Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Pine or Spruce board indentification

Posts

Pine or Spruce board indentification

#1

Pine or Spruce board indentification

Bill Howatt

>Is there an easy way to tell if a dressed board is pine or spruce?

Thanks,

Bill

Re: Pine or Spruce board indentification

#2

Re: Pine or Spruce board indentification

David Yoho

>Spruce generally has smaller and much tighter knots and is more white in color. The one sure way I know to tell the difference is the way they smell when cut with a power saw. Pine smells... well, like pine but spruce does not. To me it has a buttery smell.

David

Re: Pine or Spruce board indentification

#3

Ellis Walentine

Pine is creamier

Ellis Walentine

>Spruce has a bolder grain, with wider summerwood rings. It's a lot trickier to work, too. It tears out easier with hand and power tools.

Ellis

Re: Pine or Spruce board indentification

#4

Re: Pine or Spruce board indentification

JohnKJordan in East TN

>Bill,

In Hoadley's book "Identifying Wood", the primary distinguishing feature of pine vs spruce is the resin canal size: pine has large resin canals while spruce has small. However, using relative information like this without prior experience in comparing the softwoods may be difficult!

He also refers to separating the species by color reaction to a chemical reagent. He doesn't provide details, but gives a reference: Barton, G.M., 1973, Chemical color tests for Canadian woods. Canadian Forest Industries February: 57-62.

Wouldn't it be great love to have a little wood ID kit with all the chemical, fluorescent, and photomacrograph tests at your fingertips?!

JKJ

Re: Pine or Spruce board indentification

#5

Thanks

Bill Howatt

>Thanks for the responses. Because of a lack of suitable samples of pine except for a lousy bowl I turned, the pine smell test was what I used. I just couldn't make up my mind about color or growth rings and I certainly don't have a cool chemical test kit :).

I was surprised at the lack of "smell" in the spruce piece. The rack I took it from at the local HD did have it labelled as spruce. I'm making a base for a Guinea Pig and some say that pine can be bad for them should they eat it (not everybody agrees). Interestingly, it is the smell that attracts them to it.

Bill