Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Material selection for doors...

Posts

Material selection for doors...

#1

Material selection for doors...

Steve Yakoban

>Hi,

We're getting closer to selecting new doors for the entire house. Per a suggestion on this forum, we looked into MDF interior doors but ruled them out due to excessive weight. One vendor has a lighter option, but hasn't offered details yet. In the meantime we're considering another vendor that will give us the choice of solid birch, poplar, or VG doug fir. These will be interior painted doors where we want to achieve a smooth (no grain showing) finish, without extensive painting efforts.

Any suggestions on which of these materials would be our best choice also considering durability issues among these soft woods?

And, we want a new stained entry door that will mimic our medium colored stained maple cabinetry. I heard maple is not a good exterior wood choice. Any thoughts on this or what wood would be a good match?

Thanks guys!

Re: Material selection for doors...

#2

Re: Material selection for doors...

NickB

>I don't have a good comment for you on the entry door, but for your paint-grade interior doors, I'd go with poplar. I've just about finished replacing the molded hollow core doors in my house with paint grade poplar, and I'm very happy with them. Can't comment on birch, but I've done a bunch with vg doug fir, and I've found the poplar is easier to deal with in terms of machining and getting a nice smooth finish.

Hope this helps,

Nick

ps. On your entry door, unless it is completely sheltered from the sun and weather, I'd think pretty hard about going with a completely wooden door-no clear finish can stand up to the sun for all that long, and who wants to spend all that time refinishing. I seem to recall that most major door manufacturers all make entry doors that have a non-wood exterior with a stain-grade interior option. Personally, I'm going to replace our not very good steel entry door with a paintable fiberglass door at some point not too long from now-we get full afternoon sun on the front door).

Re: Material selection for doors...

#3

JL

Re: Material selection for doors...

JL

>Poplar is nice, paintable and easily worked. I'd give it a "rinse" with water before the final sanding if you are planning on using latex.

As far as exterior doors are concerned, maple might work if you use a good spar varnish

Re: Material selection for doors...

#4

Re: Material selection for doors...

David Yoho

>Any suggestions on which of these materials would be our best choice also considering durability issues among these soft woods?

Although poplar takes paint great, it's a little soft. My choice would be birch because it's harder and also takes paint great.

As for the exterior door, unless you're dead set on wood, have you considered a fiberglass door? They can be grain-painted to look most persuasively like wood. Otherwise, I don't see why you couldn't use a hard maple for the door as long as it had a high quality protective finish. My reasoning is that maple has such a tight grain and is very hard.

David