New tidbit on tankless Water Heaters (OT)
Barry Irby
>As a Home Inspector I attended some training the other night on Water heaters and gas piping.
The fellow offering us the training was a proponent of Bradford White Heaters based on the fact that they do not sell them Retail through the big box stores or otherwise and that they are all professionally installed by plumbers. His company also sells a Re-branded tankless heater someone makes for them.
The topic of tankless heaters has come up here several times so I thought I would share what I thought was an interesting piece of info.
He said that the full story is not in on tankless heaters yet. His belief was that they were not as efficient at heating the water as the better tank heaters. The problem is that the tankless heaters must have a powerful firing rate to heat the water quickly n a single pass. Therefore the stack losses or the amount of heat that is wasted by going out the flue is most likely significantly greater. Also, if the demand on the heater is too great (the flow rate too high) and the unit cannot heat the water hot enough fast enough, it has the ability to reduce the flow rate. In other words, your shower could be reduce to a trickle.
So, the savings comes from the fact that there are few if any standby or tank losses, not from the efficiency of the burner.
That's not the tidbit. When I asked what was the most common problem with them his answer was that often when people took out an older tank unit and replaced it with a tankless one they were often dissatisfied and that their service people usually found that the gas supply to the new unit was, in effect, under sized. The tankless unit has a higher firing rate or consumption and therefore the old gas lines are too small and the unit is starved for gas. The "trick" in solving the problems is to get the gas supply adequate and the flue or vent correct. He explained that in a competitive world some plumbers were reluctant to demand the additional money to improve the gas supply and flue.



