>I've got a basement window well that leaks with the 'right' combination of wind and rain. The cement on the inside is sort of flaky too. I'm having a hard time hiring somebody to replace it (my free time is limited, and I don't want to mess with it myself, I don't do metal or cement very well). Light is not an issue.
Is just filling the well with concrete feasible? It's the standard 3' x 1' well, about 18" to 24" deep, surrounded at the ground level by a concrete patio.
If it's not a bad idea, could I expect the window to 'contain' the cement without bursting until hardened? Thanks for any advice offered..
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well
Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI
>You should be able to get a plastic cover that goes over the well that would keep out any water. Most home stores like Home Depot / Menards would carry these. So far as filling in the well I think you might want to check your local code before you do that.
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well
Ron Hildreth
>Tom,
I agree with Moses about a cover, but further add that if the window well is filling with water, like a sink, you might be better off to find a way to drain it, too. This might be nothing more than digging it out a bit more, then adding maybe 6-12" of washed rock for the water to drain through. Make sure the bottom of your well is at least six inches below the bottom of the window after filling with the rock. Another option would be to install a drain pipe to deliver the water away from the house altogether, but you'll have to look at the "lay of the land" to see if that's feasible- hard to get water to run up hill without a little persuasion!
I don't think filling the well with concrete would be a very good thing to do!
Ron in Iowa
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well
Tom
>I may try digging out, once the weather warms up and the ground thaws. I've tried the plastic covers, and have even built my own out of green plywood. They don't help at all. The problem is the wind, I think. Even though the concrete patio surrounding is sloped (enough, I'm not sure, but I can't do anything about that), sometimes the wind makes the water back up a bit. There is also a two story wall right above the well too, that just collects a lot of rain when there is a driving wind. There is no 'lip' at ground level on the well either, just the edge of the patio.
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
>been throuth this.. Filling in the window well is an option but I find water finds a way. Do not know if your dilemma is like mine, but here goes. When i bought my house, the basement is poured concrete. There was a crack under the window (standard sized 3' x 15") right to the floor. Water would come in the crack. Contractor filled the inside and dug the outside, appled tar and plastic. Held up well for years. BUT - the problem was, in heavy rain, the water table would rize, window well fills up, and a waterfall comes in. I dug out the window well with a post hole digger, put a couple of inches of gravel and a performated 5 gallon bucket with a small sump pump in it. Problem solved, but if the power goes out, no joy. I have a slight grade away from this window and I dug a 40' trench, starting 2' deep at the window and gradually tapering to ground level. 3" drain quality PVC in there. No more sump pump. I had a window about 8 feet from this one - no crack, but it would fill up. I connected the 2 wells below window level with a piece of 2" PVC, and one sump pump / drain serves both.
Good luck.
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well
Barry Irby
>You have gotten good advice here, the others are right. As a Home Inspector I know a few things about this.
The BASICS: To have a leak you must have all three of the following, A HOLE for the water to go through, a DRIVING FORCE that makes the water go through the hole, and WATER. (On a dry windy day, the holes may be leaking AIR, but you don't really care about that, the water is your problem.) The driving forces are gravity and wind, and you can't turn them off. The water is rain, and it will rain again. The holes may be inaccessible or nearly impossible to seal.
To solve the problem you have to take away any one of the the three things. The covers for the well are an attempt to prevent the water from getting to and through the hole. The drains and gravel try to give the water somewhere to go without reaching the hole. The sump pumps are doing the same thing, but as mentioned they are mechanical and fail for a variety of reasons, including power outages.
Your idea of filling the hole with concrete might work, but I tend to doubt it. Concrete almost never forms a perfect bond with the surrounding materials and may do no better than the covers you have already tried. It is conceivable that it would make matters worse, by filling in the places the water finds to stand in now and leaving it nowhere to go except through the cracks. If you put the concrete into the well gently enough to not break the window, it will almost surely be riddled with cracks and voids that will let the water through.
I suspect water is running down your wall and drooling into the crack between the house and the slab as well as running into the window well. If so, filling the well will do nothing to abate the leak.
If there is a crack between the house and the slab, you could try filling with the caulk they use around the coping on swimming pools (Thiokol or Pecora). You could cut a groove in the brick wall (a reglet) an insert flashing in it and create a better seal or even a roof on the window well. You could anchor a dam around the perimeter the same way. (I might try this idea along with digging the well deeper and filling it with gravel. You might actually be able to dig down to the perimeter drain around the basement and let the water fall into that. Be careful doing this to avoid damage to your existing water proofing and drains.)
Another approach would be to put a roof or awning above the patio or turn the patio into a porch or lanai. This would be the "big" approach, but an advantage would be that you get something useful in addition to stopping the water from getting to the holes.
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
>If you lose power, is it likely to be for a long duration? If not, perhaps you could buy a UPS like you would use for your computer and run your sump pump through it.
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
>In many jurisdictions, the window well is a code item. Most codes say that there must be an alternate (to the interior door) egress from the basement and the window well serves that purpose.
George
Re: How bad of an idea is filling in a window well?
>Good thought George. Actually, from the description of the existing window well and window I was pretty sure it was not an Egress Window, but its still not a bad idea to be sure.