Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT Solar PV power question.

Posts

OT Solar PV power question.

#1

OT Solar PV power question.

Barry Irby

>There a appears to be a group that will put Photovoltaic cells on your house along with the balance of the system and lease them to you over a 25 year period. (Google Join the Solution) It appears that the idea is they figure out what you need and install it and lease it to you at "today's rate". You save money if the rate rises for the power company and you get the benefit of not using "planetary resources". Anyone know anything about this? What do you think?

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#2

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

Rick Christopherson

>I don't know that I would ever consider this. You will be paying these people forever for energy that is otherwise free once the initial investment is paid off. In a sense, all you are doing is fixing a portion of your electric bill at today's price, but you're not taking advantage of the solar energy (cost wise).

I believe you would be better off taking out a loan and owning the equipment outright. Once the loan is paid off, then you have free energy.

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#3

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Barry, my son has been looking into this. He has done some investigation. It appears to be a pretty good deal. It would cost more in interest to buy your own system than the power saved. However, apparently this company is figuring the cost of the Photocells will come down and with a large enough base of customers will become a profitable endeavor. As the normal life of one of the PC's is around 20 years I wonder if they ever will be profitable. He may contact them and try the system out. You do have to make a payment for installation. It doesn't seem there is much to lose. As I am certain electrical power will increase in cost - if due to inflation if nothing else, it does seem like a fairly good deal.

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#4

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

Mark Nowicki

>I did google as you suggested, and stopped reading after a few lines. My cynical character kicked in and my eyes glazed over.

Also my finance degree allows me to smell a rat, especially one that tries to grab me by the emotional "short and curlies" in order to separate me from my money.

I had a professor who was even more of a cynic than I am, and his way to analyze problems of this nature was to draw a horizontal time line, with outgoing cash represented by arrows pointing down, and incoming by arrows pointing up, and then doing a simple Net present value analysis (google that) Keep in mind that money spent is money spent and pie in the sky promise is just that. Therefore, the "not using planetary resources" BS has no monetary value.

It is impossible to say if this is a good deal without hard numbers. Much to my surprise, I had no luck finding those on the website you suggested.

What I can tell is that,IMO, the only way that this operation can secure their investment is by registering their presence on the property deed. When you change your mind those kind of festering clauses are harder to get rid off than cancer.

Hang on to your wallet.

Mark

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#5

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

ScottS

>Here in Silicon Valley, solar power has become quite a fad. Several of my friends have paid to install solar systems on their roofs. The problem with these systems is that they are expensive to install and even here in sunny California, they typically don't generate enough power to run an entire house. I don't know that it's impossible to have enough solar power to run a house, but most people seem to be constrained by how much money they're willing to spend on the initial equipment install AND how much of their roof they're willing to have covered with ugly solar panels.

My buddy recently built a house and install solar panels on a large portion of the roof which wasn't directly visible from the street. I don't remember the economics, but I think he said it would take him 10-15 years to recover the cost of the equipment unless energy prices rose dramatically. For his family, it was mostly a "feel good" thing. Money wasn't an issue for them and they felt better about building a climate-controlled wine cellar, installing central AC, and other options that would increase the amount of energy they used over that of a typical house.

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#6

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

Steve Schoene

>There is an article in the January 2008 issue of Fine Homebuilding on photovoltaics. They provided examples of the economics of a $36,000 initial cost system in various parts of the country, showing varying outputs and electricity cost savings.

It none of these examples was the system even close to being an economically sound investment. You would have to factor in electricity price increases dramatically higher than the overall inflation rate for very long periods, and assume zero maintenance costs for the system. In a few cases, large governmental subsidies closed the cost gap considerably, but those are paid by someone.

So is it "good for the planet" despite being more expensive electricity than off the gird? The answer is that it is almost impossible to tell. The initial costs is some measure of resources going into manufacturing, distributing, and installing the product. Many of these resources have energy components, others have ecological effects. Without a very thorough audit how would you know. That's the primary merit of the market system for determining prices and resource allocations. It does give a consistent metric to weigh one set of costs against another. Not a perfect metric--markets do fail, and external effects aren't often priced correctly by the market place. But as they found in the failed economy of the former USSR trying to make allocations without relying fundamentally on the economics isn't likely to be very efficient, and may have impacts quite a bit different from those good effects that may have been intended.

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#7

Re: I have enough solar to power my house and shop *LINK*

Peter Gregory

>I installed a 5k kWh system this summer. It looks like we are breaking even on electric now. Of course, we have compact florescent lights in every fixture we use and are careful with power use. We are running a 4 bedroom house and separate shop building on the system. The panels we have are invisible to my eyes on a black roof. Cost was just under $30k.

