I posted about this a few months ago. The outside units - the exchangers, are almost always frosted up or have a coating of ice on them, even when the outdoor temps are above freezing.
This past month I had a $605 electric bill.
I had the units serviced after that suggestion here by a reputable company. They added quite a bit of refrigerant to one of the systems, but said everything was working otherwise. I have to suspect otherwise, as it just doesn't seem right that these things are so frozen up all of the time.
They're not original to the house, and are about 8 years old. The house is nice and warm, probaby because I'm pumping so much electricity into it.
House is a 1988, 3500 sq. feet cedar sided colonial in the woods. TONS of double pane Anderson glass - no condensation on the windows, no discoloration inside, no reason to suspect they're defective. I have put that seasonal plastic over many of the windows, it does wonders.
Yes, we keep it warm, 71-72F during the day/eve. 66 at night. There is a hot tub on the back deck.
I gotta suspect something is wrong with the HVACs.
Sounds like the outside unit has shut down and you are running off of pure electric heat pump backup. The heat pump should have a reverse cycle where it will prevent any ice buildup. Sort of like a defrost on a freezer. My opinion, the thing is not reversing and is on solidly, generating no real heat pump heat, and the heat is coming from your electric backup. How to tell is - there are two pipes coming out of your inside unit, a large one and a small one. One of these ought to be real hot when the unit is running.
Good luck. I jus had my heat pump die after 19 years (which is pretty good). $5500 later, my bills are lower with the new unit.
Yikes! Is it running off the emergency heat? (resistive elements, feel warm air from the vents, light glows on thermostat?) If so, the heat pump may not be working at all. (when the heat pump is working properly, air from the vents will not feel warm) Is air flow from outside vents partially blocked by anything? I think I'd call a different HVAC guy.
We had high heat pump bills in our last house but never that high. In this house we heat 95% with one small centrally located Vermont Castings woodburning stove with ceiling fans to help move air around.
>I'm no HVAC guy either but I've been down a similar road with one of ours recently.
It sounds like either your freon has run low again (can you say leak?) or the defrost cycle isn't working or both!
If the suction line (larger of the two coming into the outside unit) is iced, that's a good sign of low refrigerant. Another culprit can be clogged filters but I would think that to not be the case here.
Is the fan running on the outside unit? If not, there's several things besides a motor that can cause this. Did the previous guys check the system for leaks? This was the problem with one of our units. It was to the point of no return and we replaced it with a larger and more efficient Trane unit. I've already noticed a difference in our electric bill and the comfort upstairs.
Hopefully your next service people will nail the problem and it won't dent your tool buying budget like mine did!
>Typical heat pumps will work until the outside temp is around 40 degrees and then they become less efficient and may tend to freeze up. Older units had strip heaters outside mounted on the coil, that would turn on to create heat. The heat pump would then attempt to cool off the air from these strip heaters and pump it into the house via the refrigerant system. Needless to say they weren't very efficient. I think some of the new units acutally have the strips mounted inside the air ducts in the house so the heat goes to the house directly without the added cost of running the heat pump. There should be a freeze sensor in your unit that will prevent the outside coils from freezing up, though some ice may be visible.
My geothermal heat pump doesn't have that problem as the ground water stays above 40 degrees at all time.
>I have two separate systems and they are both showing nearly identical symptoms. The outdoor fans are running intermittently. The upstairs unit - the one that had low refrigerant, ices more than the other, but it did even immediately after it was serviced.
I have a LOT of glass in my house, I mean a whole lot, so I expect a healthy bill, but this is really high.
HVAC is one of the few areas of home stuff in which I lack knowledge and REALLY appreciate you guys help.
I can give you lots of info on this, but my typing is tedious for me. Let me know and I will hammer this as much as you want.
