This is a tree !!
Dan Donaldson
>Glad it wasn't me that had to cut it down, especially with the tools in the picture ;-)
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
This is a tree !!
Dan Donaldson
>Glad it wasn't me that had to cut it down, especially with the tools in the picture ;-)
Re: This WAS a tree !!
Dale Lenz
>Looks to be near 20' across, thanks for the pic.
Re: This is a tree !!
Frank G
>I'm just sorry it was cut down.
Proof that Leprechauns do exist!
Jay in Tx
>Just kidding. Man, I wonder how long it took to fell that big boy?!
So where's Gulliver?
Alan Young
>
How long it took to cut down this tree
wilbur
>6 hours.
1 hour to cut down the tree.
1 hour spent sharpening the saw.
4 hours on the Pony Express to argue whether the saw should be sharpened with Scary Sharp or waterstones.
:@)
Re: This is a tree !!
Barry Irby
>There are stories about felling huge mahogany trees in Honduras. Supposedly they built a platform around the tree above the buttresses. At that point the trees were 12 or 15' in diameter. Tow men would spend up to two years cutting the tree down with axes and fell it toward the river or stream. Then they would cut it up and roll the logs into the water and float them out. If the tree fell the wrong way and they could not roll it into the river, it just got left there. The were then floated over to Florida where there was a huge bandsaw mill. Hmm, wonder if any sank along the way???
So, your job today and tomorrow and .... is to chop on that tree.
...but how'd they move it ?
Pete in Holland, MI
>Have seen many photos of large trees cut down in the redwood forests, but often wondered how they got such large logs out of the woods.
I've always heard . . .
steve mackay
>and seen many programs about the grit, determination and ingenuity of that era but no matter how hard I try I still can't wrap my little, modern, pampered mind around getting a hand powered saw through such a massive chunk of wood. Ranks right up there with stacking big stones high enough to get a Pyramid !
clearing the gullets
Tom Sontag - St. Louis
>Endurance and determination explains howtwo men can cut down a monster like that by hand. But the saw shown would seemingly always have most of its teeth buried inside the cut and I can't see how they clear the gullets to allow more cutting action. I also wonder how they gt these things out of the woods.
Re: Link with lots of info *LINK*
Brian in Brighton
>Here is an e-book called "The Project Gutenberg eBook, Handwork in Wood, by William Noyes". I would not recommend it for dial up as it's a big link. It shows trains with sections like this on each train car.
I do not have time to go thru it all yet, but it came up on a Google image search for "big log on train".
Looks like a lot of work and a shame to destroy such a majestic beauty. This tree is older than the time before Columbus came across. Maybe even a thousand or more years. We'll (the human race) never see these again.
Brian in Brighton
The Project Gutenberg eBook, Handwork in Wood, by
Re: clearing the gullets
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>Tom, I did a whole lot of sawing with a 2 man crosscut when I was a young lad. No trees like the one shown, but have cut some oaks about 2 foot in diameter with a 4' 2 man crosscut. When you "rock" the saw, IE: the "pulling man" pulls part way out of the cut while the other loads into the new wood, the saw tends to pull derbies from the cut. This does pull some, if not most of the material clear of the gullets. My Aunt lived on a small farm, in a log cabin they had built in the 1920's. She heated and cooked with wood until the late 1950's. She raised one of her grandsons, he and I cut all the firewood and fence posts used on the farm using axes, crosscuts and bow saws. I sure learned how to sharpen the axe and saws pretty well and quickly. The woods on the farm were mostly a species of White oak (we called it pin oad". This was in yellow sand soil in northern Indiana. In most of the woods the pin oak trees were about 6 to 8" in diameter, 30 to 45 foot tall and hard as iron. Often sparks would fly from the axe blows. I was in my early teens and could cut wood for several hours without tiring - Now I get tired thinking about it :~).
Re: Not what I thought
Brian in Brighton
>I was figuring that the pull man would toss a small woodland critter into the cut on the return stroke to help pull the Chip out. Unless of course you happen to be out on the Dale, in which case. Well, you can figure it out. :-)
Brian in Brighton
Re: Link with lots of info
JohnKJordan in East TN
>>Looks like a lot of work and a shame to destroy such a majestic beauty.
What's sad is to read the history of the iron industry in the US. Much of the eastern part of the country was deforested at one time for charcoal. One of my blacksmith books shows a typical lease in New Jersey in 1770 for a furnace, house, smith shop, coalhouse, and "5000 acres of well timbered Land to accomodate the Furnace". And that was just one furnace.
JKJ
Re: Link with lots of info
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>Hi Brian,
That is exactly what bothers me when foresters quote the statistics on how we have more forest now than we had x number of years ago.
"It's like trading 5 lbs of filet mignon for 15 lbs of hamburger." (Sam Venable, Knoxville News Sentinel) Even though he was talking about the damming of the Little Tennessee River, the point is still the same.
As long as we keep cutting the big trees, we will have fewer big trees. To me that is a net loss regardless of the monetary profit.
Gary
Re:Okay, Gary you struck a cord...:">
Dale Lenz
>with me, a forester. Show me from a respectfully site where a true to life forester said we have more forest today then yesterday, WE DON"T. We have more trees than yesterday, kinda of game if you ask me, a forester. You can grow 100's of thousands 4" tree/ac but only a few large trees. The quality of the wood from the trees are lesser than yesterday of course because the average tree is not as large. If we as a society want to continue to use wood we must learn to use wood of lesser quality, in general. Kiln operators have changed and tweaked their schedules and will continue to do so as wood quality drops. Not upset with you Gary, only stating the facts as I know them.
