White Oak Problems
Jim Orasky in Davenport IA
>I'm making some dining chairs using QSWO.
In several places the oak is "delaminating" along the lines of the flakes/rays.
Any idea what causes this?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
White Oak Problems
Jim Orasky in Davenport IA
>I'm making some dining chairs using QSWO.
In several places the oak is "delaminating" along the lines of the flakes/rays.
Any idea what causes this?
Re: White Oak Problems
Dale Lenz
>Since you are having internal radial splits, sounds like honeycombing to me, a drying defect. Unfortunately, not an easy thing to fix. Depending on how bad it is I have used "super-glue" to fill a few gaps. If I see the defects prior to getting to far into the project I've learned to firewood the oak.
Good luck,
Dale
Re: White Oak Problems
Sgian Dubh
>Dale, honeycombing is unmissable. It looks like this:

Notice how most of the voids follow the medullary rays with just two or three following the growth rings.
Jim reports that the wood is opening up following the lines of the medullary rays. This makes me think it's more likely to be severe surface checking caused by a steep moisture gradient (rapid drying) quite early in the drying process.

The shell in such circumstances is put under a great deal of tension stress and wants to shrink. It can't because the intermediate zone and the core are, in this case, wetter and retain their larger size. If the shell can't shrink it's got two choices:
1. Set hard in an 'oversize' condition or,
2. Split following lines of weakness.
The weakest line is radially following the medulla. In this case it sounds like it has taken the second option and split. Later in the drying process the intermediate zone and core shrink as they lose moisture and then the shell can shrink around these zones. At that point the splits or checks often disappear.
These checks reveal themselves again later when the timber is worked, and I suspect this might be what Jim is witnessing, although there may in fact be another cause for the radial separation, eg, stress as the tree grew, or some form of unusual stress at the time of felling.
There may be no cure as you suggest, but sometimes glue injected into the cracks followed by cramping pressure provides some kind of repair. Slainte.
Re: White Oak Problems
Dale Lenz
>Richard what ever the problem, and you maybe correct, surface checking. But, the slightly bigger than hair-line cracks that may not go completely through the wood maybe difficult to squeeze together with clamps. I normally just use the super glue as a filler. Under "natural" finishing I don't see the glue. Dale
alternative suggestion
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>The defects described by others lead to symptoms more severe than I think you are describing. These defects lead to stress in the lumber, as well as the voids, and this stress shows up when the lumber is ripped. The ripped pieces will twist and bend often to the point of stalling a modest HP saw. Such lumber is very unstable and I would not suggest using it.
When air drying oak in summer months it is common to get surface checks and they initiate at points of greatest weakness, which is usually the rays. These checks usually aren't very deep and they appear to seal together as the lumber continues to dry. In flat sawed lumber one never notices them in the KD piece. But it can lead to bits and pieces of rays flaking from the board when these rays are exposed at the surface. Other than the annoyance of flaky rays this lumber is ok to use for most purposes.
And then some oak just has occasional flaky rays that may have nothing to do with drying the lumber.