I rarely do OT questions and now there are so many I feel guilty but you guys are sharp and well versed in many fields.
My brother is using insulation that already has a vapor barrier Owens Corning R-13 thermal and kraft faced?. He wants to start using a plastic second barrier on top of this (please don't ask why.
Isthere a problem with this (drafty farmhouse)
Sorry for the OT and thanks for any quick answers.
>The way I was told was if you use the plastic with a faced insulation, It will build moisture between the two. Also, the facing must face the heated room.
>I don't think it would be any problem, in fact I did my new shop that way. The way I figure it no moisture can be accumulated in the wall as I have housewrap on the outside of the wall. The vapor barrier on the insulation is directly against the plastic so very little if any air (moist or otherwise can get there. My shop has 2 x 6" (on 16")walls stuffed with fiberglass insulation with kraft paper, then plastic then 5/8" fire rated drywall - the outside is 7/16 OSB then housewrap - with vinyl siding. I have central forced air heat and air conditioning. I haven't noticed any problems in the 3~4 years since it was built.
>I actually do know something about this. I have a College Degree In Building Construction, Was a Class A contractor and have been a Home Inspector for over twenty years. So In this case, the Addy Protocol does not apply, I can answer this question.
It is safe to use two or even more vapor barriers as long as they are both in the same position in the wall or ceiling (on the warm side, in a heating climate). If they are in contact with each other they are considered laminated. So, Yes it is safe to put two of them up on the same wall or ceiling.
There is a drawback or two. It costs a little more. He might be able to buy unfaced batts cheaper and then put poly over them. Also, the Vapor barrier/poly needs to be on the warm side of the wall. (Keeping the VB warm prevents humidity from condensing on it when it hits it.) Another drawback to poly over the wall if that it eliminates the possibility of gluing the drywall to the studs or ceiling joists. Gluing is considered a superior method of installation for several reasons. He will have to use the nail or screw pattern designed for use without glue. OTOH, the poly also makes a good AIR barrier and helps cut infiltration in addition to being a VB. (Once a house is reasonably well insulated, Infiltration or Air changes are likely to be the largest source of heat loss/heat Gain.)
>What amazes me is the different answers people get about the same thing. I have no degree or actual knowledge if the answers are correct or not so I listen to ones who do claim to. Barry may very well be right. He sounds like he knows and gave a good explaination. My point is, the person who told me what I stated has been in the insulation business for over 25 years so I guess we go with the answers that make the most sense to us. It seems to apply to a lot of things in life and the good part is it makes a person think.
>Sean, You raise a very good point. As with any free advice, we all have to take what we read here on WC or anywhere else for that matter with a grain of salt. This is a good group of people here and I have never seen anyone intentionally try to mislead anyone, but we still have to be careful. Research the answers you get further and check them against the giggle test.
What you said was generally true. I think the "rule" is that you never want to use two vapor barriers. What that is about is two or more vapor barriers in different positions (on opposite sides of a wall). The exception is that if they are in the same position and basically in contact with each other they are consider laminated and there is little danger. If you have them in different positions with other materials in between there is a chance moisture will build up between them and be trapped. (Not Good).
As we make buildings tighter and tighter the use of a vapor barrier and the position of it becomes more and more important. In an old drafty farm house there was no VB and no problem. If rain or humidity found its way into cavities occasionally, it just ventilated out and dried. Good for the building, heck on your heating bill. As we add insulation and tighten the building, we increase the potential for water and humidity to leak into and be stored in the insulation and wet the surrounding wood, rotting it, encouraging insects like termites and also mold. It increases the risk of those things, but hopefully reduces the heating bills.