What a heat pump should do is heat the air between 14 and 20 degrees. Plus or minus a degree or two either way. When the unit is running put a thermometer near the return and get the return temp. With the unit stabilized (running for about ten minutes or more) take the temp at a supply near the unit. Return temp should be about room temp and the other one should be 14 to 20 more. If the Difference is less than 14 it USUALLY indicates low refrigerant (Freon). If the Difference is over 20 or 22 it usually indicates restricted air flow. (Very dirty filters, poor duct design, too many vents or dampers closed, dirty indoor coil, or fan speed set wrong.)
There are any more things that affect the performance, including too much Freon.
The outside units frost up because they must get cold to extract heat from the winter air. So condensation and frost forms on them. The unit might have a frost sensor and defrost only when necessary or more likely it just defrosts every so many minutes. The defrost cycle is very expensive. The unit reverses and runs as an air conditioner which heats the outdoor coil, melting the frost. The strip heaters come on to offset the chill of the AC. So, you are paying to pump heat you already paid for back outside and then triple that to replace it with electric heat.
Units have been known to frost up excessively because the Freon was incorrect.
Units have what is known as a "Set Point". Above that outdoor temp they run as a heat pump, below that they run as an electric furnace. There is a trade off. Raising the set point makes the heat pump run less and probably last longer (life time). Lowering the set point may increase efficiency and make it run cheaper, because the heat pump runs more, but at the expense of shortening it's life. what makes this somewhat complicated is the fact that as the exterior temp falls, so does the efficiency of the HP. At about 47 it is about three time as efficient as the electric furnace. At 35 it about double and at about 20, its a wash, so there is no point in running the HP when it is twenty or twenty five outside. You might ask your guys what the set point is.
If your units needs more freon it means you have a leak. That must be cured because of the environmental risks form the freon.
How long have you lived in the house? Is this bill really high compared to last year? If this is your first year in the house it could be that it is very poorly insulated. Has something else changed? You don't have the door to the attic open do you?
>Thank you Barry. Part of this is rate shock - as Maryland had energy prices regulated until this past summer, when all residents experienced a 50% or more higher bill, overnight.
My electric use between this and the same period last year was a little higher for this year, but the average temp was 40 when last year it was 44.
I had a new roof put on last year. The walls are not cold to the touch, but there is a seriously large amount of double pane Anderson casement glass in this house. Very large casement windows in every room as we have really nice views. One other thing I haven't checked into is the water heater. That is next. Of course the hot tub on the back deck isn't helping.
Due to the electric rate increase, there's additional incentive for me to make sure things are running right. I have another company coming out on Wednesday and you all have given me a lot of questions to ask of them. Thanks!
>Mike, Do you have an electrical tester that has an "amps" setting. The ones I am familiar with is an Ampere and it has a set of jaws that close around a wire, without touching it, and can read the current flow through the wire.
If you have such a device, you can clip it onto the wire to the Inside Unit and see how much current it is drawing. It should be using one or two amps to run the fan if it is running as a heat pump. If it is running as an electric furnace it will draw MUCH more current. Like 18 Amps, or even a multiple of that. Most units have either one strip, two or occasionally three. They come on in sequence, usually about thirty seconds apart. IF you have such a device, you can hang it from one of the wires in your electrical panel and watch to see what is happening. The unit should come on and run the fan and draw a very few amps. After a few minutes it may bring on a strip heater and the needle will jump. A minute later, it may jump again, and again. It should never pull more than 80% of the rated amps for the breaker.
If your rates jumped 50% you should be able to take last years bill and add fifty percent to it, plus another five or ten percent for the slightly more severe weather. If that is significantly less than your current bill, you must have some other problem.
Anderson windows are some of the best. (IMHO) Covering them with plastic will help.
Beyond that, with the rate increase, it might be time to think of energy upgrades. How hard would it be to add some insulation to your attic? R38 would be good for MD and you should have R 19 under the floor. Casement windows are excellent at resisting air leaks, so not much to do there. Are they new enough to have Low E Glass?
