other posts solve your problem, but can you tell me

where you get that 100% Tung Oil? Blue

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#5

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Pure tung oil will take a week or two to dry, and a month or so to actually cure. Which is why it's rarely used as a finish.

Stripping it off with a solvent will remove it from the surface and if you're pretty sure the stain was set before the tung oil was applied you'll probably be OK with applying another top coat. But if you think the tung oil actually penetrated, you may want to let it set for at least a week after cleaning the stuff off the surface before you apply something else.

Tung oil finish has driers (and other stuff) in it and it will set in an hour or two and polymerize in a day or two. You can also add japan drier to the tung oil you have to get a similar effect, but the ratio can be a bit of black magic.

Rob

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#6

couple things

David Yoho

>Rob's reply was good advice. In addition, the Minwax stain probably sealed the surface ever so slightly (this is a good thing). Another good thing is you say you wiped away the excess tung oil. Just for your own reference, read the container and see if your tung oil contains any dryers. Yours may or may not have some and will determine, along with temperature, how long it will take to dry.

If you're in a hurry and need to get this finish done, you might want to scrub the surface with a solvent like naptha or acetone, which evaporate quick, to remove the tung oil you applied. After that, check your color and do what you need to get that correct.

After giving this some time to dry, you might try coming back with several coats of Waterlox, which is tung oil based and will give you a close to the wood look if applied right. Apply the first coat of Waterlox with a brush and wipe it back off with a cloth. After dry, come back and wipe on and off as many more coats as you find necessary.

David

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#7

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

Todd Nebel

>Woodcraft. There is a store near me (Allentown PA)

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#8

The bottle says dry time 2-3 hours

Todd Nebel

>

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#9

The culprit is the stain

Michael Dresdner

>Minwax stain is rather notorious for causing drying problems in coatings above it, and tends to be one of the slower drying stains on the martket. I get dozens of questions regarding problems with coatings drying over what I would call only partially cured Minwax stain. Please remember that drying times printed on cans are minimum times, not maximum. It is in fact fairly rare that things actually dry as quickly as they say, since heavier application, higher humidity and cooler temperatures than what is considered ideal will all vastly increase drying time. In this particular case, some residual solvent in the stain has no doubt now migrated into the tung oil.

Beyond that, I rather agree with a lot of the other comments about tung oil. It's great for coating cast iron for shipping overseas, but pure tung oil as a wood finish leaves a lot to be desired.

Purity, while it sounds good, is not always an advantage. I wonder, for example, how many folks would enjoy pie made from pure rhubarb with no sweetener added.

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#10

Hijack here

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>While I've never used pure tung oil, I've used the polymerized one and have been quite happy with the results. What's your opinion of the stuff?

Thnx,

DC

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#11

Hijack response

Michael Dresdner

>I'm sorry, but that's a bit too general a question to answer very directly. Allow me to explain why.

All oil varnishes and oil polyurethanes are essentially modified oils, as is polymerized (or more accurately, partially polymerized) tung oil. The process converts some or all of the oil molecules into resins. Needless to say, these materials run the gamut in terms of durability, user friendliness, drying time, and so on. For me to comment I would have to know exactly what you are using.

I will say that modifications of 'raw' materials are typically done in order to make them 'better' -- that is, more durable, faster drying, quicker building, and so on. Assuming it was done correctly, it certainly would not surprise me one bit that your modifed tung oil is better in many respects than pure raw tung oil.

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#12

This is what I've used

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=20050&cat=1,190,42942

It applies easily, wears well. If someone leaves a leaking flower pot on the surface it will not protect against that (DAMHIKT), but otherwise it is quite resistant. I've used it on a maple hall table, after more than 10 years the finish is in quite good shape (except for THAT spot).

DC

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#13

Re: couple things

Howard Acheson

>>> Minwax stain probably sealed the surface ever so slightly

Actually it would have sealed surface completely. Minwax stains contain varnish (resin) to adhere the pigments to the surface of the wood. Between the oil and the varnish, it pretty well seals the surface. As they say on the can: "Penetrates, Stains and Seals".

Re: Why is the Tung Oil not drying?

#14

Re: couple things

David Yoho

>Thanks, Howard. I wasn't sure how to state just how much the wood would've been sealed based on whether it was wiped or brushed. My main thought was that if the wood did get sealed, the oil probably didn't go in as deep and would be easier to remove if necessary.

David