Helping Home Depot learn - kinda
Robert W - aka nailshooter
>Thinking about a recent thread, I decided to post my method to help Home Depot "learn" about commercial accounts. This incident provided me with not only a way to protect my account, but to get off some of the steam they were directly responsible for in dealing with them. Hey... if they can't take a joke...
A couple of years ago HD didn't ask for ANY ID on a commercial account charge if they went to the "pro" desk (This is easily found by the number of folks sleeping on the counter or making personal calls.) Literally, they asked for nothing, not even a commercial card if you knew the exact account name and were on the "approved charge" list for that account.
I had a not too pleasant experience when one of my employees left, and he kept the HD charge card along with everything else when he left. Knowing that they didn't check ID, he went in and charged a few small items, probably thinking that I wouldn't notice. When I approached HD about this, they said (since no ID was involved) they couldn't prove to their satisfaction that it was even him that did it.
We had a great, long fight with me being the loser as all it did was make me madder and madder. And HD told me, well, that's our policy, and until it changes, there isn't anything we can do. They too him off the approved charge list, but then after thinking it through it came to me that without an ID check anyone could go up and tell them they were ME and charge on my acct. I was up against it as I buy odds and ends all over town as needed and HD is my "hardware" store.
So... I started signing my receipts "Woody Woodpecker". I signed a lot of them that way. I paid the first months's bill with the WW signed receipts to build a record of it. I called HD the moment I got the second bill and asked them to verify the signatures on the receipts.
It was hilarious. It is a crying shame I didn't record the conversation.
"Well, sir, we have a signed receipt right here that says "Woody" somebody signed for these items."
I look at the photocopy of the receipt. "Is that last name Woodpecker?", I asked.
"Well, it looks like it. Are you saying you don't have a "Woodpecker" that works for you?"
"Nope", I say. Nor anyone named "Woody" I assure her.
"Well, has there been a Woody Woodpecker that worked for you recently?"
I thought I would collapse. "Noo.. hey wait... do you think that's THE Woody Woodpecker?"
"I'm sorry sir, I don't know who that is."
I actually had to go up the ladder two supervisors (and three decades of age) before one of them got the reference. So I asked her, "if this was YOUR Visa card, and someone signed the name of a cartoon character and charged $900 worth of goods, would you feel like you should pay it?"
We talked twice a day off and on for a week through all the different channels of HD credit, their procedure guys, their security guys, their account reps, their internal security, you name it. They told me that NO MATTER what happened, I should pay for the charges in question as someone had used my account without my permission, so that meant that >> I << should go after this "Mr. Woodpecker" for the money, not them. Since they only sent memos to each other and didn't actually look into things, apparently no one else caught the reference to Mssr. Woodpecker.
Their continued insistence that I pay the bill was due largely based on the fact that I paid it a month before and didn't say anything. That's it. If it slipped by once, it had to be OK. I told them I would be glad to take their information as well as their evidence of Mr. Woodpecker's work to our State Attorney General and see who he thought should pay for the charges. Then, I told them I would be glad to report them to the SAG in their home state as well. I just never have like being bullied by anyone.
Finally, they decided two things. First, they would put a tag on my account that specifically says: "No charges allowed without proper photo ID" and "all charges over $250 to be verified with owner through the pro desk". The second thing was that although they didn't think they should (which by law, they did) they told me they would take the charges off my account.
Now I had what I wanted. A verified ID at the time of a charge on my commercial account. No need to take the other charges off, I tell them. I revealed the actual identity of Mr. Woodpecker. I always pay MY bills.
Man alive were they pissed off. I was delighted. "Are you getting a feeling of what I went through? Are you just as frustrated as you are mad? Do you see how pointless this was? A simple check for ID would have prevented all those charges."
Still pissed. They had two different people call me and talk to me about fraud, etc. No fraud, says I. The check was in the mail. If you suffer no loss and cannot prove intent to gain, there is no fraud.
The last call I got was a head of one of their security sections. He actually thought it was kinda funny. He asked me two or three times "and they NEVER asked for any ID, even when you signed Wood Woodpecker?" He told me they were in the midst of "revamping" their system, and he was completely positive that my/their situation would come up when setting out new guidelines.
As for me, my driver's license is checked every single time I go in to charge at a register now and so is my foreman's. So in the end, I got what I wanted so I'm a happy guy.
But you know, it never fails, when I am at the register (not the pro desk) and someone shows a commercial card, they cashier asks them "are you so and so?" and all the guy has to do is nod.
So I guess in the end they can learn, but they are certainly slow learners.
Robert



