>I'm attempting to add a layer of rigid insulation (polycyano - something or other foam board, with paper on one side and foil on the other) to an unheated attic space - partially to increasse insulation, abut mostly to seal air leakage into the living space.
There are already glass batts between the studs, with kraft paper toward the living space, and I'll be putting the rigid insulation over the exposed glass on the attic side.
My question is, should I put the foil side or the paper side of the rigid board toward the existing insulation (or conversely, which side should face the unheated attic space??). I'm thinking paper toward attic.
I'll be sealing the joints with caulk after all is done.
Also, any hints on attaching the rigid insultion to the exposed studs? The existing insulation holds the board away from the studs enough that adhesive wont work, and screws tear right through. I'm thinking furring strips, but maybe something better is out there?
>You want only one vapor barrier as close to the heated side as possible, some vapor will get by and an other barrier will only trap the moisture between them. The glass should have one and it should be against the sheetrock ceiling. Moisture will travel till it hits the barrier and condense if it is too cold there. With a barrier atop of some insulation that insulation will collect moisture and eventually damage the sheetrock ceiling below it.
You may be better off with a blowen in insulation, they seem to seal rather well and is far less expensive, so for the same price you can put lots more insulation in. HD and Lowes often loan the blower if you buy enough insulation from them. With a helper half a day should see the insulation in and the site cleaned up.
So in answer to you question, NO; neither side up. If you really want to use the rigid stuff remove the glass and put the foil side to the living space.
Bill, it's not cold when you can see your breath, it's cold when you can see your breath fall to the ground and break.
>Will probably proceed as you say, with blown-in insulation for the "floor" of the attic space, but I'm concerned with the walls between the attic and the living space (there's sort of a walk-in attic above our living room, and adjacent to an upstairs bedroom), so there's a common wall between the attic and bedroom, and I'm trying to contain leaks as well as boosting insulation.
Removing the batts and re-doing the vapor barrier isn't really an option.
Guess I'll have to rethink the rigid insualtion idea.
>Bill Killed this. I am a Home Inspector and know a thing or two about vapor barriers so listen to what he told you.
You could put in an AIR Barrier that is not a Vapor Barrier. 15 b lb felt, Craft paper, red rosin paper or Tyvek will all work. All of them breath. You could roll any of them out and cover it with the cellulose. Bill is right, Celulose is a better air barrier than fiber glass. Just covering the upper surface of your ceiling insulation with paper or Tyvek will increase its apparent R value by about 15%. If you can cut he air flow too, that may be even more significant.
On what sounds like you knee walls you should insert pasts into hem from the back side with the vapor barrier face toward the living or heated space. If you can get in there to work you can cover the back side with the paper or Tyvek.
If you have access, you may be able to find someone to come in and spray in about a half inch of Urethane foam before you insulate or your could spray in the Icynene foam they love so much on This Old House.
>I had the same problem in my shop only the fiberglass was starting to sag and the paper was tearing. I added 1/2 in rigid insulation on the under side of the joists. It worked like a charm. Vapor can't go through the alminum so it is the vapor barrier. I used nail with built in plastic washer about 1 in. in dia. They hold the rigid board without tearing. They were in HD with the nails. I've had no moisture issues I 2 winters so far. (Note my location)
Given the comments of Bill and Barry, I'm going to take this up with the guys who recommended I do this to the attic, and see what they say about vapor/condensation issues before I proceed. We had a home energy audit done a few weeks back, and this was one of the issues they suggested I tackle as a "do-it-yourselfer" project (to same money so I can give it to the specialized contractors later...)
Good to know that you had success with it, though, since you're in pretty much the same climate as me....
I might actually do it your way later, but for now I get a reprieve from attic work this weekend!
This was part of some suggestions made after a home energy audit we had done a few weeks ago. The guys doing the audit made it sound like something easy and quick I could do to tighten up the house right quick, and save up $$ for the bigger issues that neede to be done by contractors.
