Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Shaft material for slot mortiser

Posts

Shaft material for slot mortiser

#1

Shaft material for slot mortiser

Jim L.

>I'm considering building a slot mortiser/horizontal router and need advice on the sliding table mechanism. I have been watching the 8020 garage and it looks like it would be about $110 for the 10 series parts and $150 for the 15 series. I was trying to find some suitable bronze sleeve bearings at McMaster, but I am not knowledgable enough to know what is appropriate (shaft, housing, etc). I am just a hobbiest, so the machine will not see daily use, but I would like it to be accurate and last for a while. I am weighing the cost to build vs a Domino. As another option, I have some ball bearing drawer slides and the FWW article on building the horizontal mortiser, but I'm wondering if it will accurate and sturdy enough (I am looking to make some mortises in 8/4 x 5" x 50" maple rails for a fish tank stand to support about 1500 lbs.). All suggestions are appreciated.

Jim

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#3

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

Bob Lemon Sacramento Ca.

>If you like, I can send you a PDF file with detailed plans for building your own 3 axis machine. I'm sure this would help you with your construction. The file is 1.27MB. Bob

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#4

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

Jim L.

>That would be great, Bob. I saw the original post by Paul and emailed him to find out if he was happy with the 8020 products, but didn't get a response. I thought he might see this thread and give his opinion. The idea for the bronze bushing and steel rod came from his thread where he was discussing the cost/benefits of 8020 vs bronze with another poster.

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#5

Dan Barber Shop Shot 390 *LINK*

Eddie pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Dan built a heck of a multi router type machine using birch plywood and other easy to get parts. I bet that this tool is still serving him well.I haven't seen any postings from him in a while, but I may have missed some. Check out his Shop Shot.


Shop Shot 390

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#6

Ellis Walentine

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

Ellis Walentine

>Hi Jim,

I'll leave it to the machine heads in the group to give you specifics on shaft sizes and such. All I can pass along is my experience with two mortisers that we used to have. One had a direct-drive 3600rpm motor with a big chuck mounted directly on the arbor, which was about 7/8" dia. It could take up to a 5/8" shank. This machine was very sturdy (Advantage Machinery, now defunct) and you could easily hold down a 100# piece of wood on its table.

The other machine was a converted horizontal milling machine that had a Reeves drive and a draw-collet arrangement instead of a shaft and chuck. This was by far the most stable and accurate mortiser I've ever used. We had collets for all standard sizes from 1/8" to 7/8" and routinely mortised 4" deep with a 7/8" end mill. If you can find an old horizontal mill at a scrapyard or machinery dump, you might be able to make something similar.

Ellis Walentine, Host


img

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#7

Rick L

Mortiser expert.

Rick L

>I was the one who was talking with Paul on the bronze bushing and 80/20 stuff. I've used them all and many different mortisers over the years all the articles as well going back 25 years in FWW.

1. FWW #141 mortiser with drawer slides, brilliant and it does work well.

2. FWW Tools and shop issue several years later. DIY mortiser using T track. FWW #141 had the best raising system for the router.

4. Paul Cates system with 80/20 is simple.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=newarticles&file=articles_834.shtml

There was an article in American Woodworker? a few years ago where a guy made a simple router lift using simple bronze bushings and plain shafting available from most hardware stores. Simple bronze bushings were mounted in simple wood frame pieces. Even thought it was a router lift table the possibilities for a mortiser, sliding shaper fixtures are endless and "cheap". Linear bearing are way too expensive and bronze bushings are perfectly suited for low speed application and I wouldn't worry about grooves. Some folks just get too picky about unnecessary details. For many applications a slight amount of friction is a good thing. I'll try to find the issue but in my opinion it's one of the most insightful and practical articles. It has so many possibilities for other applications.

5. The Grizzly G0540 was around $300 plus shipping. I much prefer the lower rpm of direct drive motors over routers. Quieter for one and the rpm is more suitable for endmills and using the machine as a Doweling machine.

http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/reviews/articles_729.shtml

6. The Domino would be about here price wise at $750.

7. The newest entry would be the import from Laguna at $1,000. Having someone do all the engineering is worth more than most people realize.

8. The mortise-flex and others I'm sticking in here. As cheap as they seem to be to make, unless you are a scrounger it's still pricey.

The Robland combo unit would be about here. By the time you put it all together it would cost around $1,000. You can make it with a router or standard motor with the included chuck and add your own jackshaft. I think the new import Laguna is a better deal.

9. The Rojek, nice machine but at $1,600 it's still up there. I do know the machine well as a local school I maintain the machines on has one. I'd say the fit and finish is comparable to the G0540 but the higher HP and doweling bar is a plus.

10. The Invicta, Multirouter would be higher up the pyramid based on cost. I much prefer the 3450-rpm commercial ones over the Multi-

router as I've said before.

http://www.woodworking-pro.com/html/horizontal_mortiser.html

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#8

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Hi Jim,

I sent you an email on Sunday? with a couple of pics...maybe it's in your spam folder?

I made the mortiser from FWW 141 using the drawer slides, but I found that it had too much slop for my taste. It was fine going back and forth and side to side, but did not work well if you tried to mortise into the end of a long piece of wood - too much play up and down due to the leverage. Thinking about it now, it might work just fine if I had placed all of the slides vertically instead of lying flat (like in the article). I'd certainly try that first. I also used 3/8" x 16 threaded rods for the raising and lowering mechanism like another poster mentioned...worked very well.

I am very happy with the 80/20 linear bearings. For a few dollars, they sell shims that ensure that the UHMW bearing pads are snug against the rails. No slop at all, and the size pads and rails I used are heavy duty. Just holler if you have any more questions about the 8020 stuff.

As Rick L has said before, bronze bushings with steel shafts would work fine too. The shop made router lift article using the bushings and shafts is in the March 2004 issue of AWW.

At McMaster, a bushing like #6338K433 should work fine.

Paul

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#9

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

Jim L.

>Thanks for the heads-up on the email, Paul - it was in my spam folder. I'm glad to hear you are happy with the 8020 stuff because I placed my order with them last night for the 10 series parts. They had the pre-drilled pads for $1.55 each which is a huge plus (I would have had to make a jig to drill the holes perfectly, which would have taken some time). I did order the shims based on your previous posts concerning the effort to align everything. It came to around $150 for everything. Hopefully it will be worth the $ and effort.

Jim

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#10

Re: Mortiser expert.

Jim L.

>Hi Rick-

Your posts (in my thread and in Paul's previous thread) have been very informative. I ended up ordering the 8020 parts (10 series) last night. For the amount of use this jig will see, I'm sure the bronze bushing would have been sufficient, and I might try it for the vertical adjustment of the router (I did join FWW online to get the plans for the jig in issue 141, so it's good to know that is a solid design). I decided to use a router instead of a lower speed motor in case I wanted to do raised panels on the jig (which, along with the shipping charges to the West coast, also ruled out the Grizzly).

Jim

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#11

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Please post pics of your mortiser and fish tank when finished. We like pics!

PC

Re: Shaft material for slot mortiser

#12

Rick L

Re: Vertical adjuster

Rick L

>it's all about friction and wear. You don't need bronze bushing for the height mechanism. Steel to steel is fine as you don't move it often or much in travel. The pivot in FWW #141 is much simpler and more reliable for a height adjuster unless you need to go a great distance. Can't see the need to more than an inch.

Can't understand why folks want to be able to do raised panels with this type of mortiser. Making a seperate height pivot thing and mount it on your router table or even table saw would be a simpler way to go.