Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Posts

OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#1

OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Barry Irby

>My next door neighbor hired a tree guy to remove a couple of trees.

Tree guy ran into trouble and dumped a big tree on my little tree. A fruitless cherry I planted about 20 years ago that I enjoy when it blooms in the spring.

I talked to the tree guy and his attitude is he is going to do nothing, because it is just a little scrubby maple or something, couldn't be worth over twenty bucks.

Nope, It was a dwarf fruitless blooming cherry. Well I got nothing to do with all that, the neighbor did not tell me there was cement in the tree and we had to rope it off to the tree across the street and it still got away from us.

My answer is that "I got nothing to do with all that", he's the expert and he should make it right.

He wants to cut down the tree and plant something similar beside it. I don't want him digging in the yard, I have irrigation and water lines and other plants out there. What would you expect?

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#2

JL

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

JL

>I'd make a claim against the neighbor's home owner insurance and have someone else do it.

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#3

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Tom O'Connor

>Seems to me that you should get exactly what you had! The tree guy should have a pretty hefty insurance policy that he doesn't want to make a claim against.

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#4

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Figure out what you want and when you want it and then deal with the homeowner. It's up to him to deal with the arborist he hired, not you. I'd also call your insurance guy and file a statement if intent with him so you've got a record of what's transpired.

But before you go any further, decide what you want from them to make this right.

good luck

Rob

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#5

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Howard

>There is a value to a mature tree that a good nurseryman should be able to give you. You don't want a 1-2 year tree replacement, you want the same tree of the same age. Another alternative is to find out the cost to have a company "transplant" a similar tree to your spot - they have special trucks that cut the roots of an existing tree and then transport it.

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#6

Take pictures now - start the documentation proces

M. McNamee

>Be a boy scout - always be prepared.

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#7

Dale Lenz

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Dale Lenz

>Talk with the person in charge, your neighbor, I'd think. Then your neighbor would talk with the supervisior/owner of the tree company. The tree company should be held accountable. I'd try to settle out of court, if possible.

Good luck

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#8

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

Jesse Cloud

>As somebody said above, first step is to figure out what you want. I would do this and give the tree company a chance to make it right before you pursue the insurance route - they probably will not replace it with a tree of equal age/value.

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#9

Licensed? Bonded? Insured?

John in New Mexico

>Get the contractor to make good, if he's none of the above, then report him to the registrar of contractors in your state. Most states have fines for un-licensed contracting. The tree guy isn't necessarily incompetent, but that's why pro's should have insurance or at least a bond - to cover accidents. Either way, I'd say its the contractor's responsibility, no need to make an enemy of your neighbor.

Re: OT Tree guy next door ruins my Tree Question?

#10

Compensation

Tom Dunlap

>I've spent my whole life working as an arborist. More than once I've done damage. I've tried to make things right too. Like any situation there are chislers that need to be dealt with.

This situation is not dificult. Take lots of pictures and write everything down.

Talk with your neighbor and get hold of the tree cutter's [he's not an arborist] insurance company directly. If there's no insurance then you're going to have to take the next step.

Determine the value of the loss. Is the cherry beyond any recovery? I've worked on storm damaged trees that needed a couple of years of reconstructive care to get them back on track. With this knucklhead's attitude you don't want him to do the aftercare.

If the tree has to be replaced you have every right to get a tree that's the same crown and trunk size. If he had smashed your Lexus you wouldn't settle for a Kia replacement would you?

You may not be able to find a large replacement since it is a special tree. in that case you'll have to work out a cash and replacement agreement.

If you need to contact a qualified arborist or a Consulting Arborist in your area let me know. There's a good chance that I can hook you up with a credible representative.

Tom