Merry Christmas to you and all WC. Dale
Re:Okay, Gary you struck a cord...:">
Gary Evans Tallassee, TN
>Hi Dale,
This is actually the latest post I saw in this vein from a professional forester:
http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning.pl?read=169957&v1=e2vrt43&v2=hand+plane&v4=bar+clamp&v5=tyr6gh
I think you and I agree that more acreage does not equate with the quality of forest products and if cutting the biggest trees continues to be a focus then it is just a matter of time before we only have 4" trees in our forests.
Obviously, no offense was intended.
Gary
Re:Okay, Gary you struck a cord...:">
Dale Lenz
>Dan says: First of all, the lower 48 states have more land covered with trees now than when the Pilgrims arrived here in the 1600's.
I'd like to see that information and the definition of: land covered with trees. Just think about, all the commercial forest, (acres capable of growing 20 cubic of wood/year, I think that's correct) Since civilized man has come to the US "WE" have taken thousand of forest acres out of production because of agriculture, cities, home site, road etc. Yes Nebraska has millions of trees now thanks to the Arbor guy, J. Sterling Morton(?).
Gary, no offense was taken by you what so ever. Forester are good folks, we are doing a good job, of trying to renew one of our great renewable resources. Doesn't pay worth damn, but being a Forester is a noble profession, something I'm quite proud of. Dale
Gee........
Dan Donaldson
>Gee, I didn't mean to cause a lot of controversy ;-) Just thought it was an intersting picture about some of the stuff they used to do with limited tools.
Re: Gee........
Sgian Dubh
>It is an interesting link Dan. And I've printed out the first 50 odd pages as a resource for a text I'm working on. There's some fascinating stuff in there, and it confirms much of what I already knew.
Interestingly this concern for the environment and cutting down forests is nothing new. 21st century man is a bit of a Johny-come-lately on the deforestation thing. One of the difficulties faced by ancient civilisations was a lack of fuel and materials to build with. All around the Mediterranean are examples of civilisations that eventually failed largely due to unsustainable logging.
�Ancient writers observed that forests always recede as civilizations develop and grow. The great Roman poet Ovid wrote, for instance, that during the �Golden Age,� before civilization began, �even the pine tree stood on its own hills�; but when the Iron Age succeeded it, �the mountain oak, the pine were felled.� (Perlin, J. A Forest Journey: The Story of Wood and Civilization, 2005, p 25.)
In the end, the world can easily survive without us. We humans are just a wee pinprick on its backside. The climate has been much hotter than it is now, and a great deal colder. We're just fiddling at the edges with our so-called concern for the environment, and that concern is only directed at our own survival as a species. We don't matter a jot is probably the reality, we just think we matter. Slainte.
Re: Gee........
JohnKJordan in East TN
>Don't think of it as controversy, but as discussion and education!
As for deforestation, I have an interesting observation. A few years ago I was driving through northern Scotland and there was not a tree in sight for many miles (km!). Hills were covered with grass, wild areas in low bushes. While thinking about the type of climate and soil conditions that would keep trees from growing, I drove over a ridge and saw a line of demarcation halfway up a hill - beyond the line was a thick forest! It hit me just then that the deforestation was not natural, and the forest area must have been protected over the years. Yikes!
I found a reference on deforestation which indicated that Scotland went from an estimated 80% coverage in early recorded history to 5% after WWI. Ireland was evidently worse, dropping to only 1% of the land forested, rebounding to 7% today. Double yikes! (I have no knowledge of the accuracy of these figures.)
This makes me appreciate east TN and my own woods even more. I have large oaks and maples and y.poplars, some over 10' in circumference and am adjacent to neighbors with hundreds of acres of woods. What a joy it is to walk and ride horseback under such trees.
JKJ
Re: Gee........
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I saw similar areas in Portugal where they had crews climbing the sides of mountains to plant trees in the remaining soil pockets. Apparently the areas were once covered with trees, but all were cut down. Then the soil washed off and now they can't get trees to grow becuase the soil is gone in many areas.
Lee
Re: Gee........
Sgian Dubh
>John, Great Britain's tree cover since the last Ice Age ended about 10,000 years ago has never exceeded approximately 75%. Great Britain specifically means the biggest of the British Isles excluding Ireland. There are natural boundaries that prevent tree growth such as altitude and latitude accounting for the 25%.
The attached graph provides the essentials at a glimpse. The deforestation of Great Britain in earnest began about 3000 BC. The trees and wood were/was used for fuel, coppicing, food, building, cleared for farming, and great swathes of the country were deforested for smelting metals. The Romans virtually stripped the south east of England of forests starting about AD 43 in their quest for metals.
The departure of the Romans and the Black Death offered respite to Britain's forests, but Henry VIII began a period of serious industrialisation. The forests were yet again decimated. It was only the discovery of coal that saved the forests and facilitated the British Empire. Slainte.

Changes in woodland cover over time in Great Britain�adapted from Watts (2006) p 273. Great Britain, the largest island of the British Isles has a surface area of 80,823 square miles. Therefore 15% forest cover, the estimated land coverage for 1086 AD, equals approximately 12,123 square miles.
Slainte.
Addendum *LINK*
Sgian Dubh
>I didn't attribute my source properly in my previous post.
The source for the image was Watts, K. (2006) British Forest Landscapes-- the legacy of woodland fragmentation. The Quarterly Journal of Forestry, VOL 100; number 4.
An online version of this source is below. Slainte.
British Forest Landscapes
Re: Richard...
Dale Lenz
>>The trees and wood were/was used for fuel, coppicing, food, building, cleared for farming, and great swathes of the country were deforested for smelting metals.< I'm confused as what my mean by trees used for coppicing? Coppicing is a forest regeneration method, managing stump spouts. I've always thought that coppicing was strange term for spouts but anyway. Maybe you have another definition of coppicing. Dale