Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

hybrid table saws

Posts

hybrid table saws

#1

hybrid table saws

Bruce, a MN galoot

>I'm in the market for a new table saw, having just barely managed to get by with a 9" Delta for the last 30 years or so.

So I'm thinking of a hybrid, because I don't think I can justify the expense of a good cabinet saw (unless Craig's list comes through with a good Unisaw at a decent price)

So, for those of you who have a hybrid, what really are the differences between a contractor saw, the hybrid and a good cabinet saw? I've read as many articles as I can find, but not one of the authors will discuss the differences in trunnions, etc. That's what I'd like to know.

I'm not likely to get into wholesale cabinet construction during my retirement years, but I do want to be able to produce furniture, both for family and for business.

Thanks for any information you can provide.

Bruce, in remarkably cold MN

Re: hybrid table saws

#2

Re: hybrid table saws

David Yoho

>Bruce, as you probably know, Pop Wood did a review of hybrid saws recently. They seemed to like the Jet ProShop and the Steel City 35601. The Jet (in various setups) is on sale through the end of the month. I think the SC is too. (The SC has a nice large table)

The bottom line is - power. Contractor saws are 1.5 hp, hybrids - 1 3/4 hp, and cabinet saws are 3 - 5 hp. I think it depends on the type and thickness of material you'll be cutting the most as to which will work better. If you cut much 6 and 8/4 stock with a 1.5 - 1 3/4 hp saw, a thin kerf blade will be a real asset.

I wouldn't expect the hybrids to have as good a trunnion system as their cabinet saw counterparts. However, if budget is a great concern, either try to wait for a deal on a used cabinet saw or go ahead with a new hybrid purchase.

David

Re: hybrid table saws

#3

Re: hybrid table saws

Bruce, a MN galoot

>Thanks, David,

The question Pop Wood didn't address is whether the hybrid saw trunnion is better than the contractor saw's trunnion. I lust after a Unisaw, but I'm not sure I have the patience for the right one to show up.

Bruce

Re: hybrid table saws

#4

Re: hybrid table saws

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>There are two types of hybrids: contractor-based and cabinet-based. The Craftsman and Steelcity have their trunions mounted to the cabinet; blade-heeling is a fairly simple table-top adjustment.

All the others attach the trunions to the top, like a contractor's saw. Heeling correction can be a bear with this setup.

Fine Woodworking also recently did a hybrid saw review and rated the Woodtek it's best value and best overall. Incidently, the General, Grizzly, Shop Fox and Woodtek are all 20 amp, 2 hp machines.

Re: hybrid table saws

#5

Re: hybrid table saws

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Any differences in the mechanicals among any of the range of table saws of the major manufacturers are irrelevant to the hobbyist woodworker. My Delta 34-444 with a good blade has served well for the past 25 years. A Unisaw wouldn't make my work any better.

If you have the space, get a contractor saw and a Delta RAS for the same money as a fancy hybrid.

Clint

Re: hybrid table saws

#6

JL

Re: hybrid table saws

JL

>I looked at the hybrids before I bought my cabinet saw.

The "bottom of the line" Steel City Cabinet saws (SC-35610 and SC-35606) both have 3 hp motors and a single poly-v belt (and a less massive trunion system). Their "lighter" cabinet saws (SC-35601 and SC-35670) have the 1.75 hp motors. They were impressive and are definitely worth a look.

I bought the 5 hp cabinet saw because it had a more massive fence, motor and trunion system. I have two pieces of Steel City equipment (cabinet saw and 8" jointer) and I have been quite happy with both. A friend bought the 16" band saw and he has been happy with it. My $0.02.

Re: hybrid table saws

#7

Re: hybrid table saws

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>Clint

I also plan to get a hybrid sometime next Spring. I currently have a Delta Contr which has done me well. However, the dust collection is very bad even with "improvements", and I don't like the motor hanging off the back.

Otherwise I agree. A Contr saw is a good, basic saw.

FWW did a good review of hybrids in the recent Tool issue . Begnal seems to know his machines. I was surprised that Woodtek was rated a top saw simply because I had no idea they were still in business. To me, outside of price (and they're all essentially the same) and how well the saw works, the next important matter is where can I get it! That leaves Craftsman, Jet, and, I believe, Steel City which can be had locally.

