Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Posts

New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#1

New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector I attended some training the other night on Water heaters and gas piping.

The fellow offering us the training was a proponent of Bradford White Heaters based on the fact that they do not sell them Retail through the big box stores or otherwise and that they are all professionally installed by plumbers. His company also sells a Re-branded tankless heater someone makes for them.

The topic of tankless heaters has come up here several times so I thought I would share what I thought was an interesting piece of info.

He said that the full story is not in on tankless heaters yet. His belief was that they were not as efficient at heating the water as the better tank heaters. The problem is that the tankless heaters must have a powerful firing rate to heat the water quickly n a single pass. Therefore the stack losses or the amount of heat that is wasted by going out the flue is most likely significantly greater. Also, if the demand on the heater is too great (the flow rate too high) and the unit cannot heat the water hot enough fast enough, it has the ability to reduce the flow rate. In other words, your shower could be reduce to a trickle.

So, the savings comes from the fact that there are few if any standby or tank losses, not from the efficiency of the burner.

That's not the tidbit. When I asked what was the most common problem with them his answer was that often when people took out an older tank unit and replaced it with a tankless one they were often dissatisfied and that their service people usually found that the gas supply to the new unit was, in effect, under sized. The tankless unit has a higher firing rate or consumption and therefore the old gas lines are too small and the unit is starved for gas. The "trick" in solving the problems is to get the gas supply adequate and the flue or vent correct. He explained that in a competitive world some plumbers were reluctant to demand the additional money to improve the gas supply and flue.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#2

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>My main job responsibility is reading meters for a natural gas company.

Part of the job is to notice unusual useages, both high and low, and find out if the customer is doing anything different.

On several occasions when a I've noticed a sharp drop in useage the reason has turned out to be a tankless water heater.

I'm sure not an expert on the subject, but in these cases at least, the customer is using less gas.

Prehaps the answer is that a regular water heater is going to fire every so often regardless of demand. It may in fact be more efficient, but because it continues to cycle 24 hours a day it uses more gas in the course of the day than a less efficient tankless model.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#3

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

George@Colonel's Workshop

>Good Afternoon Barry,

Thank you for that insight. I had been considering installing either a electrical or gas tankless heater in my home as a pre-emptive measure to the flooded celler we'll wake up to fairly soon. Our water tank is 9 years old or more. Maybe I should wait another ten years, use up a replacement tank, and then look into the tankless version when I am 79 years old. I'll get one with a lifetime guarantee. As an aside, We lived in substandard housing when we were in the Air Force stationed in Libya. Our abode was a Belgian made house trailer, moved there from Morocco and stored outside for a number of years. It was equipped with a "flash heater" which was driven by bottled propane gas. It worked on water pressure demand, and given enough propane in the tank would flash while the demand was present. To take a shower or fill the mineature tub kept it flashing. It was hung on the kitchen wall, which was plywood. One winter night I took a tub bath to get warm (the kerosene heater wouldn't vent properly and I wouldn't use it.)and noticed a lot of snap, crackle, and pop coming from the kitchen as I exited the bathroom. The flash heater kept flashing after the demand had ceased and I had a house fire with flames licking over the walls and ceiling. Fortunately I had a flexible shower hose and hooked that up to the kitchen sink faucet and sprayed the entire area, catching the fire early enough to save the unit. Fortunately my very pregnant wife had been sent to Germany before giving birth to #1 son. After I had put the fire out, I was walking over to ask our nexr door neighbor for help when I realized I was naked. It was a memorable night.

George

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#4

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Barry Irby

>Randy, I hope you are correct, that these folks spent their money on a tankless heater and got a nice reduction in gas use as a result.

We need to consider other factors as well. Your circumstance is comparing their old, possible decrepit, possible leaking, water heater to a nice new one. We don't know what would have happened if they had installed a new tank style heater. Perhaps their savings would have been similar.

Also, we don't know if the new water heater was the only thing they did. They may have done other energy saving type things at the same time.

And, they may have changed their habits a little. Maybe because of the expense of the new unit they came very conscious of gas use and cut down in general.

Theoretically, the only thing the tankless heater saves you is the tank or standby losses. And some of the losses from water circulating out into the pipes. It sure would be nice to see a real world comparison between a properly installed unit on both sides and with the tank and pipes well insulated. The tankless units strike me as very expensive and I wonder if they ever pay off. It is good to know that some people are benefiting. Thanks.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#5

28 years ago.

Basil

>The X-wife's mother was British and so about half her relatives lived in England. They began to visit here back in the 70's and they commented about the excessive water pressure and heat we Americans used. I took that as a chance to learn something. Even different parts of the US do things different from others. Everybody thinks they have a better way of doing things and sometimes, they do.

One of her cousins was telling me about hot water heater for showers. It was a small electric water heater (box) mounted on the wall with the shower head sticking out. You selected the temperture you wanted and waited a few minutes and then took a shower. Because of the low pressure on the "grid" (35 lbs. on national water system) they used very little water or electricity for daily showers.

