Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT Home Security

Posts

OT Home Security

#1

OT Home Security

mdclor

>We have almost completed our new house. Unfortunately, there have been 2 burglaries in the neighborhood and a third aborted attempt. We have a dog, but he is not at all guardy so I am looking to the knowledge base here to point me toward a good technological solution.

Since we didn't wire the house for security solutions, I think I will have to use something like X10, Z-Wave, Insteon or something else I haven't found yet.

My questions are:

1. Does anyone have any suggestions?

2. Is there a good source for unbiased information?

3. Should I just get a guard dog to keep the current dog company?

4. How crazy should I get? Video cameras? Remote video storage? etc?

Thanks in advance for your input,

Merle

Re: OT Home Security

#2

Re: OT Home Security

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I wired a house for an alarm system 50 years after it was built and it wasn't too hard. I fished wires through walls the way electricians do it. I stuck to door alarms and internal motion detectors (no inside dog to set them off.)

I also had several outside cameras, one of which was active and fed a monitor in my office, no video storage. Cameras themselves, especially those with blinking red lights, may keep away some dirtbags. Relatively inexpensive 4-camera systems with recorder are available.

I think x-10 stuff is junk, don't know about the others. A good electronics supplier will have quality and perhaps even an experienced advisor.

"Protected by xxx alarm systems" signs seem popular.

Re: OT Home Security

#3

Re: OT Home Security

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>You have a lot of wireless options so not having prewired the house is not a problem. Invite a few salespeople in to have them try to sell you a security system. This will give you a real good idea of what is available and different ways to approach securing your house. Remember anything they can sell you you can buy somewhere and install yourself if you are so inclined.

Home security starts with your landscaping and fencing. Don't make it easy for someone to sneak up on your house. Next is lighting. Then the locks on your doors and windows. They need to look secure as well as actually being secure. Remember deterrent is the key. This is why when the security system is installed you want a sign or decals to announce it. You also will test it so the neighborhood knows what it sounds like but not so often that they hate you.

As to the electronics themselves. Only do as much as needed. Be sure that you can turn it on while in the house and your dog does not set it off. It must be simple to use but not simple to defeat.

The primary purpose of a home security system is to protect you and your family, then you stuff. It is not to catch the thief! But you can do something about that if you wish. Most systems will have the ability to turn on something (dry contacts) like a video tape recorder. The X10 system or another can be tied into the recorder and when activated record what was happening when the alarm goes off.

Smoke detectors can be part of the system too along with a whole lot of stuff. Let the salespeople educate you and then decide for your self what you need and want. If you decide to let someone else do it specify your needs and take bids. If you decide to do it your self buy real equipment and not the stuff available at the Borg, RS or HF.

Have fun with the project.

Bill

Re: OT Home Security

#4

Re: OT Home Security

Gene Gauss

>I contracted with a security company to recommend the various sensors, their locations, and the technology to be used. After discussions and some give and take, they installed three area motion detectors that cover the major areas downstairs including all of the crossroads in the house, monitored all doors, installed two smoke detectors, one on each floor, and a heat detector in the furnace room. None of the wiring is exposed in the living areas. They snaked it through walls for the most part, but in one case use a radio communication between a second floor smoke detector and the control station. We didn't monitor windows (prohibitive cost for the large number of windows, relying on the motion detectors instead. The installation cost a little over $600, and there's a $20 per month monitoring charge. (If an alarm occurs and a person answering the phone can't give the correct name and password, or no one answers, they notify the police or fire department as appropriate.) In the past five or so years since I had it installed, one prospective intruder was frightened off by the alarm sounding in the house when he/they tried to jimmy one of the alarmed doors. By the time the police arrived, the intruder was long gone. Cheap at twice the price. There've been a couple of false alarms that resulted in the correct responses - they served as inadvertant tests of the system.

Re: OT Home Security

#5

Re: OT Home Security

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet,TN)

>Alarm companies will wire you house and you will not be able to see how they did it. I had my house in Plantation, FL wired after I purchased it and they did a fantastic job. All security situation are different so get bids from several alarm companys.

Re: OT Home Security

#6

Re: OT Home Security

Ron Hildreth

>Merle,

Not sure if I can help you pick a good security system, but just had to tell you that dogs aren't always what they seem to be, either. Case in point - is my beloved Labrador I just lost. I bought her in hopes of at least making a little noise if someone broke in, hopefully scaring them off. HA! I really think she would have held the door open for them so they could make several trips to the their truck with my power tools! Loved her and still miss her sorely, but a guard dog she was not!

Ron in Iowa

Re: OT Home Security

#7

Re: OT Home Security

Brian Aust - Nevada, IA

>If you are technically inclined, install your own alarm - wired, wireless, combination, check the link. You can also set up monitoring for $10/month. I am putting mine in as I remodel room by room, the programming takes a little practice but not too bad.

Re: OT Home Security

#8

Re: OT Home Security

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Merle,

A lot of security companies are using wireless systems these days. This means no wiring to the sensors. It is a lot easier to put them in, but I have reservations about them. It would not take too sophisticated of a thief to make a jamming device to interrupt the signals between the sensors and the controllers. If the system itself was not designed correctly, this would render the entire system useless. Just make sure you ask if the system is wireless and ask what would happen if the controller suddenly lost communication with all other sensors due to excessive noise. Does it sit and do nothing or does it notify the company somehow, and then what is their policy on handling the notification.

Judge yourself from the answers they give, but I would insist on a wired system, and whatever you do, do not put the controller in the foyer closet. According to the "It Takes A Thief" television show, all burglers know to look there for the control unit. Hide that thing somewhere else.

Finally, they say on the above mentioned show, the best thing you can do is provide visibility around the house and have plenty of light at night. Do not provide the bad guys any place to hide and take time to get them into the house.

Ok, I am a way too paranoid electrical engineer who sits around and thinks too much. Not only that, but I watch too many of those shows on television.

Hope this helps,

Rob Hix

Re: OT Home Security

#9

Re: OT Home Security

mdclor

>Thanks to everyone for your input. You always have valuable info. I will contact the local security companies as suggested. I had just thought I would do it myself, but it can't hurt to learn from those in the industry. I am inclined to agree with Bill, that my border collie would help any thieves...probably round up the valuables for them.

Merle

Re: OT Home Security

#10

Re: OT Home Security

Sam Layton

>It is important that you protect your family, and your house before something happens. A lot of peopel think security after the fact. A hard wire system is best, and can be done. Go to www.homesecuritystore.com there is a security fourm that will give you a lot of info on security alarms. They can also help you decide on a good company if you do not want to DIY.

Sam

Re: OT Home Security

#11

Our home had an ADT system installed when

henthorn

>constructed. We are seldom gone and I and my wife are usually close to arms and good shots. I never had the system activated after we bought the house from the previous owners. The darn thing is always beeping. I can turn it off but it only stays off a few hours at most. I can't hear the beeping but it drives my wife nuts. I could disconnect the box where it is plugged into power in an upstairs closet, but I know the fire alarms are all hardwired into the system and I don't want to disable them. Hope to be selling the house soon and will tell the new owners they have a problem. Of course they may want to reactivate the system.