Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

taking off tried and true

Posts

taking off tried and true

#1

taking off tried and true

McKay

>In the past I made a footboard using "tried and true" and liked the effect that it gave me on walnut. However, I am making a cherry display case and I do not care for the finish at all. It is dull and looks lack luster. Will alcohol remove all of the tried and true enough to put on something that will add a greater sheen?

Re: taking off tried and true

#2

Re: taking off tried and true

David Yoho

>You did not say which Tried & True Wood Finish you used -- there are three. All are Polymerized Linseed Oil based. I don't think alcohol is the right solvent to use for any of their finishes. I think mineral spirits is a better bet.

However, you asked about applying something else over top of what you have already applied. I don't believe you need to remove what's there first. I do believe you need to be sure what you've applied already is dry before proceeding. I think you can sand the surface with a 320-grit paper (lightly) and apply some other type of petroleum based product with good results.

The only caution is the word - DRY. Since Tried & True finishes do not contain additional dryers, you just need to be sure what's been applied IS dry. Linseed oil is a drying oil and will dry, but without the additional dryers it will take a little more time to do so.

David

Re: taking off tried and true

#3

No on the Alk

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>T&T is an oil finish which polymerizes to form a film. It will not "redissolve" like a solvent finish such as lacquer or shellac. At this point you have several options:

1. You can strip the piece back to "bare" wood. The longer you wait to do this, the more work it will be since polymerization is a relatively long process that can take weeks or more to complete (as opposed to mere "drying" of the applied finish by evaporation of the solvent thinner used [Yes Michael, I remembered!].

2. You can sand off most of the surface film, and then apply some other drying oil finish which you like better. You'll likely be changing paper a lot as the still-soft film will clog your grit pretty quickly.

3. You can treat what you have as a sealer coat, rough the surface as you would for reapplication, and then apply a different finish with a resin content to build some depth to the coating. A gloss oil poly or gloss Waterlox might do you well here.

4. You can set the piece aside and give it at least 10 days for the polimerization curing process to get the bulk of its work done, then abrade lightly and apply a evaporative topcoat like shellac or lacquer as the final finish.

My usual finiah for cherry is to apply a drying oil (Watco, Danish, etc.) to pop the grain, let that sit and cure for 2 weeks, sand lightly with 400 grit lubed with ms, wipe down to dry, apply a thin coat of fresh dewaxed 2lb. shellac to seal in the oil, and then, 24 hours later, apply my waterborne finish such as Enduro, General, Target, or Fuhr. I get some terrific depth and chatoyance with this routine, and I can tint each stage in order to blend the result to get a more uniform color on the cherry.

Hope this helps

Re: taking off tried and true

#4

Re: taking off tried and true

Jim Dillon

>McKay,

I've used a lot of T&T oil/varnish and like it, but you are right about the sheen. Have you tried putting on more than one coat? I have put on up to three coats on stuff and the sheen does grow a bit more but will never approach a gloss polyurethane, at least in my experience. Another trick I'm using more is to put an initial sealer coat of blond shellac on (1# cut), then the T&T. This really helps give the final finish more shine. As a side note, I once had to sand the sides of a poorly fit drawer that I had put three coats of T&T on and was surprised how difficult it was to remove once it had cured. I then reapplied T&T and everything was fine.

Jim