Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Particleboard kitchen cabinets

Posts

Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#1

Particleboard kitchen cabinets

Nathan

>(I know, ewwww.)

I'm gearing up to build our new kitchen and I talked the wife into custom cabinets built by yours truly in addition to custom cabinet doors, etc.

So I'm getting close to building the first cabinet and I'm wondering what the best joinery method is for particleboard. I'm guessing that it's dowels and regular PVA glue.

Anyone care to comment? I'd especially welcome ideas on the assembly process, how to apply the glue, clamping, etc. from those more experienced than me (which is about all of you here, I think...)

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#2

Particleboard carcases, doors will be solid wood

Nathan

>

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#3

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Consider using MDF for the boxes with 3/8 plywood backs. There are screws for joining MDF. Those with PVA will be more than enough. Also consider European style adjustable hinges and full overlay doors and full overlay drawer faces.

Clint

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#4

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets *LINK*

Nathan

>Thanks for replying, Clint. I will definitely be using the European-style adjustable hinges and I'll go with the plywood back as you suggest.

As for MDF over particleboard, I have no problem with that in theory but in practice, PB is just so much easier to get. I can take my cut list down to the Borg and they cut and edge-band it to my specifications.

Your post gave me the idea of using Confirmat screws instead of dowels - now I know why the local woodworker supply shop has the Confirmats displayed in such a prominent location right by the cash register.

As for the doors, my wife saw a kitchen that she liked and wants (well, "demands" might be a better word) a particular design - rail-and-stile frames with narrow T&G slats instead of a raised panel inside. Painted white. She likes the look. Whatever she wants, I'll build it. I'm just glad I was able to talk her out of "scuffing" the white paint to make it look older.

By the way, here's a link to the MDF versus particleboard discussion at Woodweb knowledge base - if anyone's interested.


MDF versus Particleboard discussion at Woodweb

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#5

I wouldn't!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I don't recommend particle board or MDF for kitchen cabinets. It isn't strong and will sag under its own weight over time. If you are investing major hours in making your own cabinets, use a better grade material. Plywood at least is a bit more durable, though the quality of stuff from the two Borgs is more questionable than ever, but should be sufficient for carcases.

Lee

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#6

Don't take this wrong...

David Yoho

>They're your cabinets but...

If you're planning to use particleboard simply because it's convenient to find, inexpensive compared to other materials, and/or because the local Borg is going to cut and band it for you - saving you that work, then I question whether you're really set up to handle this project in the first place.

The main reason for building your own cabinets is to get a better quality product in the end. Maybe I'm wrong but, in my opinion, neither particleboard nor MDF translates to quality. Both will be very heavy and may not stand the test of time. If you're dead set on building your own, you might try to investigate other material choices, even if it means ordering your sheet goods from a source other than the Borg and waiting on them.

Another idea might be to order your cabinet boxes unfinished from either the Borg, or one of the places that do that type of thing. Although it might not seem like it up front, it might be cheaper in the long run. Then you make the doors and drawers from solid stock yourself. This way you save yourself some headaches, get the job done quicker, and end up with a better product in the end.

Still, nothing beats doing it all yourself using good quality materials and sound construction and joinery. However, if you're not set up to handle large sheet goods, don't have the space a project of this magnitude requires, or all the skills needed to tackle it yet, then there's no shame in subbing out parts you can't easily do and tackle those you can. Might be something to consider!

David

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#7

Re: Don't take this wrong...

Bill White

>"Engineered" products have a place in cabinetry. You gotta remember that there was a time when there was no plywood. All cabinetry/furniture was all wood.

Same holds true with wood flooring today. Laminate, engineered, or solid wood.

We can all be purists if we want, but to what end. MDF multi-pass routed doors can be painted, glazed, etc. with good results. All wood face frames for sure. Frameless? Knock yourself out, but most will be melamine or ply.

Bill with flame suit handy.

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#8

Re: Don't take this wrong...

John Pappas

>David, I agree with you for this reason. WATER! In a kitchen water leaks are not uncommon. It is for this reason that I insisted on plywood cabinets when our kitchen was redone. Water in time can cause damage to plywood also, but I believe that ply would withstand any leak better then particle board or MDF. Just my humble opinion.

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#9

flame suit handy

David Yoho

>Actually, I'm the one figuring he'd need the flame suit. I still stand by what I said though. I've replaced several customer's kitchen and bath drawer fronts and doors made from MDF because they swelled and "exploded" from prolonged exposure to moisture. Particleboard is great for use under laminate countertop material but doesn't hold fasteners as well as plywood or solid wood does and therefore I don't like it for cabinet case construction. I know the advances with today's glues sort of counters this notion but it's still a fact that I think is important not to overlook.

One nice choice (there's others) for cabinet case material is the prefinished maple plywood. This eliminates having to apply a finish to the inside after constructing the cabinet box. They don't sell this at the Borg and so it might take someone living in a more rural area a little more effort to try to locate a source. In the end, though, I think it's worth it.

I used to build my own computers because I could do it for less and get what I wanted. I don't anymore because I can order one almost as cheap or cheaper. The only reason to build one myself now would be to get EXACTLY what I want in it. Building your own kitchen cabinets is about the same. You might save some money due to labor costs but you can't beat the price of materials. This leaves getting exactly what you want and better quality than mass-produced as the motivating factor.