I've looked for years for someting similar here but finally gave up.

BTW: I believe if I had had one shipped from England back then it would have been 240 volts 50 cycles. Might have had problems with it.

Anyone seen such a contraption sold in the US yet?

Basil

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#6

Electric heaters are almost 100% efficient (OT)

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>The heating elements are immersed in water, and the only heat loss is the small loss to the surrounding air. The trade off is the cost of electricity vs gas. I'll let some engineer figure that out....

Happy New Year,

Ken

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#7

Thanks, Barry - Glad I have an electric one!

Ron Hildreth

>

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#8

Tankless does not equal big savings

Kevin Rabenaldt

>The hype surrounding tankless water heaters really surprises me. When they were first pushed by new home owners and builders (I design and have built several houses), I ask why they want one over a standard natural gas water heater. First out of the mouth, is the money they are going to save. I ask how much money are you going to save. They have no clue.

I have two 40 gallon natural gas water heaters. I have gas cooktop and gas central heating. During the summer when all I use is the water heaters (family of four) and cooktop, my natural gas bill is $35 a month. Now really folks, how much are you going to save? At 50 percent (and that is generous) it amounts to $17 for me. It will take a long time to pay one of these things out.

Another reason I hear is that they last longer. Where I live the water is hard on plumbing. A water heater lasts 5 years on average. I doubt the tankless will last past 8 to 10 (before the warranty runs out). I ask them, do you really think you are going to collect on the warranty?

Kevin

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#9

Agreed

Nat Robison

>My gas bill in the summer is also in the neighborhood of $30 (also have a gas cooktop). When I replaced a water heater last winter, I couldn't justify going tankless on cost savings alone. At $15 a month, it would take forever to recoup the addl. costs.

My plumber neighbor also stated (I think) that tankless heaters need a 1" gas line feeding them.

I like the thought of tankless heaters but it doesn't appear that they equal savings for everyone.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#10

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>As I said we check when the useage is higher than normal as well.

Let's take the biggest user (heat) out of the picture and say it is summertime.

Where I work the readings are written in a book instead of one of the electronic readers most utilities (at least the ones who still have people actually walking up to a meter) use. Each page is good for two years and has the reading prior to its insertion printed on the left side of the page. I can always see, at the very least, the previous year's use and every other year the previous two years.

Just to pick a number, let's say the normal reading from April through the end of August is a little to either side of 50. Water heater only. The July reading is 80. A check with the homeowner finds that there is a dripping faucet in the bathtub. Yes, such a seemingly small problem can make that much of a difference. And I would say that pretty close to 90% of the time, that, or a leaking pop off is the problem. It would be a water useage problem with a tankless heater but it wouldn't effect gas useage.

Of course, sometimes the tank on the water heater itself leaks or in a worse case situation lets go.

I am pretty sure that it is possible to buy a water heater with electronic ignition but I have never installed (we do that too) or even seen one as far as I know. Without electronic ignition there is always a standing pilot that, while it may not be a lot, IS using gas.

I have on more than a few occasions installed new water heaters where the old one had so much lime in the bottom it had to be working hard to do the job. Nonetheless, I cannot remember the difference between old and new ever showing up in subsequent readings.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#11

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Howard Norman

>Randy,

>I have on more than a few occasions installed new water heaters where the old one had so much lime in the bottom it had to be working hard to do the job. Nonetheless, I cannot remember the difference between old and new ever showing up in subsequent readings.<

That is an interesting observation. My neighbor across the road is on his second tankless water heater in less than ten years since installation and four years of living in the house full time.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#12

Agree and disagree *LINK*

Ron Hildreth

>Kevin,

In my household, the kids are gone, and there's only the wife and I. YES, I do save money by owning a ELECTRIC tankless water heater. After all, SWMBO & I don't use that much water between us! I can see that if a big family of parents and three or more kids in a household probably wouldn't save much - takes a lot of juice to heat the water if everyone has to shower on a Friday night.

My water heater has a lifetime warranty - call them and next day, rush delivery, no charge, & they pay shipping. It's in my contract. The cheaper ones on the market don't hold a candle to that, and if that's what you install, you need to look into a better heater for your customers! Try the link below, and I think you'll be impressed. BTW - look at their credentials. I'm now on my fifth year and going strong. Sure like to know I'll never run out of hot water during my shower tonight, no matter how long I'm under the shower head!


SETS Tankless Water Heaters

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#13

Re: Electric heaters are almost 100% efficient (OT

r payne

>They may be efficient compared to the energy put into the unit but how do they compare from the energy generation. The last time I accually figured the stats for that (loooong time ago, project for college environmental course don't think I still have that) gas was more efficient when comparing total energy lost from generation to usage.

ron

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#14

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Barry Irby

>Thanks Randy. I was not trying to start an argument about one Vs. the other. More along the lines of intelligent discussion and real information without the hype. Amazing how hard it is to sort out the facts from the hype.

