Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Table saw advice

Posts

Table saw advice

#1

Table saw advice

Helen

>Hi there.

I'm editor of CWB magazine and familiar with a lot of woodworking equipment. But when it comes to making a purchase for my new son-in-law for his hobbyist woodworking shop, I'd like to get some "real world" advice. He is upgrading from a Craftsman and thinking about the Delta 36-980, 10-inch, 1-1/2 hp, left-tilt contractor's saw. Will this be a good next step for him? Should he spend a little more to get a higher horsepower now and, if so, any recommended models that won't break the bank?

Thanks for your feedback.

Helen

Re: Table saw advice

#2

Re: Table saw advice

Greg Haugen

>Helen,

I'd look at a Hybrid Saw, a cross between a contractor and cabinet saw. Fine Woodworking (Tools and Shops issue) just did a "buyers guide" on these saws. They rated the Woodtek, from Woodworker's Supply, as the top choice and best value. It's right around $700 and 2hp. Steel City's and Craftsman's hybrid saws have trunnions that are attached to the cabinet, making adjustments easier than the other saws which are attached under the table. This shouldn't detour from some of the other saws on this fact alone since this adjustment should be a "one time job". It is easier on those two saws though. Hybrids are built just a bit better than contractor's saws and their prices are really becoming comparable to good contractor's saws. Jet, Dewalt, Steel City, Delta, Woodtek, Grizzly, General International, and Shop Fox all have hybrid saws.

Depending on the saw he had from Craftsman the hybrids maybe two steps up. There's only $200-$300 more between contractor saws and Hybrids. I think Hybrids are the most saw for the money. If the extra is an issue I've heard good things about Home Depot's Ridgid 10" 1 1/2 horse saw, $550. No matter the saw, as long as he has an option for service he should be fine. Ridgid has a lot of service centers around as well as Delta and others.

Hope that Helps,

Greg Haugen

Re: Table saw advice

#3

What is CWB Magazine?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>What is CWB Magazine? I believe I've seen copies at one of my clients who is a custom millworks shop. Is is a magazine geared towards the industry side of woodworking? I searched online and wasn't able to find anything definitive.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Table saw advice

#4

I'll chime in ...

Mike Farinella

>OK Helen, here's my take. You will get a myriad of opinions on this subject - here's mine. If he is a serious hobbyist AND dust collection may be in his future, then don't get a contractors saw. I am a hobbyist , have a contractors saw with tons of upgrades, and the only regret is there isn't any dust collection. If you can't afford a cabinet saw, then get a hybrid. Good luck and Merry Christmas.

Re: Table saw advice

#5

Re: I'll chime in ...

Greg Haugen

>Very good point about the inability for adequate dust collection on contractor saws.

Greg

Re: Table saw advice

#6

Re: Table saw advice

Ray DuBose - Memphis TN

>I have a Delta Contractor Saw, The Delta 36-431 with the Beisemeyer Fence.

I work out of my garage and if I had it all to do over again I would not get a contractor saw. I would have gotten a Cabinet Saw. I didn't do my homework at the time and thought the contractor saw would be smaller but the motor hanging out the back makes it a bigger footprint. It has no dust collection either. Don't get me wrong, it's still a nice saw and handles my needs. When I purchased it, Hybrid saws were just coming out and most were more expensive at the time or didn't have cast iron tops. They seem to have gotten better and are a good middle solution as they house the motor inside.

Ray

Re: Table saw advice

#7

Link to magazine *LINK*

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Follow the 'magazine' link on the web page. You have to drill down a couple levels but eventually you will get to the individual issues. It's a good resource for the pro cabinet shop. I like the ads :)

Ed


CWB parent company

Re: Table saw advice

#8

Re: Table saw advice

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>Boy I wish I had a MIL like Helen. Mine always gave me the Honey-Do jobs my FIL couldn't or wouldn't do. And on top of that she gave me her daughter.I think there was one time she gave me a tie or maybe some Old Spice aftershave. Some guys have all the luck.

Re: Table saw advice

#9

Re: Table saw advice

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Hi Helen,

Sweeten the pot for him and link him with the fine bunch here, as well. I we love new folks joining us and his participation (or just lurking) would be welcomed by the 'regulars' here.

As for saws,I personal have a cabinet saw, but it was the cost of today's hybrid saws back when I got it. It replace a bench top and a contractor's saw. I have never looked back. Smaller foot print, easy to keep in tune, dust collection, etc. What's not to like?

Quality tools only cause pain (in the pocketbook) upon the initial purchase. "Saving money" with lesser tools only means that you get to buy them again, costing much more in the end. Not mention frustration and inaccuracies of lesser tools.

Good on you for helping him out.

Re: Table saw advice

#10

Re: Table saw advice

Tony - Memphis

>This is always a big debate. I have been using a similar saw (Delta 34-444) for over ten years. I have never had any issues with the performance for the work I do. I've always thought it was a good saw and was a good investment. To qualify, I'm not picky about dust collection and I build furniture. Most of the wood I work with is 5/4 or less mahogany, cherry, and maple. I added a dust chure under my saw and it works pretty well. A cabinet saw was not in my budget. Sure, I could have waited, but then I would have been not woodworking while I was waiting (and it would have been quite a while!). I'm not familiar with the Craftsman models, so I'm not sure where his would stand with a new contractor's saw. I guess my main point is that you don't need a cabinet saw to build nice stuff.

