Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

Posts

Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#1

Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>This is No. 1 in a new series. Looking at your lumber can tell you a lot about how it was produced, and how it is going to work. There will be no logical order to these short posts. When I get an informative picture I will post the message.

The picture shows a section of a cherry board with a serious crack running along one edge as well as a section from the adjoining end of this board. This board was FAS clear lumber when it came off the saw. The crack formed during drying. No amount of end coating or drying management would have prevented it. Why?

The piece cut from the end of the board tells the story. Note this board contained the center (pith) of the tree and that the cracks radiate from this center. For reasons that I don't know, the centers of trees typically crack while drying and nothing will prevent it. For this reason logs are turned during sawing to saw the boards from around the center. The center is isolated into a chunk(cant), often 3 x 5", that goes to the pallet factory to be converted into pallets, or 7 x 5" to be used for rail ties.

In cases the sawing strategy leaves the center of the tree in boards. The unfortunate person that buys this lumber (me for example) will see it crack during drying.

In my hands cherry centers are the worse for cracking, but it occurs in everything I have ever dried. I don't think it is predictable how far out from the center the lumber is likely to crack, but 1-2" is typical.


img

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#2

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

Stuart Hough

>Thanx, Bill! That gave me something to watch for when I go out to get lumber from now on. It almost makes sense that the cracks would start from there. I wonder if it might be that the pith releases moisture at such a slower rate that the fibers outside it can't physically hold together after they have dried past a certain point. It would be like wet rawhide drying around a log...tightening up to a point that it can't stretch anymore and giving way. Just a rambling thought....

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#3

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

Sgian Dubh

>I think you know why Bill, but you're just not letting on, ha, ha. The first twenty or so years of a trunk or branch's growth is different to what follows later and is known as juvenile wood.

It's got uncharacteristic shrinkage features due to the softness or lower density of the growth tissue. The growth rings are usually further apart than growth rings in mature heartwood: it shrinks more radially and tangentially, with length shrinkage being sometimes 10 or 20 times greater than normal heartwood longitudinal shrinkage numbers, usually about 1/10 of 1%, or 0.1%.

Not surprisingly it often causes cracks and faults as in your example. Slainte.

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Simple explanation

Jesper, Denmark

>The wood shrinks as it dries - and it shrinks across the fibres but along the growth rings - in a circular fashion. In a board sawn without the center, the shrinkage caused warps and cupping. When the center is included, the part of the board with growthrings that are unbroken, has no place to shrink to, and must break somewhere as the outer rings shink more and get too short.

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#5

not so simple, I think

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>While I am sure both your and Richard's explanations contribute, I think there is more involved. A 1 " cherry stick will not split when it dries, yet the 1" board, with pith, split severely. In fact, logs up to several inches in diameter usually don't split when they dry. In old trees the center can be shattered even before it dries. Maybe something in the aging process of the tree weakens the central wood. Or the combination of juvenile wood and older wood sets up stress. I have seen the heart of the tree spontaneously split minutes after felling a tree. This observation suggests that the center of the tree is under tension for some reason, even before drying.

Whatever, mills typically avoid including this central wood in their high grade lumber. However, when you are sawing for rift or quarter grained woods this central wood may be included in the boards and it will split when it dries. Note that the piece in the picture is quarter sawed.

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#6

Re: not so simple, I think

Barry Irby

>Bill, This is interesting.

Could it be that the differential shrinkage rates are the problem? A small piece of square stock would likely contain only juvenile wood as should a "log" from a sapling sized tree.

If a board like yours had the pith down one side and lets say it were parallel to edge, if you ripped that board, would that "solve" the problem? In effect, could you upgrade the balance of the board by ripping an inch or two off the edge?

I have had quarter sawn boards sawed bark to bark and I ripped the pith out and glued them back together and they seem to do fine. (Walnut).

I also know that juvenile wood is the bane of the truss industry. Trusses made with juvenile wood will do what is known as Truss Lift and have been known to arch and lift off the center line walls as much as an inch or two. I have seen whole hacks of 2 X 4's that were obviously sawn from pines just big enough to get two 2 X 4's. A truss plant would not want those. I get called in on Home Inspections occasionally to explain why the ceiling is no longer on the walls. They lift in winter and fall in summer.

Essentially all landscape timbers and 4 X 4's (treated pine) are juvenile. Landscape timbers are the cores left over from making plywood. They are poorly treated and sold as a by product. My guess is 4 x4's are the result of "boxing the heart" in pine. Almost all of them have the pith in them and juvenile wood and they warp and twist as they dry.

Another question, why do (treated pine)4 x 4's tend to twist or rotate as they dry? One explanation I got was that the tree tried to "follow the sun" across the sky and actually twisted itself as it grew.

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#7

twist and shout

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Another question, why do (treated pine)4 x 4's tend to

>twist or rotate as they dry? One explanation I got was

>that the tree tried to "follow the sun" across the sky

>and actually twisted itself as it grew.

Hoadley states "Lumber from trees with spiral grain will invariably twist upon drying."

From my reading, there are two main causes of twisted grain. A tree can grow twisted and every board will have spiral grain, or spiral grain can be "caused" at the sawmill. Even a board cut from a straight-grained tree can contain spiraled grain due to misalignment when sawing.

Imaging a 4x4 taken from just to the right of the pith and where the near end is below the pith and the far end is above the pith. Visualize the grain down the board. That 4x4 will likely dry twisted.

This is something I watch for while sawing on my little mill, but a log with significant taper will require compromise. I suspect the priority in a large commercial sawmill is to maximize production rather than saw for optimum stability.

JKJ

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#8

Re: not so simple, I think

JohnKJordan in East TN

>>Note that the piece in the picture is quarter sawed.

A trivial observation, but it seems to me that any such board (thinner than it is wide) that contains the pith is quatersawn by definition.

As for cracking in juevenile wood, it can also be exacerbated by reaction wood in the log, say from tree which grew leaning to one side. I've had these split open suddenly with a loud crack.

JKJ

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#9

Re: not so simple, I think

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The fact that the radial shrinkage is less than the tangential shrinkage means that the circumference wants to shrink more than the radius for a given distance from the center. Something has to give, but it could mean just internal stresses rather than actual fracture. This is one factor which accounts for different drying schedules for different species. A walnut board containing pith often does not crack, for example.

In the case of a 1" branch of cherry, I suspect that since the circumference is equally exposed to drying, tiny radial cracks form all the way around and are not really visible. On a board that has end checking, there are often microscopic cracks in addition to easily visible cracks. On a board that has pith in it, the face near the pith is more exposed to drying than wood that is buried in the board, so this area is vulnerable to cracking. In addition, it takes a lot less force to break a radial crack from the pith to the face than to form a much deeper crack inside the board or to go from the pith toward the face at an angle. In a contest between the wood from pith to face and the wood from pith to edge, bulk wins out. I have often seen a board with pith right near the edge of the board where the crack went out to the edge rather than the face, the path of least resistance.

Re: Reading Your Boards-#1 checks

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: Treated pine

Dale Lenz

>>Landscape timbers are the cores left over from making plywood. They are poorly treated and sold as a by product<

More than likely the treated cores are from SYP. SYP heartwood does not accept treatment very well. Moral of the story, don't buy treated SYP with a large percentage of heartwood. SYP's sapwood accepts treatment VERY well.