Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Toolmaking Contest

Posts

Toolmaking Contest

#1

Ellis Walentine

Toolmaking Contest

Ellis Walentine

>Good morning, folks. I just wanted to copy a post I added to a recent thread over on the hand tools board regarding the upcoming Toolmaking Contest. The question was, who's actually entering? Here's my reply....

One thing we've learned about contests by now is that, regardless what deadline you set, people will wait until the last minute to enter, whether to avoid tipping their hand, as someone mentioned, or to hopefully get a better idea of their odds of winning. So, please don't think that the lack of current entries in any way reflects how popular or well-attended this contest will be. And, whether or not you win one of the top three prizes or the five runners-up prizes, this contest is a no-lose proposition, as all entrants receive subscriptions to two magazines as well as a Lee Valley thickness gauge just for entering.

Now, as to whether only hand tool folks are likely to be involved, the answer to that has to be a resounding no. Our theory is that everyone, including people like me who use both hand and power tools, at some point in the course of things find a need for a tool they don't already own. I've cobbled up numerous quickie tools in the past (and a few really overwrought ones), just to get the job done, whatever the job was. And, don't rule out the turning folks either. They probably make more tools than the rest of us combined. This contest is an acknowledgement of this primal need to make tools. You Neanderthals here should know that better than anyone, as your ancestors sat around fires in caves, knapping flint spear points and arrowheads and bashing rocks or whatever they needed to get the job done. :-)

The other trichotomy that should be addressed here is the function vs form vs ergonomic factor. Stephen makes tools with little regard for appearance, since he uses everything he makes. Others make presentation quality tools that are pieces of art in and of themselves. Some people concentrate on ergonomics; I think James Krenov is in this category, as he spent a lot of time whittling his planes to fit his hands. The point we're making in this contest is a celebration of user-made tools, in every way, shape and form. There will be winners in all three main categories, so everyone has a chance.

And, remember, you can't lose. :-)

Ellis


Re: Toolmaking Contest

#2

Ellis, am I reading this right?

Mark in B'ham

>Do the entry instructions mean that we have to sent the actual tool to Lee Valley for judging in person? That is a little different from other contests were the judging was done via the pictures that were submitted, isn't it?

If that's right, I'm going to have to make a smaller version of my bowsaw that I was going to enter that will fit in a flat-rate box.

I still want to enter. Maybe only five people will enter and I'll be a runner-up!

Re: Toolmaking Contest

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Ellis, am I reading this right?

Ellis Walentine

>Sorry I didn't catch this earlier, Mark. Yes, the judges will be meeting in Ottawa in late March for a hands-on judging session. That's the only way we could possibly judge functionality and feel. It is a departure for sure, but this whole contest is a departure. I think it is going to be great!

If the size of your bowsaw is a factor in its function or ergonomics, you might want to just pay the extra postage. I doubt it would be too expensive. (Easy for me to say. :-)

Ellis

Re: Toolmaking Contest

#4

Thanks ....

Mark in B'ham

>Thanks for the email and clarification, Ellis. I will certainly find out how much shipping will be. I don't think that hands on evaluation will help my chances of winning, but this is the first contest I've felt like I was able to enter. Plus the entering bonuses are really nice.

I know you hear this all the time, but thanks for the work you do for Woodcentral.

-Mark