Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

why multiple coats of oil?

Posts

why multiple coats of oil?

#1

why multiple coats of oil?

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I was dousing a curly maple piece with BLO this weekend and ended up watching the wood suck in lots of oil multiple times. And this was a day after a first coat. Fast forward a couple days and guess what: it looks the same as it did after the first coat.

So, I ask, what is the point of multiple coats of BLO? It does not seem to change the look - it still needs wax or a french polish or something - and building up a penetrating finish can't really do much for durability. "Durability" and a "penetrating finish" don't really overlap much, do they?

My plan is to let it all cure for a few weeks and then put on my final surface finish. Did I just force myself to wait longer for more oil to cure?

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

#2

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>It will start to build on the surface after a while. However, this can be a whole lot of coats later, as you have noticed. The oils do harden inside the wood and add to the durability, rather than just provide surface protection as with film based finishes.

I use oil mostly to pop the grain, then seal it after a coat or two with shellac. At this point you may continue with the oil, and in doing so will consume far fewer coats of oil than would have taken without the shellac. I typically move to an oil based varnish after the shellac coat, prefering Arm R Seal over most others.

Another advantage of oil based finishes is that they're extremely easy to repair.

If you don't want to put a hundred coats of Watco on something, switch to Waterlox or Daly's tung oil.

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

#3

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think the real question is, "Why BLO in the first place?", unless all you want is an oil finish. Any film finish can be its own sealer/undercoat and will emphasize the grain as much as BLO. BLO just complicates and drags out the process. I suggest washing down your current work with naptha to get did of the loose oil and speed up the cure, then topping with a good alkyd varnish, solvent lacquer, or water borne poly.

Clint

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

#4

Why BLO in the first place?

David Yoho

>As was already asked, why BLO in the first place? As far as I'm concerned (so this is only my opinion) they can ship all the BLO in the world to Mars and we'd not be any the worse for it!

If you want a simple oil finish plus something to "pop" the figure in that curly maple, you really want to use either a tung or linseed oil that has both a dryer and a resin in it. Watco fits this bill well. There are other products out there that will too. The point is make sure your oil has both additional components. One will make the oil (in this case linseed) dry quicker and the other will help build a thin film.

With BLO, it goes into the wood but takes a long time to dry. Before it does, you put on some more. It goes into the wood but takes a longer time to dry. As long as you keep applying the BLO, the "takes a long time to dry" scenario continues. To demonstrate this point, get a pieces of glass and put a couple drops of BLO on one area and a couple drops of Watco on another. Leave them for an entire day and come back to check which is runny and which is not. The Watco will not because of the dryer in it. The BLO will still not be dry and given more time, will eventually become gummy (still not dry).

So, there you have it - enough said!

David

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

#5

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>One of the aspects of woodworking is the amount of stuff you can learn. So you just learned what a BLO finish looks like, and that will help you the rest of your life as you make finishing decisions. The project could actually just be left to dry and then used as it is. I personally do not care much for a plastic coat of stuff built up to a shine so the stuff no longer looks like wood but glass or plastic instead.

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

#6

Watco vs BLO, and why each has its place

Michael Dresdner

>First, let's clarify. Watco Danish Oil is not oil. It is a varnish modified to make it easy to apply by flooding on and wiping off. One reason it dries faster than most BLO applications is that a large part of it is resin, not oil.

For that matter, how fast boiled linseed oil (BLO) dries depends largely on two things; how much drier has been added to it, and how much access it has to oxygen. Thinner coats mean more oxygen, as does higher drier rates, since the function of the drier is to shuttle oxygen into the oil.

Various manufacturers put both different amounts and different types of driers into their BLO, so you really can't make blanket statements about its drying time. For the uninitiated, BLO is simply raw linseed oil with driers added.

Using oil to pop the grain works for two reasons. Thanks to its low molecular weight, oil will go deep into wood, causing the upper layers to become more translucent as they become saturated. Thanks to its color, it will tint the more absorbant areas more than those less absorbant, thus intensifying subtle grain, such as in figured maple.

Other low molecular weight materials, like shellac and Danish oil, do the same thing, but with slightly different visual results. Try a sample of all three and see which looks best to you.

One note: any solvent based coating will go over dried linseed oil or Danish oil nicely, but if you plan to coat it with a waterbased coating, use a barrier coat of Zinsser SealCoat first. It's not necessary with all brands of waterbased coating, but it is with some, and it is not worth the risk if you don't know for sure.

Re: why multiple coats of oil?

#7

Re: Watco vs BLO, and why each has its place

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Wasn't there an article in FWW a while back that compared the "popping" effect of oils versus film finishes on various woods, which determined that there was no apparent difference? IMO, oils tend to muddy and flatten the figure, especially on darker woods.

Clint