Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

Posts

DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

#1

DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

marc rosen

>Hello All,

Hope the winter is treating you well. Here's my question about dust collectors. I have a unit that is rated 1200CFM (fitted with a trashcan cyclone at the front end) and it has a 1 micron filter bag. On many occasions I find it necessary to remove the bag as the normal "swatting in position" does not release the all of fine powder lining its inside surface. After these cleanings it is noticeable how much more air is moved by the system. I was thinking about getting a larger bag but also toying with the idea of replacing the bag with a pleated canister filtr. Do any of you canister owners ever need to remove the can to really clean it out or does the cleaning mechanism realy work? Thanks in advance for your info.

Marc

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

#2

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Marc,

I don't have a dust collector, but offer my experience with a similar situation in my shop vacuum.

For years, I have used a foam sleeve filter, sometimes, if used for dry pickup or fine dust, supplemented with a paper filter. I dreamed about having a pleated paper filter. When the old shop vacuum's cannister rusted through, I got the chance to try the pleated filter on it's replacemnt.

With the new vacuum, I decided to remove probably 30+ years of accumulated dust, dirt, pidgeon droppings, hay, and straw from my barn loft. I started with the new pleated paper filter but soon (less than 10 minutes) the intake airflow was reduced to an ineffective level. I had to remove the filter, beat it against a solid object (outdoors), reinstall the filter, and vacuum for another short time. After a few cleanings of the pleated filter, I decided to try the foam sleeve with paper overlay filter. Much better airflow over a longer time. When the airlflow finally decreased to an unacceptable level I was able to turn the vacuum off and whack the side of the vacuum with my hand to dislodge the dirt and dust, then continue the cleanup.

The pleated filter does capture more fine dust than the foam/paper filters, but the pleated filter clogged so quickly that I found it too time consuming to constantly clean the filter. After cleaning the pleated filter a few times with the whack-it-against-a-solid-object method, I had to blow it out with a nozzle and compressed air to remove the very fine dust. The foam/paper filter allowed very little fine dust to escape into the air.

I'd vote for the bag filter for your dust collector. No matter what sort of cleaning mechanism the pleated filter has, I'm betting it won't dislodge the fine dust that accumulates and gets tightly packed into the filter's pleats. Sooner or later you'll have to remove the filter to the outdoors and manually clean it with a brush or compressed air.

Al

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

#3

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

knotscott

>I upgraded my two 1 mic bags to a single cannister filter w/plastic bottom bag. The airflow is a big improvement even with only one filter. The cannister came with a flapper that works well, but I do take the cannister off every now and then to give it a more thorough "beating". It's a lot less messy than changing the bags, and is a performance upgrade too, so I'd recommend the cannister.

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

#4

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

Nelson

>I have a cannister on mine and it works great, the flapper does a good job but about once a month I will take the air hose[low pressure] and blow around the cannister so no need to take it off.

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

#5

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

Barry Irby

>I'm with Al on this.

I have a shop vac with a pleated filter. I have to take it off and beat it against the side of the trash can to dislodge the dust.

My dust collector has a bag. The "cake" that builds up on the bag is part of it's rating. They figure it will reduce the air flow, but in effect make the bag and finer filter and capture finer particles. When I change the lower bag, I whack the upper on a few times to dislodge some of the cake. Occasionally I take it off and turn it inside out and really shake it out. Makes and astonishing difference in the air flow. The diminished air flow crepe up on me and I did not realize how bad it was until I shook out the bag. I was in the process of upgrading the system to improve it's performance. Cleaning the bag was the most effective thing I did.

I can almost guarantee you that the same thing will occur with a canister. It will work amazingly well until you get the pleats packed with dust. This all but elimantes the "increased" surface area they tout for canisters. So you are back to about the surface area of a bag. Unless you can effectively clean the pleats.

It also depends on what you are doing. If I am turning green wood, there is not very much in the way of dry "fines" that clogs the bags pores. I can go a long time without diminished air flow. OTOH, if I am sanding with myPerformax the bag will clog in an hour and I have to shake it out. I would not spend much money on a canister.

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

#6

Re: DC question- pleated filter vs bag filter

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have the Grizzly 3 HP cyclone - as the cyclone does remove much of the material my results may not match yours. I had the cyclone installed for about 3 ~ 4 months when Griz sent a retrofit kit with a new brush (seemed much more aggressive and larger) to install in the filter cartridge. I have been using the unit for about 2 ~ 3 years now without removing the canister filter for any additional cleaning. The brush seems to do a pretty good job of maintaining performance. I have overflowed my unit a few times - running material into the canister. After cleaning the filter with the brush, I didn't notice any loss in performance.