A Piano Bench-Adventures in design
Alan Young
>A few days back there was a lengthy thread on "design issues".
The long thread is here:
http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl?frames;read=342741&v1=e2vrt43&v2=Freud+bits&v4=shellac&v5=dfrwq67
I thought I'd share my design process in this recently completed piano bench.
My wife bought a baby grand piano a couple of years ago. It was a purchase she had been desiring for a number of years and when a used piano became available she snapped it up for a good price. The piano did not come with a bench so we kept the bench from the previous upright-as the people we sold ours to did not need the bench....
Part of the old bench's problem was the storage compartment-It's bottom was some pretty flimsy 1/4 MDF/hardboard type material, so the music kept falling out. The legs were bolt-on-to-the-apron type construction. They were frequently coming loose and it all literally collapsed under my son one day when he sat down...I therefor was commissioned by my wife to make a new bench.
Here is the main design.
As I cut out the legs on the bandsaw I ran into some drift problems and the blade got away from me-The result was the middle taper was uneven and difficult to fix even with decent hand work so I punted and put the legs on the lathe and turned a cone for the middle taper. That turned out OK I think but I also turned round feet instead of using the spade taper as in the design.
I also added a bracket around the entire lower section.
I know I don't like the turned feet.The bracket is a bit unconvincing too...so I went back to the drawing board....I think I'll cut off those round feet and fabricate new spade feet.Hopefully I'll exercise better control at the bandsaw.
I also moved the rails from the side to the back. This way I eliminated 1/2 the work while keeping the detail.
Here are the casualties of bad design-well poor execution of design!
I cut of the round-turned feet.
I will replaced these with a modified spade foot design. The new feet will be attached to the bench legs with 1/2" dowels. I needed to drill holes into the legs- and doing this by hand is tricky because it's difficult to maintain a 90 degree angle. So I turned to my drill press.
Now my drill press was a tad too short for the depth of the bench and the distance from the spindle center to the center of the bench leg was too far apart. So I rotated the spindle 180 degrees and raised the drill press up by placing it on a 3/4" piece of plywood.
Now I was able to drill countersunk pilot holes that were perpendicular and centered on each leg.
From there I drilled 1/2" holes with a hand drill.
I made a mitered frame the gets attached to the top of the bench.
Here is the frame getting glued to the bench.
I glued up some stock for the new spade feet then marked the profile. You don't always need fancy drafting programs or mathematical equations to get the profile you want-Here I just used a clock to mark the arc.
I like these feet better. They look like Nuclear Power plants upside down!

Ok I skipped a bunch of photo ops as I made the brackets and rail. I just got carried away cutting the profiles of the brackets and turning the rail.

The scroll brackets are glued to the legs with 1/2 dowels. I will carve more "scroll" details into the brackets.The rail has turned tenons that are joined to mortises in the scroll brackets.

The bench will have an upholstered seat. The seat will be a two part lamination. The lower part will set inside the bench frame while the upper layer will rest around the top of the frame perimeter. There will be no hinge- The seat will be removable.I carved a small line in the scrolls and added some moldings around the aprons. Now some sanding, then the finish.
I made the seat with 2" thick foam and wrapped it material that Eileen chose.

The top/seat is not hinged. It has a backing board sized to fit inside the frame. There is plenty of storage space for music-The floor is 3/4" thick so it will hold up for a long time....


Overall I gave this piece a b-minus...The end look is pretty chunky and heavy...I preferred the original leg layout and I think the skirt around the feet is an OK addition but the pattern is too busy- again my tendency to design with the "more must be more" philosophy :^) or is it :^(
Anyway we now have a bench that will hold music and people for quite some time....


Alan