The climate matters also. In a strictly heating climate you put the VB on the heated (living) side of the wall. In a strictly cooling climate it goes on the outside. We don't have much territory in the US that is a total AC climate. An example would be that in the deep south it is a bad idea to glue up vinyl wallpaper with wheat paste or any glue that has any organic material in it. The vinyl is (incidentally) a VB. The AC cools and dehumidifies the interior. Heat and humidity move from warmer and wetter toward cooler and dryer. The humidity condenses under the wallpaper and mold grows. (There were a couple of Nursing Homes in Florida they practically had to tear down because of mold under the vinyl wall paper.) The really tricky part is to figure out where to put the VB in a climate that reverses, where you heat in winter and AC in summer. Whatever you do, you want the wall or ceiling to be able to dry in one direction or the other. Therefore the prohibition against two vapor barriers.
So, I think your insulation buddy just latched onto the essential bit of information. He kept it simple and I bet it kept him and his customers out of trouble.
As I was reading this thread, a question I've had for a long time reared it's ugly head. You came this close (holds thumb and forefinger very, very near one another) to answering that question with:
The really tricky part is to figure out where to put the VB in a climate that reverses, where you heat in winter and AC in summer.
But what's the answer!?
Here in central Iowa, its not unusual to experience 90�+ F temperatures with 90+% relative humidity in the summer or -20� F with 35-% RH in the winter. Which is the proper position for the vapor barrier?
>Our climate in Indiana is very similar to yours in Iowa. Standard practice around here is to put the VB on the inside of the framing after insulation is installed. I'm sure I would have heard of issues with this practice if there were widespread problems with it. Nary a peep.
Jason (in a lot of different homes as a painter...)
>Al, This is a vast topic. Much more complex than meets the eye. Moisture flow, heat flow, air flow, and pollution flow through houses are all interrelated and complicated. The problem is that you can not move air through a building without moving the heat it contains, the moister and the pollutants with it. Making matters worse, you are not just dealing with indoors and outdoors. You have other spaces that are in some sort of limbo between them, such as crawl spaces, attics, and wall cavities. You can have movement into the conditioned spaces from some of these spaces and out to others. And they can change all day long.
I have been looking at this for over forty years. On thing I have learned is that what we thought we knew was based on assumptions and guesses that were not much better than old wives tales. You would have thought that somebody would have done some outstanding research on this, but, not so much.
To try to answer your question without turning this into a novel, it turns out that Vapor Barriers are not very critical in the southern half of the country. There is a phenomenon known as the "35 degree Isotherm". If you are north of it, VB's are important, to the south, not as much. North of the line, the weather stays below 35 degrees (F) for more than twenty days a year. So, if it stays cold enough long enough, condensation builds up in the "interstitial" cavities and things get soggy and stay soggy long enough to do damage. (They tell me that in the norther tier of states they can tell how cold it is by how high the frost is on the base board/wall. ??? Anybody here seen frost on the baseboard????) The 35 degree Isotherm is a wavy line drawn across the US from about DC or Baltimore westward.
So, if you are in a Heating Dominated climate, the VB goes on the living space or heated side of the wall or ceiling or floor. So, either poly or faced batts, or foil backed drywall on the walls and ceilings and the faced side of the beat goes up under the bottom of the floor.
In the tropical climes (southern Florida and Hawaii) it is more important to put them on the exterior side.
Crawl spaces are so complicated that it looks like the next great thing is going to be the "Conditioned Crawl Space". No insulation in the floor, none on the ducts, Excellent VB on grade (100% wall to wall.) no foundation vents, insulate the foundation walls and soil surface in about two feet, and blow some heat and AC into the space. I am in conservative Virginia, and we are the last place to see these new fangled things, but I am seeing conditioned crawl spaces. Unfortunately, they don't have hard and fast rules for them and I am seeing some pretty badly mangled. I am also in a severe termite zone and we are not clear on how to deal with those covered walls. An ideal termite entry point and the insulation gives them cover. Time will tell.
>Barry, your making a lot of sense. I asked the Insulation guy here a very simple and straight foward question and that was the type of answer I received. I think your right, there are a lot of variables.
Have you ever observed that you can see stripes on frame houses that correspond to the studs and framing?