Tony

Re: Table saw advice

#11

PS....

Tony - Memphis

>Actually, that was a dust CHUTE, not chure! I don't really see what the issue is about dust collection on these saws. I added the chute and a couple of pieces of plywood over the back and it collects dust just fine. I never have to sweep under it anyway.

My mom works at the High Point Furniture Market and sends me copies of your magazine now and then. I enjoy looking at them. Interesting to see the profiles of the businesses and the new technology in the field. I'll probably get a handful of copies when I visit for Christmas next week.

Re: Table saw advice

#12

JL

Re: Table saw advice

JL

>As others have said, a good hybrid or an inexpensive cabinet saw would not be that much more than the Delta 36-980.

It all depends on what space he has available to him and what power he has available. Cabinet saws are usually 230 V - if he doesn't have easy access to 230 V, he would be better off with a hybrid. Steel City has their lower grade of cabinet saws with a 1.75 hp motor (which means they can use 115 V with a 20 amp breaker) - this is a rough equivalent to a hybrid. If he doesn't have a dedicated shop area (or even if he does), he'll probably need a mobile base no matter which way he goes.

Re: Table saw advice

#13

Re: Table saw advice

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think his justification for a choice he would make is most important. For his actual need and level of use, what would he select? Think of it as a business decision.

Clint

Re: Table saw advice

#14

Re: Table saw advice

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>Helen...liked the picture of the Beatles...I'd let him pick his next saw...don't buy one for him as some guys have a real personal attachment to their tools and if he didn't like it, then there could be a little disharmony...you can't go wrong with a good cabinet saw...people disagree about which one to get... but once they get a cabinet saw, the level of satisfaction is very high and there is seldom a need to get a different saw from there...if he is really committed to woodworking as a life-long activity, he would make this purchase once.

Re: Table saw advice

#15

Re: What is CWB Magazine?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>It's also Childrenwear Buyer magazine (UK)!

http://www.ncwa.co.uk/cwb.html

And Coaching Women's Basketball magazine

http://www.wbca.org/Advertising.asp

CWB is also the Canadian Wheat Board, Cival War Brigade, and Cinema Without Borders but fortunately they don't seem to publish magazines.

JKJ

Re: Table saw advice

#16

Re: Table saw advice

Helen

>Thanks to everyone for great advice. I appreciate getting your opinions as actual users of these saws. I always tend to think it's wise to make an investment in the best you can get, especially if you plan to have something a long time. Your comments help a lot.

Happy holidays!

Helen

P.S. CWB is a magazine for professional shops doing custom cabinets, millwork, store fixtures, furniture, etc. Basically means people have to figure out how to make a living doing the woodworking they love! Web site is www.iswonline.com.

Re: Table saw advice

#17

One more tidbit:

Barry Irby

>I have had a Rockwell/Delta Contractors Saw for 37 years and I like it. About thirty five years ago I burned up the motor that came with it and added a 2 hp. 230 volt motor. I changed the pulley and went to a link belt. (Not much help). I added a dust chute that is about 90% effective. I put on a Biesemeyer Fence I got at Lowes on clearance. Couldn't stand the idea of putting a $400 fence on a $350 saw, but for $80 I could not resist. I also covered the grid tables and extension table I added with Formica. There is a router in the side table. So, me and this saw are old friends and I have too much effort if not money invested in it to change now.

OTOH, if I were buying a saw today and I had the coins, I would look at the SawStop. I believe they are coming out with a Contractors version. Its a lot of money, but I like having all my parts attached. I sawed the tip of a thumb off when I was fifteen. Mangled it so badly the doctor wanted to take the last joint off. I was having none of that, so he taped it up, put a shield around it and gave it a kiss for luck. I still have it and am glad I do, but I was young then and my current age it would never heal. And today, you would go to the hospital and they would spend the cost of several saws on it.

SawStops saws are somewhat controversial. Some say they increase carelessness and others say they are life savers, or finger savers at least. I think from what I know, they have inherent quality as good as or similar to other brands and the improvement of possibly saving you a serious accident.

Re: Table saw advice

#18

Re: What is CWB Magazine?

Ron Hildreth

>Mark,

CWB Magazine is "Custom Woodworking Business" Magazine. It comes to my house for free (how they got my name I'll never know), but about two weeks ago called me and wanted me to renew my subscription for $xx.xx. Told them I wasn't interested.

Ron in Iowa

Re: Table saw advice

#19

Re: Table saw advice

knotscott

>I think the advice you're getting in favor of a hybrid is spot on. If a full 3hp cabinet saw isn't in the picture, a hybrid is the way to go for a new saw. They're essentially updated contractor saws that have addressed most of the issues associated with contractor saws and their outboard motors. The hybrid has better dust collection, smaller footprint, shorter drive belt, more mass and stability, and in many cases, slightly beefed up and updated trunnions and carriage. In a nutshell, there's little to no design advantages with a contractor saw over a hybrid. The Delta contractor saw is a very good version of a nearly obsolete technology.

Re: Table saw advice

#20

Re: Table saw advice

David Yoho

>The Steel City 35601 is a hybrid saw.

David

Re: Table saw advice

#21

Re: I'll chime in ...

Chuck Lenz

>No dust collection for a Contractors tablesaw ? If you don't have it, you can get it. Good dust collection on a Contractors tablesaw isn't imposible.