I'll put the project on hold untill I can talk to the energy guys, and see if there's a way around it - maybe I misunderstood what they suggested I do to the walls....
They did strongly suggest the cellulose insulation for the attic floor/rafters, so maybe I'll pursue that.
>You need to be careful. And you obviously are. You are far enough north to be concerned about vapor/condensation issues. What Bill did (below) was correct for his (and your)climate, because he put the stuff on the bottom side. Big difference in putting it on the top side.
I would be skeptical of any advice the Auditors gave me if they are proposing to do the work themselves. The Auditors should be independent and not financially related to the guys profiting from the work.
My experience with this stuff is that it is very difficult to project savings of money verses dollars spent on the cure. There is a disconnect in the calculations. The work is designed to save BTU's of heat. Related to energy flow and air flow. And Comfort. Then you do an additional "conversion" to change that into dollars saved. Unless they have gotten a lot better, the calculation often fails to predict anywhere near a reasonable estimate of the savings and I have NEVER heard of one where the savings was more than predicted. The conversation usually goes "Spend $4000 now and save $400 dollars a year AND you will be more comfortable. you will get your money back in ten years if you don't consider interest." Later, you realize that at 10% interest, you never recover the money. A year or two later you realize you are not saving $400 a year, its more like $100 or even nothing. You confront them and they say "But you are more comfortable are you?" What fool would admit he had spent $4000 and was NOT more comfortable? So you say you were, even if you had not noticed.
The "Replacement Window" people are masters of this. They say, replace your leaky old windows and our new windows will save you forty percent of your heat bill, and we give you a one year guarantee. Then they charge you about four times what he windows are worth. Your heat bill barely changes and they say, well, "this year was colder than last year." You press them and they write you a check for 40% of your HEATING bill or about the cost of one window. You are left with a huge bill and little savings.
In a reasonably well insulated house the largest source of heat loss is usually air leakage. There are some do it yourself handyman projects that may pay off. These may involve a lot of time and labor or as they say sweat equity, but if you work at it you may be able to actually reduce your heating bills and increase your comfort at very little expense other than your time. If you are interested let me know and I will try to describe some of them to you. (Anything that stops vertical air flow through your house is good.)
>I for one would like to see some of these projects listed. I feel I have a pretty good handle on most of them, but it never hurts to hear about a few more.
>John, I would rethink applying any type of rigid board to the studs on the cold side of the attic wall if it compresses the existing fiberglass insulation. Chances are that it is 6" insulation in a 4" wall and the studs should be furred out accordingly. George
>Thanks for the reply, George - Too cold lately to work in the attic, so I've been spared having to deal with this.
Yes, You're right, I think it is 6" insulation batts. Hadn't actually thought about this issue - so if I decide to pursue this, I'll be sure to add some furring strips to the studs.
None of the improvements suggested by the energy auditors were things they would contact out for - all they do is energy audits and consultation. They have some people they recommend for certain things, but it wasn't a hard sell, and I felt like I was given enough information that I could shop around for my own contractor to do the work.
I also inquired about the vapor barrier issue, based on the responses here, and they seemed to think it would still be OK, since it woouldn't be completely air-tight. They also suggested something called Astrofoil (I think that's what they called it) as an air barrier instead of rigid insulation, since they felt it was less of a vapor barrier. Have to look into that some more.
The big things they pointed out were where we had big air leaks and conduction losses (rim joists, basement doors, and around a couple of window seals), and I'm addressing those (thought he rim joist issue will probably get contracted out).
They also suggested a process called Aeroseal, which seals leaks in HVAC ducts, and I KNOW i have lots of those I can't reach with tape and mastic.... Not sure what the quote on that will be, yet.
Not really looking for $$ savings, just trying to be less wasteful with energy (Wife and I are in environmental conservation-related fields, and are pretty militant about things like that), and also trying to be more comfortable in the house.
I appreciate your knowledge, and taking the time to answer my posts. If you don't mind posting some of the handyman-level projects that others can do, I'm sure there are others out there who might like to hear about them. Every little bit helps, after all....