Hopefully I'll have more information before May or June.

Re: hybrid table saws

#8

Re: hybrid table saws *LINK*

knotscott

>I stepped up from a very good GI contractor saw to a Craftsman 22124 hybrid, which is nearly identical to the Steel City. The horsepower differences are small, but the shorter drive belt gives more efficient power transfer. Aligning the cabinet mounted trunnions was much easier on the 22124 than with the GI, and I was able to get it to ~ 0.001" in about 10 minutes. The combination of a more efficient drive system and better alignment, equates to a mild improvement in the overall perceived power. One huge improvement was mass...the 22124 weighs 425# vs 300 for the GI...> 40% more. It's notably more stable.

The are no advantages in the contractor saw design over the hybrid design, although some individual saw packages may appeal for various other reasons. Any current contractor saw would be improved by moving the motor inside the cabinet. Heeling is less of an issue with the hybrids beaause there's less leverage on the carriage, and some of the hybrids have slightly beefed up trunnion parts.

The industrial cabinet saws have significantly more robust trunnions, motors, and drive system. For about the same price as a high end hybrid at full price, Grizzly offers a very good 3hp cabinet saw. If you've 220v and are willing to ~ $1k, I'd lean heavily toward the cabinet saw. With that said, many of the hybrids go on sale in the $600-$800 range.


img

22124 Epinions review

Re: hybrid table saws

#9

Re: hybrid table saws

lee beeden

>Grizzily just knocked there 3hp cabinet saw down to $895

very good price I think

I'd be tempted to buy a cabinet saw

Lee

Re: hybrid table saws

#10

Re: hybrid table saws

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I guess I should be ashamed to admit it, but I have no clue as to how to go about "aligning the trunion." Moreover, the only time I ever got up close and personal with it (at least that's what I think it was) was when I had to flip the saw over to clean out all the gunk that was preventing the blade from being raised and lowered. And, what's heeling?

Clint

Re: hybrid table saws

#11

Re: hybrid table saws

Stuart Hough

>Bruce, I have the Craftsman 22114, which has the 3/4 style cabinet with shorter legs and cast iron wings. I have found it to be very good for what I have used it for so far. I am still in the neophyte stage, but it has helped me do some really accurate work so far. The trunnions are much beefier than the contractor style, but, in a curious twist, are connected to each other with what seem to be shorter versions on the contractor style bars. This is sturdy (I've had my saw for 3 years now), but not as solid as a regular cabinet saw trunnion. Mine passes the "nickel test" at full song, but not at startup or shutoff, though I think that might be a belt issue. I have only bogged down the blade one time, doing what I shouldn't have been doing, and I think that was a good thing, because the only other result would have had me picking myself up on the outside of the garage! This saw is currently running $650, but if you are a Craftsman Club member they regularly go on sale for $50-$100 less. I'm pleased with mine. Good luck in your search!

Re: hybrid table saws

#12

Re: hybrid table saws

Pete

>I bought my Craftsman 22124 during the feeding frenzy when they first came out. About $650 out the door due to a sale and Craftsman Club membership. The Biesemeyer fence was a great selling point. At the time, I was looking at the 3 HP Grizzly but did not have easy access to 220V. I have since updated to an Incra fence, a WWII blade, added a router table on one end and never looked back. It has been very reliable under heavy use and a great addition to my woodworking hobby.

Re: hybrid table saws

#13

Heeling

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Heeling is when the blade is not exactly parallel to the miter slot. You have to adjust the trunions to correct the problem with a contractor saw (or a hybrid saw that attaches the trunions to the saw's top). It is easier to adjust the table itself, possible only if the trunions are attached to the saw's cabinet.

Re: hybrid table saws

#14

For used, check eBay too

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: hybrid table saws

#15

Re: hybrid table saws

Barry Irby

>Check around for a used tool dealer, even an industrial one. I know there is one here in Richmond, VA and another in Atlanta. I would assume there are many others across the country. The one here nearly always has a Unisaw in stock. Used to be able to buy them for $600 - 800 depending on condition and whether they were 3 phase or not. He even sells converters.