As I under stand it, there has to be a certain amount of flow through the tankless unit before the gas kicks in and fires. So a dripping faucet might only waste water and not gas with a tankless heater, but with a tank unit, it would waste both. Interesting.

Reading those meters, you are in a position to know what really happens. You know how much gas people use seasonally.

In my case, I live in an all electric home with a heat pump. I look at my two low bills of the year and figure that is about the base load, the amount I spend for none heat/AC energy. Any over that goes to heat and AC. Insulation and air sealing would save on the part that is Heat/AC related, but not much off the base. Things like compact fluorescent bulbs would save off the base.

I want to believe that tankless heaters are the best thing since sliced bread and are going to save us form the next ice age, but I would like to see some real world proof.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#15

Nine years, Colonel?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>We are still using the same water heater that we bought not long after we moved in here 30 years ago.

We're on well water and we've replaced a number of elements and a thermostat or two, but the tank is still good. I've shoveled out sediment every time I've replaced the bottom element and the old girl just keeps soldiering on.

Gary

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#16

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Bob Wilkerson - Richmond, VA

>FWIW, we often install tankless heaters in the new homes we build in Richmond. I'm one who is not convinced that the actual cost of gas savings will pay off but the other factor that I like is the advanatage of not running out of hot water or seeing the typical temperature drop when the tank type starts running low. Sizing the heater to actual consumption is also critical. The major complaint is when multiple points of use occur at the same time and the unit is not able to keep up. The other time the tankless is great is for those who have large soaking tubs that need a large volume of hot water to acheive comfort when filled.

Recently I perused an article that suggests using a tank in conjunction with the tankless.... I'll need to look at that harder to see if I can grasp the reason for that.

I think that the need to reduce gas usage will also be a factor in the future as energy costs rise. Competition between the types will help on both sides of the equation. That is one of the main reasons that tankless heaters come from Europe and Japan who have much higher taxes on all fuels. As the costs of fuels go up the small differences in efficiency will translate to greater savings.

Getting past the hype is a task for all of us as the need to lower fossil fuels useage looms larger. I will be getting deeper into this study as I start working on LEEDS certification for new construction. Cost/benefit must meet our customers needs for us to be able to sell houses whilst incorporating additional long term benefits. A percentage of the market can afford to be the ones who help get the technology funded but until it gets very effective the mass who would really benefit can't afford the upfront costs of implementation. It's up to builders and consumers to meet that challenge.

Bob

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#17

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Jay Lombardo

>When we remodeled the master bath 4 years ago the wife wanted a large jacuzzi tub for relaxing in, who could refuse. After all, I got to build the vanity and cabinets. After months of construction the tub was finally ready for her to use, and after filling it about 4" the old 40 gallon HWH was out, OOPS!! I guess I didn't think that one all the way through. The house is on a crawl and the HWH is in a very small closet in the kitchen, not big enough for 2 heaters or not even big enough for a 70 gal unit. After much research I decided that a gas tankless unit was the way to go. I can report that I am extremely satisfied with it's performance. I installed it myself, brought a 3/4" gas line, and installed the type 3 stainless vent piping (the only part that ticked me off, that vent piping is REAL expensive). Savings amount to approx 15-20%. But the endless hot water is priceless, 6 people living in house. We can use any 2 points of use at the same time, shower & laundry, dishwasher & sink, etc. Except for that jacuzzi, we can fill it up no problem but while that tub is filling you don't get hot water anywhere else! Just thought I would add some real world experience to the conversation. I really like the unit and have had no problems whatsoever, and I would highly recommend them.

Sorry so long winded,

Jay

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#18

Re: Agree! Tankless does not equal big savings

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>My summer water heating bill is $35 - That is a MINIMUM charge - and I haven't calculated the actual gas usage. I used an electric tankless unit at the factory where I worked prior to retirement. The unit sadly disappointed me. I would suggest a far cheaper method to eliminate much of the heat loss from conventional water heating systems. Insulate the tank with a blanket and all the hot water lines with the wrap around foam insulation. I have one bathroom that is over 30' from the water heater. I do have a short time lag (less than 15 seconds) of water running prior to full hot water. I also agree the "hard water" lime buildup could be a major problem to those without a water softener. I personally would never invest in a tankless unit. I was a professional plumber for a number of years (had state contractor plumbing license in Indiana), A properly sized conventional gas quick recovery unit will provide all the hot water a family will use without a problem (unless you are trying to fill a large spa or hot tub). I raised 6 children, my wife and I took daily showers as did the children, washed all clothing at home and ran a dishwasher, we very rarely ran at all short of hot water with a conventional 40 gal heater. As Barry said, the only possible savings is in the loss of heat from the pipes and heater, so insulate what you have and don't look back. As I (and most have) widely separated points of use (2 bathrooms, and kitchen - the only way tankless would save due to pipe heat loss is if I installed one at each POU. I'm sure I could never recoup the $1000's involved in installing tankless units.

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

#19

Re: New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)

Kevin Rabenaldt

>Jay,

You have the perfect circumstances for a tankless heater.

Kevin