Anything you can do to resist vertical air flow through the house might be good. Caulk holes left by electricians and plumbers through the bottoms of walls int eh crawl space and tops of them in the attic.
>Since it's happening to both units, I doubt that it's caused by a system part failure. I haven't had a heat pump in years but as I recall, mine had a jumper adjustable defrost timer. If you're going in to defrost cycle OK, it may not be set long enough on either unit. Mine also worked on a pitot tube principle where the defrost cycle was triggered when the frost cut off the air flow across the tube and a vacuum switch(lack of vacuum) put it into defrost. Spiders and mud daubers had a habit of building nests in the tubes in the summer, and it became a fall ritual to clean the tube so it would work.
We have a fairly new mid-grade Trane heat pump for our cabin in northern Virginia and just paid $150 for the last month, but that bill also includes the separate two-car garage where I have two resistance heaters going full-time. So your bill does sound high. In addition to all the good advice from others, here is a link to a search on a good HVAC forum using "icing" as a search word. I had this happen on a rental unit once, and the HVAC man came out and replaced a part and added new Freon and no more icing. Wasn't very expensive IIRC, but I don't remember what part was replaced. We all would be interested in what the second HVAC service person says.
>Modern heat pumps are charge critical to � 0.5 oz. HP makers use pre-charged line sets to achieve this. The lines use large fitting nuts, o-rings, and piercable brass membranes to contain the freon. After the line sets are pulled thru the crawl space (during installation) these fittings get dirty. This almost guarantees leaks. Along comes your serviceman, the only way that he can charge the unit is to blow the remaining charge and weigh in a WHOLE new one. Did your past company do this? A 3-ton unit will contain something about 9 to 12 pounds of freon.
Look for an oil slick on all fittings. This is your leak. Oil and freon circulate together. The oil slick will attract dirt.
During the heat cycle, the freon outside is below 32�F. Any humidity will freeze to the coil and will stop the air flow. HPs use timers and frost sensors to start/and stop defrost cycles. During defrost, the HP reverses cycles and brings on auxilliary strip heats in the inside coil so that the cold air does not blow inside the house. The hot freon melts the ice from the outside coil.
HPs start losing ground below 35�, because the lower heat content in the outside air and increased defrost times. The house thermostat is multi staged. As the differential between it's setpoint and actual house temp increases, the t'stat will allow auxilliary strips to come on. Good systems have multiple outdoor t'stats that do not allow more strips to come on until the outside temp drops. (�28�,20, 15). Most systems have two or three 5KW strips that at 10.3 cents per KWHour, one hour of a 5 KW strip costs $0.51. Figure that for four weeks! Ouch! Some of these separate controls may have been replaced with combined circuit boards.
Do not use night set-back t'stats on HPs unless it is specifically designed for HPs. When the t'stat comes out of set-back, the sudden increase in differtial will force the strips on.
>Glad to hear they are running well, I think. Might have been nice if he had some cheap magic answer that cut your bill in half.
Glass is tough on heat bills. The R Factor for windows is about 1 or 2 and even with Low E glass it is not over about a 3. A wall could easily be an R-15. So the window could be losing between five and 15 times as much energy as the wall area.
If you are really concerned, you could consider shutters or some other devices that cut those losses. Even properly installed pleated shades can double or triple the effectiveness of windows against radiant losses. Insulated drapes can help also. Some of this is ancient technology.
My grandmother had two sets of drapes. The summer drapes hung off the sides of the windows and there were white shears. The light colored fabric reflected the sun back out but let the breeze dome through. (There was no AC). The winter drapes were lined and insulated and hung on the windows. During the day she pulled them back to let the sun in. there were no shears. At night, she released the ropes and let them close over the windows. Voila! Passive solar heat. The house had been built before the Civil War with the major glass facing south. They knew a thing or two about working with the environment. Not any more. We slap in windows facing every which way and crank up the thermostat to compensate.