Therefore, if I'm going to go through all that work to build all those "boxes" myself, danged if I wouldn't want to use something other than particleboard. If I wanted particleboard, I might just as well by them from the Borg as save myself the trouble.

Okay, I'm prepared to take the heat. I don't mean to sound "holier than thou" on this subject and I hope I don't offend anyone - that's not my intent.

[flame suit on]

David

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#10

Re: flame suit handy

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>David, I agree with you.

Further if the Borg is handy and Melamine cabinet boxes will do, I just buy the pre-bored, pre-banded, 12, 15, or 24 inch wide Melamine, cut to length, dado for the back, glue and screw together, slide in the back, and I'm done.

Same thing for the kitchen cabinets. The sink cabinet got all seams caulked with the white seam fill as a sealer, so when the drain leaks it doesn't ruin the box. Unfortunately that has been tested at my house, and it worked!

My two cents. But my flame suit is at the cleaners!

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#11

Re: Water!!!

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I'm slowly redoing the kitchen at my son and daughter-in-law's place. Prefinished maple ply, made in the US, from the local pro plywood & lumber place. The counter tops came from IKEA, their choice, and didn't look bad. But, for some reason, over the dishwasher, they have swelled from the steam, in less than a year. I'm very glad that I didn't use MDF anywhere else.

For me, the killer would be the weight of the MDF in the shop. It's so much heavier than 3/4" cabinet ply, which isn't lightweight. That's hard on the back, full sized.

What's killing me is the WB poly on the door frames right now. Can't get it to level without bubbles. Should have just used the oil-based old reliable...

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#12

Appreciation and some more thoughts

Nathan

>I appreciate all the replies - lots. No one here to talk these things through with other than my wife, and she's more into the "final look" than the technical issues of materials, fasteners, joinery etc.

You're right - I'm not set up to break down full sheets - the slider on my saw doesn't have enough travel. But every shop around here has a big slider so getting someone to format the sheets would not be a big problem.

As for materials, I do hear what you're saying. I'm not religiously inclined to particleboard; other options simply didn't occur to me. I can get plywood here, but there's another option I'd like to run past you. It's called "lathboard" and it's basically a bunch of roughsawn spruce laths (stickers) sandwiched between two layers of poplar veneer. This is what virtually all cabinetry in this country used to be made of (I know because I've salvaged a lot of it from old sewing machine cabinets, etc.) - it's a nice material to work with since it's real wood.

I have some 8/4 poplar in the shop, so I could glue strips of that onto the front edges to hide the spruce core.

Anyway, I'm glad I asked this question here! The spruce-core board will be a much stronger material than particleboard, especially considering the weight these cabinets will carry - I forgot to mention the wife is dead set on stone countertops!

I might add that this is a small kitchen. Only six cabinets total - all lowers, no cabinets above the counter needed as we have a walk-in pantry. Even so, it will be a big project - no question about that! But I've been dreading it for so long that it's beginning to get ridiculous. At some point, I've got to roll up my sleeves and dive in.

All encouragement welcomed!

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#13

Here's what "lathboard" looks like *LINK*

Nathan

>One picture at the top, scroll down for another with a European-beech front edge glued on. Maybe someone will chime in - can you get this stuff in the U.S. and if so, what is it called? (I know it's not called "lathboard", obviously, but what?)


Images of "lathboard"

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#14

At the cleaners

David Yoho

>Carol, I hope they don't use that stuff that removes the flame retardant. Things tend to get hot after that - I know ;-)

David

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#15

Re: Appreciation and some more thoughts

David Yoho

>Nathan, I have no idea where or if "lathboard" plywood is available. If you have a place in your area that supplies the cabinetmaking trade, check with them to find out what's available. If you end up using a veneered plywood for your boxes, the next step will be choosing the proper grade so you don't spend more than you have to.

Places that sell to the cabinetmaking folks usually carry from A-1 down (A-1 being the best). Remember, you only need plywood with one good "show" side for the boxes (inside) except for the end cabinet/s where you would see the inside and the outside. As Carol suggested above, Melamine-covered panels might be another possibility.

There are times when we all walk the line between our wants and our budget. Only you can decide what you can afford for this project. Even with the small number of cabinets you mentioned needing, your materials choices could drain the wallet quickly. If you're like most folks here, you don't have a money tree growing in the back yard and you're probably trying to find the best bang for your buck. Be persistent, do your homework by checking out what's available to you, come back here and ask more questions if you need to, develop a plan, and get to work -- boom, it's that simple (easy for me to say!).

David

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#16

Forgot to add...

David Yoho

>If you can, take a look at the new issue of Fine Woodworking Magazine. There's a nice article by Norm Abram (he's on the cover) on tips for building kitchen cabinets. You might pick up some good ideas there or find something you hadn't thought about.

David

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#17

'Lathboard' = lumber core plywood?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>

Re: Particleboard kitchen cabinets

#18

Re: At the cleaners

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Oh, gees, Dave! I forgot to remind them. Hope its not too late. I'll call them as soon as they open!

Darn things are expensive to replace. :)