Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Floor Sander question (OT?)

Posts

Floor Sander question (OT?)

#1

Floor Sander question (OT?)

Barry Irby

>On one the Ask This Old House shows they were refinishing a hardwood floor. They had a machine that had four sanding disks under it. They appeared to be five or six inches in diameter. Has anyone used one of these machines? Are those disks just rotating or are they acting like random orbital sanders? I have a Floor that badly needs refinishing and I will have to sand the Vee grooves off it. Will this machine do it? Any feedback would be appreciated. And where would you look to rent one?

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#2

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

Gene Gauss

>I think Pat Copper reported his experience with one of these on The Wood Works website (www.woodworkslive.com)awhile ago and spoke quite highly of it. Maybe try a search on that site, or try to get him to respond directly. Gene Gauss

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#3

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

Nat Robison

>I've used the Varathane sanding machine rented from Lowes (3 ROS discs that rotate). It works well and was very clean. Not a lot of dust.

I think it's been mentioned here before that to sand out vee grooves in a floor might be beyond the capability of a machine. I had marks on my oak floor that couldn't be removed with repeated sanding on the lowest grit. If it can't remove such marks and gouges, I doubt it would be able to remove 1/16"-1/8" on the whole floor without possibly damaging the t-and-g portion. I may be wrong but you might be expecting too much.

Overall, my experience with the machine was a good one. I think the drum sanders are more agressive, if that's what you need.

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#4

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

Grant Smith

>Barry,

I just installed a new hardwood floor and then sanded and finished it. I used the Varathane machine at Menard's. Here are my thoughts on it and another heavier machine avaialble at rental centers.

-It has an orbital action, but it is achieved via a planetary geardrive design, and so it is a rigid rotational pattern. When you first start out, it will kind of hop around on you and make a funny growling sound on uneven surfaces. Once the floor starts getting smooth, it will settle down and operate smoothly.

-Smaller (3 disk) versus similar 4 disk machines available at rental centers. I believe the sandpaper is more expensive than that available at rental centers, too.

-Keep the dolly wheels on the floor. This machine doesn't operate like a floor buffer, and instead you drive it around with the wheels on the floor. Took me 20 minutes of fighting with it to figure that out when I started.

-I used one set of sandpaper of each grit (50, 80, 100) for every ten square feet of new floor. My floor was pretty level after install, but there were a few areas that took some time. The machines at rental centers have heavier grits available than Varathane offers.

-Overall, the machine did a nice job, but was rather slow. Dust collection was great, however. It is about the right solution for a single room or less than maybe 350 square feet. A larger area would warrant the 4 disk machine or maybe a drum sander.

-Keep the rougher grits away from any edge that drops off, or it will make swirl marks that the finer grits will take a long time to remove. Do these areas with an edger or orbital sander.

-Use more light to watch progress when sanding than will ever be on the floor. This will make it easy to see flaws and make sure it will look great when done.

- The varathane machine will fill its dust collector in about 15 minutes or so...I used my DC to clean the filter each time...otherwise it would be very messy. I believe the larger rental center machines can go half an hour or an hour on one DC bag...judging by a report that a friend of mine gave me that used one.

-I think that you will want to use 36 grit to remove the grooves, and plan to take a long time doing it. These are not fast machines, but they are more forgiving than drum sanders and can work right up against the walls with no problems.

What brand of flooring do you have? is it possible that it has a warranty on the finish?

Also note that I used Varathane oil based finish. I made the mistake of using the simulated lambswool applicator mop, which left fuzz all over in my floor. After 3 coats, I now need to scuff it and apply some finish with a better applicator. Pro's use a floor buffer with some strips of fine sandpaper under it to scuff the floor before the final coat. Most paint stores sell finish products that pros use, and I will use the applicators they use on the final coat on mine(though I will still use Varathane finish). I think the pros often use either a squeegee, or an applicator that looks like a piece of styrofoam with a fuzzy, spongy applicator material on one side. These are 12" long, 2" wide, and would make it fast work, even if it is hands and knees work.

My wife and I installed 550 square feet of ash floor, sanded and finished it using the Varathane sander and system in about a week. We worked full time on it, and then some.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#5

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

John E

>Like the other posts have mentioned, these are random orbit sanders. I rented one when I put new hardwood in my bedroom. They are not nearly as "dangerous" as a belt sander as far as sanding grooves in the floor, but are a lot slower. It took quite a while, even with heavy grit, to sand the putty I used to fill nail holes and small voids even. I don't think I would even attempt to remove old finish, much less "sand out the grooves" of an old floor. You will probably need a large belt sander for this, and then maybe follow it with the ROS. They should both be available at any tool rental place. Sorry, but I don't remember the price. Sandpaper was fairly expensive, if I recall.

HTH,

John

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#6

Did you note Tom's take on gloss poly?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>He stated that he uses gloss poly for the first two coats because "It's a harder finish than the semigloss or satin finish". He then finishes up with the semigloss as the last coat. I'm not an expert, but I think he's full of it on this issue; durability is not better with gloss as opposed to semigloss or satin in my experience. In fact, since the deglossing agent is silica,I think, gloss may be the least durable. Am I mistaken?

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#7

Re: Did you note Tom's take on gloss poly?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I don't know if you're mistaken on the durability issue, but I'm in agreement with him for another reason. In fact it irks me no end when I see Norm violate it. I'm not the finishing expert, either, by any means, but I believe I recall Michael Dresdner or Jeff Jewitt (or both) say that if you want a semi-gloss or less finish on a piece with multiple coats, only the last coat should have that reduced sheen as it's obtained by mixing an agent (such as the silica you mention) into the poly. Multiple coats of that reduced sheen product would make the finish cloudier in addition to the sheen effect. It sounds reasonable to me, which is why I believe it. And of course I read it on the internet.

Rod

Re: Floor Sander question (OT?)

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

That, and...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...I believe that the deglossing agent (flatting, dulling, etc.), be it silica or otherwise disrupts the polymer chains and crosslinks in the finish, thereby making it weaker. Kind of like eating a cookie while you're chewing gum--the gum (polymer) falls apart because of the cookie crumbs (dulling agent).

I don't know if that's the case, but it sounds good to me. And, like Rod said, virtually everyone I know in the finish business has always said to go with gloss for all but the final coat. That doesn't mean I do it when I refinish floors, though...I don't really notice a cloudiness difference, particularly becuase there usually isn't a crystal clear finish on a nearby floor to contrast a multi-coat satin finish.

Jason