Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

best style workshop lighting fixtures

Posts

best style workshop lighting fixtures

#1

best style workshop lighting fixtures

billfrommich

>I have decided to use 4 ft. fluorescent lighting fixtures for the basic lighting in my basement shop, which has an unfinished joist ceiling about 7ft above the floor. There are three basic fixture styles under consideration: 1. plain striplights with exposed bulbs. 2. "shoplight" type fixtures with exposed bulbs and a reflector. 3. enclosed fixtures with a reflector and wraparound plastic diffuser.

I am hoping to get somes opinions as to which works best in a woodshop environment. I am not so much concerned with their light output and distribution as I am with their functionality in a dusty workshop environment. Are any of the above fixtures particularily easier or more difficult to keep clean (remove dust from)? Would exposed bulbs at such a low height be prone to accidental breakage? Do the clear plastic protective tube covers really do much to protect the tubes from breakage, or just reduce the cleanup after a breakage? I am incilined towards the use of style 3 fixtures but am concerned about dust. Any advice on this matter would be much appreciated. Thanks and Happy New Year!

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

#2

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

George@Colonel's Workshop

>Good Afternoon Bill,

I've used all three basic styles. My preference is for style #3 for the following reasons: the diffusers provide a less intense yet more even light source. The diffusers protect the bulbs against accidental damage/breakage. I have found that the diffusers can be repaired by clear freezer tape if they should crack when hit by low flying fruit bats, or kickbacks. There are different styles of diffusers. Some are real PITAs to remove for vacuuming or bulb replacement. The style I favor simply "hooks" over both sides of the fixture's full length flanges. Unhooking just one side of the diffuser exposes the bulbs while retaining the hanging diffuser on the opposite side of the fixture. Some fixtures are stingey when it comes to enough finger and thumb room to dislodge the bulb. Mine are stingey, and because of arthritis, I have to get my wife or one of the kids to change a light bulb. It drives me crazy. Dust: its guaranteed! I take them down for vacuuming when I feel energetic. However, its the top of the fixture which collects most of the dust. A brush on the end of a Shop Vac works fine enough for me, and I have yet to receive a complaint from a shop visitor that the tops of my light fixtutres are dusty.

George

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

#3

JL

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

JL

>I have the enclosed fixtures with the diffusers (I guess style #3). They work fine. The bulbs are protected by the diffusers. The only negative thing I can say about them is that the little "hooks" the hold the diffuser frame are a bit stiff.

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

#4

CFL's?

JohnM in Mid Mich

>Maybe consider compact fluorescent bulbs in screw base fixtures? I use 8ft tubes now, but if I was starting fresh I might consider the CFL's. Seems there is intense development on these at the moment, and so likely you'd be able to upgrade to whatever the latest hi-efficiency, natural color bulb is, whenever there is some advancement. I hate putting those tube fixtures together and wiring them.

John

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

#5

Re: best style workshop lighting fixtures

wilbur

>What often gets overlooked is the spacing between the bulbs in a typical 2-bulb fluorescent fixture. The wider the spacing, the more even the lighting, and the less shadows you'll have. The two bulb economy strips place the bulbs right next to each other, making the fixture more like a point source for light, which leads to more shadows.

This is also why CFLs may not work well for shop lighting purposes. They are fluorescent bulbs for sure, but they are a point source of light just like a regular incandescent bulb, and will cast more shadows.

The borgs around here have fluorescent light fixtures that run from $20 to $45 each, with the more expensive ones being like your #3. I went with those in my shop, and would not hesitate to do it again.

As far as dust goes, dust will accumulate equally either on the plastic protector or the bulbs themselves. It's easier to remove the plastic protectors and hose them off every so often than to try to remove the same dust from the bulb directly.