Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Sketchup Question

Posts

Sketchup Question

#1

Sketchup Question

Tony - Memphis

>Just trying to learn some new tricks with sketchup and I was trying to put a hole through a pyramid. I tried all sorts of ways to intersect and such, but it wouldn't ever leave me with a hole. Any ideas?

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Sketchup Question

#2

Re: Sketchup Question

Tony - Memphis

>Well, one way I was able to do it was to model a half of the pyramid (could be a tapered leg, whatever - an angled surface) and then copied it and pasted and rotated 180�, then moved it to mate up with the original half. I can get a cylinder to make a hole by intersecting as long as it cuts through a face (ie part of the circle is outside the model).

This Sketchup stuff is so different that the solid modeling stuff I have done before. Its really challenging (frustrating!).

Tony

Re: Sketchup Question

#3

Re: Sketchup Question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Do you want the hole to be vertical down through the middle of the pyramid, vertical but offset from the center, horzontal, perpendicular to a face, what? A blind hole or all the way through?

Re: Sketchup Question

#4

Re: Sketchup Question

Tony - Memphis

>Here is waht I was trying to do...

When I was trying to do it with a whole pyramid, I would get all the lines in place, but the whole was not open. I tried all sorts of ways, but I had no success.

Tony


img

Re: Sketchup Question

#5

Re: Sketchup Question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I tried using the intersection method (called a boolean subtraction by the rest of the world) to subtract a cylinder from a pyramid and it seems to work OK here.

Booleans in Sketchup are clunky. To do a boolean subtraction have to do the intersection then select all the pieces you don't want and erase or move them. Did you select and delete the oval/circles left on the triangular faces by the intersection? (I assume you know this.)

If deleting the ovals/circles did not make a hole in the pyramid, was the pyramid a component, perhaps pulled from a library? If you try to subtract a cylinder made from extruded circle from a component, it won't work. (at least in my version of Sketchup) You have to explode the component first.

JKJ (an occasional sketchup user, not an expert)

Re: Sketchup Question

#6

Re: Sketchup Question

Tony - Memphis

>Yeah, very clunky! But, I am using the free version, so I am trying to get as much out of it as I can without whining.

I tried to delete those ovals, but I never figured out how to. COuld be that the whole thing worked and I just didn't know how to delete them. When I click close to the oval, I end up deleting a segment of the oval.

Tony

Re: Sketchup Question

#7

Re: Sketchup Question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>When I click close to the oval, I end up

>deleting a segment of the oval.

Tony,

To delete the oval, with the select tool click once somewhere on the face in the center of the oval, not on the edge. Don't click and drag. The flat center faces of the oval (and not the edge segments) should be highlighted. Press the delete key.

The image attached shows the two objects ready for intersection, the oval selected (faint yellow selection highlight), and the oval deleted.

From what I understand, the free version is nearly identical in function to the pro version. It apparenetly has certain limitations primarily in output options and quality to entice people using it professionally to buy the pro version. I believe the tools and modeling functions are identical, however I have not yet tried the free version.

JKJ


img

Re: Sketchup Question

#8

Re: Sketchup Question

Tony - Memphis

>Well, I just figured out something by accident. I picked on the oval, but there was no highlight, I then clicked delete and the oval was deleted leaving the hollow cylinder. Very strange. Thanks for the help. I'm just trying to get good enough to make it a useful tool. I do 99% of my drawing in 2D with IntelliCad (I'm still using the old free version). Its a great program with little overhead and as an old AutoCad user, it is very familiar to me. I really miss the free solids modeler that Pro/E was giving away a few years ago (Pro Designer I think it was). That was a fantastic true 3D solids modeler.

Tony