The company being discussed has received quite a bit of press in the business and technical press. They are renting your roof, in exchange for cheaper power. If you think about it, this is the only way to make solar work. The Arizona desert is very far away from most people and the power transmission loss is a killer.

I have included a link to the root company. They have signed up sales force of independent sales people, that causes lots of search engine confusion.

Personally, if the company is willing to foot the bill and give you lower power rates, in exchange for some space on your roof, sounds OK to me. They must be betting on the future price of renewable power to be much higher and you have to buy it from someone. It is funny to see what you can make money doing, if you have enough money.


http://renu.citizenre.com/

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#8

Re: I have enough solar to power my house and shop

Mark Nowicki

>"Our customer � as an alternative � can transfer the REnU to the new home owner, so long as all parties agree and the new mortgage is still willing to subordinate."

So there is a de facto lien placed on the property.

"They must be betting on the future price of renewable power to be much higher and you have to buy it from someone."

Actually , they are betting that the homeowner believes that to be the case. The reality of electricity prices is quite different.

http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/aer/elect.html (All about electricity)

http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/aer/pdf/pages/sec8_38.pdf (Electricity: historical prices)

http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/04000.html (Us census data)

They also counting on the fact that only approximately 52% of the population stays in the same house for more than five years. I wonder how is "reasonable" quantified when someone does wish to terminate.

"It is funny to see what you can make money doing, if you have enough money."

It is funny how it is still possible to try to make money using techniques that have been around since the time of snake oil salesmen.

Plus ca change..

Mark

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#9

Re: I have enough solar to power my house and shop

Peter Gregory

>We will see soon enough what the new power rules to do renewable power prices, maybe not in your state, but in enough of them. I agree this is only for the early adapters of our society, but there is better than a 50% chance that this company or a company like it will win in this market place. They don't need a very high percentage of owners to play. I have made a whole lot of money betting on stupider things. Of course, there are people trying to make solar panels in the lab on computer printers and that might change the world.

Your charts on electrical prices are interesting, as long as Asia lives in the dark. Assuming that they continue their current path to becoming modern countries, things are likely to get dicey soon enough. I guess, if we could burn coal in unlimited amounts, that might work too?

I'm fairly sure that if you rent a piece of property to anyone, they will want a long term lease and be pissed if you take their building down. There is no difference here. The contract is pretty much boiler plate for real estate transactions of this kind (I bet, you would never let a client of yours sign it and so they just wouldn't lease anything - I've fired a few lawyers like this myself). I agree there is risk, but it isn't very much risk, is it?

What I know is that if we allowed lawyers and human resource directors to rule the world, nothing would ever get done. I kind of hope you are right, there is stable power prices and there is just nothing to worry about (I assume that you don't believe in global warming too?). But, I like to plan and then act on these kinds of things. When you are paying less for a solar electric system, than you paid for granite counters, that seems like an OK price to pay. So for me, this was an easy cost to bear.

In the end, I have enough solar capacity to supply electricity to both my house and shop building. As far as solar lease guys, they are big boys and seem to be doing fine. And everyone should read contracts before they sign them.

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#10

Re: I have enough solar to power my house and shop

ScottS

>"Your charts on electrical prices are interesting, as long as Asia lives in the dark. Assuming that they continue their current path to becoming modern countries, things are likely to get dicey soon enough. I guess, if we could burn coal in unlimited amounts, that might work too?"

I, for one, wouldn't bet on increased demand for power in Asia driving up electricity prices in the U.S. over the long term. I also wouldn't bet on solar power holding interest over the long term. It seems more likely that countries with a need for large amounts of electricity, particularly China, will move to nuclear power. Someone will come up with a bullet-proof design for a reactor and then everyone who needs power will start stamping them out...

Re: OT Solar PV power question.

#11

Re: Look into rebates!!

Brian in Brighton

>In Colorado we have rebates from both the power company and the state that will wipe out about 60% or more of the cost of installing the system. I am not sure what your state has, you might be surprised at how much money you can get back on the cost. I know someone in the mountains who put in a 2kW system that cost $24K, with all the rebates, which he got in a few weeks, it cost him less than $10K. Also look into the power company and state requirements. Some areas here allow you to put power back on the grid, but you will never get any money for it. The power companies have lobbied to make it so that you can't run the meter backward and expect to get paid for it. They will take the power, but don't have to pay you for it. Not bad, but another reason lobbiest stink.

I would love to do it and plan on putting it on the shop building when I have it built. Just to recover 75% of the power would be nice.

Please post any pictures of the installation if you get it done.

Brian in Brighton