Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Does oil-base poly darken over time?

Posts

Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#1

Does oil-base poly darken over time?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

Just re-used some pine shelf boards that Beth used to have hanging in her office. Naturally, I was one short for the new installation. 2 coats of oil-base poly on the new board and it is still nowhere near as dark as the original shelves.

I know they don't have stain on them. I prefer clear finishes. I know they've never been exposed to direct sunlight. If the poly didn't darken, then I may have used some shellac to add a little color. You would think I could remember something like that after only 7 or 8 years, wouldn't you? I guess it's that early Anheiser's.

Second part of the question, how to add maybe some "honey pine" color over two coats of poly?

Gary

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#2

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet,TN)

>Pine seems to get a dark even if not exposed to sunlight. Have you ever torn down a wall made from pine studs? They get darker with age. Also oil based poly will yellow in time.

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#3

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

John Pappas

>Gary, a glaze can be used to add color between coats of finish. There are comercially prepared glazes that are specially formulated for such use. However, any stain and especially gel stains can be used as a glaze. You can also mix your own glaze by mixing linseed oil, varnish, mineral spirits, and universal colors together. You might check books by Michael Dresdner, Jeff Jewitt, or Bob Flexner for specific information. Try a gel stain of the right color. Nice thing about glazes is that if you don't like the color, you can remove it with mineral spirits....no harm no foul. I just touched up an old dresser by applying a thin coat of stain, let it dry for a week and applied a wipe on varnish to topcoat. Restored color nicely.

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#4

P.S.

John Pappas

>Gary, the key to glazes is to apply it as a thin coat...just a veil of color.

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#5

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

David Yoho

>Gary, if you don't try a glaze, you might see if Minwax still sells their PolyShades (I think they called them). They had one called Honey Pine that would go over your existing poly finish. I never cared much for them but it might do what you want with the least amount of trouble.

David

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#6

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

Mike Fitterling

>As Bill mentioned, pine will darken with time, becoming much more amber. So it depends on how much a difference there is now between the boards. If not much, I would just leave it and let time take its course. Without seeing the baords it is hard to say if the new ones will catch up or not. If a huge difference, then you may need to try glazes. I think I would wait and see if I were you; the difference between fresh and aged pine can be quite distinct.

Good luck,

Mike

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#7

Yes

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>My experience is that oil based poly will yellow over time and pine will also darken over time. Both seem to happen faster with exposure to light. If you place an object on newly finished pine and never move it you will get a light shadow on the covered area. These areas never seem to quite catch up with the surface that was exposed. Sandig down to bare wood and refinishing will eliminate the color difference.

Lee

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#8

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I've read experts who say ALL woods darken with time, regardless of what finish you use and even if not in direct sunlight. Makes sense when you look at very old antique furniture which looks almost black. I understand a UV protecting finishe will slow down the darkening which implies that an extended dose of UV light may darken quicker. I suspect things in the air such as oxygen also cause darkening. I've cut through some old very thick blocks of tropical wood and found a layer of dark "seeping" 1/2 inch into the lighter wood.

JKJ

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#9

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

Howard Acheson

>Both the poly varnish and the wood itself will darken over time. All woods change color with exposure to UV even if not in direct sunlight. Some woods darken, others lighten. Wood will also oxidize as it reacts with oxygen and oxidation will cause wood to darken. Finally, while the woods may both be pine, there are lots of different species of pine. Different species will have a different color when first coated and will change color at differing rates.

Varnish, whether standard varnish or poly varnish will darken over time. Different brands darken at differing rates. It's a function of the type of resin used and whether the varnish is tung oil or linseed oil based.

Poly varnish is the least cost type of varnish and is made with linseed oil generally. Linseed oil varnishes change color the most and the most rapidly.

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#10

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks guys,

I appreciate the input. I made two new shelves, though I only needed one. I may experiment with color on one of them to see if I can match what we have.

Gary

Re: Does oil-base poly darken over time?

#11

One more thought

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>A primer coat of orange shellac will give new pine an amber tint similar to the aged look. I can't speak as to the long term effects of the amber under poly or varnish.

Lee