I was told that it was caused by having a poor vapor barrier and or by Brownian Motion. (The motion of molecules affected by their temperature). The idea was that the surface temperature at the stud was different that outside the insulated cavity. If you rely on the craft paper face of the insulation as a VB, the humidity is escaping through and beside the studs and the studs are not as good an insulator as the insulation, so there is a temp difference as well. Somehow this causes the stripes. The Brownian Motion part was supposed to affect how fast the air molecules were vibrating and therefore whether they deposited there pollutants on the surface or not.
I know you have seen a house where smokers lived and you could see the yellow/brown of the nicotine on the walls and ceiling and you can see where the framing is.
I had a Rep for a major siding company tell me that the exterior paint job would last a year or two longer if builders would use a poly vapor barrier that was continuous over the studs. What do you think?
>No. House Wrap products like Tyvek are specifically designed to be a water barrier and an Air Barrier, but not a Vapor Barrier. They are Permeable to vapor, which is what you want. (15 pound felt is excellent in this application as well, but since it comes in narrower rolls it may not be as good an air Barrier. One problem with Tyvek it that it is subject to UV degradation. It used to degrade very quickly. A few hours of exposure would ruin it. Supposedly they have improved it, but I don't know how much. I wonder if the UV penetrates through white vinyl siding and destroys it over time.
>I see the stripes from time to time. Like you said, smokers' homes are common, the other I've noticed is homes where the furnace is electric. (Does the air flow directly over the heating coils, causing some dust to be burned?).
As for exterior paint jobs, I couldn't really say about the continuous VB vs. Kraft paper. I think that there are bigger fish to fry when it comes to exterior coatings longevity. Back-priming, a ventilated drainage plane and a high-quality exterior coating probably contribute as much as anything to a long-lasting paint job.
>I'm no expert on the subject, but I'd guess what you describe is more likely the effect of higher thermal conductivity of the studs causing moisture to condense over them, which tends to catch whatever dust or polutants are in the air. I've heard of lots of stuff attributed to Brownian motion, and since no one is trying to sell you something in this case, perhaps it could actually be the cause - though I'm still skeptical.
>I saw a test a few years ago in a trade magazine (probably either JLC or FHB). It was a comparative test of the various housewraps with roofing felt thrown into the mix. Essentially, they took a piece of wood with the wrap nailed to it, then turned a glass of water upside down on it. All of them leaked at the nail penetration except the felt.
I think for too long, too many builders and siding contractors were too focused on sealing the exterior that they overlooked the need to let water out if it did get behind the siding. Even brick veneer (brick laid one column deep, non-structural) will have weep holes at the bottom course (and intermediate course on tall walls) if it's been properly laid--some even use a piece of braided rope to help wick the water out.
Personally, I think that properly installed fiber-cement siding is "where it's at".
>I think you've got it pretty well covered (so to speak!). Have you ever heard of using just the right size gravel as a termite barrier? No idea how effective it is, just curious.
>Never heard of gravel as a termite barrier. I have heard of it as a rodent barrier. Use gravel about the size of your little finger tip. The type that is broken and has sharp edges, not river stone. The gravel locks together pretty tightly and the rats and mice have trouble moving it and it hurts their feet. They are generally opportunists and will move on to easier pickings. Might also work with termites, but I would think it had to be down on the scale of mason's sand. Termites are tiny and would have not trouble moving through gravel that had open spaces.
>We built this house 11 years ago. As part of VA Power's (new at that time) - Energy Saver Plus package - we have a "conditioned crawl space". I've got to say I think it's the best thing since sliced bread. Heck, you can go under there in the middle of winter in shorts and be totally comfortable!
It does provide certain benefits over traditional crawl space treatment. I don't ever have to fight with insulation to access the sub-floor, running additional wiring is very simple, access to plumbing is better, no worries about pipes freezing in winter, the crawl space stays dry year-round, don't worry about insulation falling out of place, and we never walk on cold floors.
We also received a monthly $10 reduction on our bill from the power company for the first 10 years because of this package. We've been more than pleased with it and will probably do it again in our next house.