>Meeting with architect to design garage shop. It will end up within 4 to 5 feet of a mature 100' tall red oak. I really hate the idea off cutting it down. Anybody know if excavating the footings, which will cut through roots, would damage the tree to the point where it would be a hazard?? My other thought is to find a sawyer with a portable band mill and turn this into cabinets/furniture. Appreciate your thoughts.
>A few years ago, the county realigned the corner near my house, widening the road and installing cement curbs. The curb is now probably 10 feet from 2 mature red oaks. They seem to have come through it ok. 5 feet away might be another story.
Their original plan was to remove the trees (they're in the county's right-of-way) but received too many complaints about the de-foresting so they left them.
>Howard,Removing 1/3~1/2 the root mass of a tree is flirting with disaster. Any chance of putting piers in the soil ever so often, on the root side of the shop. Would think the Architect would think of that if possible. As a forester that does several house calls a year, I'd think the safe approach is to remove the tree with the lest amount of cost and get some lumber out of it.
>This is an economic question. What will it CST you to remove the tree now VS. after you build the garage and the tree dies. If the difference is not great, you can leave the tree there and wait and see. IF the difference is vast (or even half vast) you should consider removing the tree first. Very good chance it will die. What is being lucky worth to you?
>A friend of mine kept all the oak trees cut down where he built his house and used the lumber to make all the trim for the house. It drove his wife nuts because it took about two years of drying and weekend warrior trim work to get the house trimmed. But in the end they really liked it.
On the other hand, when I used to have a 100 foot tree that close to my house, I would cringe every time the wind came up. Don't miss it a bit.
After reading the U of MN book you'll know if your architect and treeguy know about construction damage.
Gary Johnson, who wrote the UofMN book has said that there are red oaks that will die if you say 'Bobcat' too loud. Some species are more tolerant of construction damage than others.
There are many options that could be pursued but you'll need a very well educated arborist to work on the tree. many trees will survive construction because they were taken care of before the first shovel went in the ground. And!!! the post construction plan was in place and followed.
This plan could include some subordination of larger,heavier limbs. DON'T ever confuse subordination with topping.
Write to me if you have any tree questions. I've made my living as an arborist and my hobby as a woodworker.