>Going to breadboard a 4/4x30x48 table top in ash. Am about to cut the tenon, but figured I'd ask those here who have also done this, how thick and long a tenon y'all would use for this application. A half inch thick would, of course be easiest matched by my 1/2" sprial bit, and I figured a 1" deep tenon would be sufficient which just happens to match the size of the planer bit I use.
I built our mission style kitchen table a few years ago, and I used a 1/2" spline, blind ended, within the three 1 1/2" QS oak stock that was to become the table top. I didn't breadboard the ends. Worked very well for me, and still looks good!
what you propose will work just fine. When I do breadboard ends I place the tenon on the main table and the grove in the breadboard end. relative size of the tenons vs the remaining wood can vary widely and still be perfectly fine. There are some rules of thumb, like 1/3 of the thickness for the tenon, but ease of manufacturing is almost as important sometimes.
>Mark, the thickness of your tenons should be determined by the thickness of the top. In other words, if the finish top dimension is 7/8", the tenon should probably be around 3/8" thick. I wouldn't use 1/2" for a top that is less than about 1 1/4" thick.
The length of the tenon should be thought of in terms of how deep it must be in order to keep the breadboard from deflecting or breaking under extreme conditions of use. In other words, if your design calls for a breadboard end that is 5" wide, I wouldn't settle for 1" long tenons because Aunt Tillie could probably break the breadboard end off if she sits too hard on the end of the table. In this case, a 2 - 2 1/2" long tenon would be better.
Usually, the drill is to decide on the maximum tenon length needed, then cut a full-width tenon that length on the end of the tabletop, then notch out between the tenons, leaving just a stub tenon, say 1/2" long between the full-length tenons. The number of full-length tenons depends on the width of the table. On a 30" wide top, you might settle for three tenons, one in the middle and two near the outside edges. Then plow a groove in the breadboard end to the depth of your stub tenon and mortise deeper for the full-length tenons. Make all the mortises wide enough to allow for the top to expand and/or contract. I usually drawbore all the tenons, but I slot the holes in the outer ones to allow them to move laterally.
I'm thinking the breadboards will be 3" wide (less than the body stock)
Plan to fix (glue/screw on the two center boards than drawbore and screw in a slot the two outside boards. This is for a coffee table that will be trestle style.
Had not thought of the haunched and stub tenons. Was going to use a single tenon stopped 1" from the end.
>A full width tenon takes out too much material from the breadboard, especially if it is long enough, e.g., at least half the width of the end. You need the integrity of the material between the mortises to keep the breadboard from flapping open.
Also, with a 1.15" top, 1/2" is going to be pretty thick for a tenon. You can get away with those 5/16" shoulders and nobody will ever know, but ideally 3/8" is the magic number IMO.
>Every mortise and tenon joint is designed for a reason. If you can visualize the reason -- usually the maximum stress expected plus a safety factor -- your intuition will generally steer you right. Rules of thumb are no substitute for at least a cursory analysis of the vectors and the engineering issues.
A mortise-and-tenon joint has several key ingredients, notably the length, width and thickness of the tenon and the surrounding mortise cheeks, the quality of the gluing interface between them, and the joint shoulders where they meet. Tenon length affects the joint strength in two ways: it determines the relative amount of glue surface and it provides leverage to keep the mortise piece from twisting or racking. The amount of leverage provided depends on the species and the tenon dimensions. The amount of leverage required depends on the stress-in-use scenario I mentioned above.
In this case, I'm making a case for "longer is better," not " shorter is strong enough." Three 1" long tenons into a 3" hardwood rail, with 1/2" tongue between them, should supply enough leverage to resist the heftiest of Aunt Tillies. The thickness of the tenons is probably not an issue either, since several 3/8" tenons surrounded by 3/8" mortise cheeks, coupled with the tongues -- assuming a reasonably close fit -- and glued and screwed or pegged, will be strong enough. So, the question is, how much extra strength or superiority is needed for this joint? My answer is probably not much -- maybe none -- but if you have the ability to mortise 1 1/2" or 2" deep, why not do it? There will definitely be some marginal increase in strength, it is likely that the parts will be in better alignment (unless you make the mortises and/or tenons crooked), there is more glue area (on the center tenon at least), and it will result in less strain on the shoulders (the fulcrum of the leverage situation) in case of torture-test conditions.
I will confess to generally erring on the safe side of engineering, especially if it comes at no greater cost or effort.
>While 1 or 1-1/4 tenons would probably be "enough", my 3/8" mortiser chisel set will cut to 2-1/4" and the up-cut spiral router bit will do 2" [if I wanted to go to a 1/2" tenon] so the intuition says to extend the tenon as far as I can.
Top shoulder of the breadboard will be 1/4" thick with the bottom cut thicker to give more meat under the joint for the drawbores' strength.