Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Posting question for Ellis

Posts

Posting question for Ellis

#1

Posting question for Ellis

Brian in Brighton

>In another forum I use we see the message and replies on the page we are writing our replies on. This is very handy to be able to quote other posters and the original question.

With the new system is this something we can look forward too?

Brian in Brighton

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#2

Ellis Walentine

Good question

Ellis Walentine

>To quote a post, you will need to copy and paste the original post into your post and then insert your comments as necessary.

Perhaps you could let me know what forum you would like us to copy.

Ellis

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#3

Re: Posting question for Ellis

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>If you're talking about places like The Oak (which appears to now be defunct), SMC, WoodWorksLive, and others (lots of others in the non-woodworking places I sometimes visit), I absolutely detest the software they use, as one can only see a finite number of threads (collapsed) before one has to click to a subsequent page. If they are set up to display 40 posts (as WWL does) it's marginally acceptable, but SMC is set up for 20 (or was before I was banned) and they often have as many as six sticky posts up which effectively cuts by 33% the number of threads you can look at before having to page. If the forum has any activity at all, threads don't last a half a day on the first page.

Granted, WC has a limit, too, but I've never remotely come close to having to go to Page 2 unless I was looking for something far enough back that a Search was more effective, anyway.

I also don't care for the display of the full text of each message when looking at the thread for a variety of reasons—I posted my throat plate article with about ten pics on another forum with that software, and not one, but two other posters quoted the whole of my text, pictures and all. And guess what? With perhaps only a dozen replies, there were three pages of posts. How is that better?

In any active thread, irrespective of whether the quoting is kept to a reasonable size, there can easily be three or four pages of posts—one can't get the full thread on one browser screen.

I hope you aren't put off by my choice of the word detest in describing my attitude about that software (and infer, correctly I'm sure, that I'm not interested in seeing it implemented here) but that was as gentle a word as I could find to adequately articulate my feeling about it.

Rod

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#4

methods

JohnKJordan in East TN

>I agree that it is extremely useful to see the message and perhaps the entire thread while composing a reply.

As for automated quoting, I've seen Quote buttons implemented several ways.

Method A: a Quote button is provided which copies the entire message to the reply box, delineated by either some special character at the beginning of each quoted line (i.e., ">") or bounded by html code which highlights the quoted text in the final reply (e.g. the ForestryForum.com). The user must manually delete text to streamline the quote.

Method B: the user highlights just the text he wants quoted and the "Reply with Quote" button copies and delineates just that text. If he doesn't highlight anything, the entire message is quoted, same as Method A.

Method C (not a quote button): The original message text is duplicated somewhere on the reply page for review but not automatically quoted.

I found both methods A and B problematic in one respect - some people simply qoute the entire message every time and never edit it down to just the minimum text needed to maintain continuity of thought. This can create huge messages with multiple levels of quotes, each perhaps with multiple pictures, etc. It is frustrating to have to scroll down through three nested quoted message just to read a one line reply! For this reason I quickly came to dislike full-quote buttons, both as a user and moderator.

Method B has an additional problem, pre-selecting just a small amount of text doesn't let the poster read and review the entire message text while composing a reply.

I like method C better, since it displays and allows referral to the message while composing and permits easy copy/paste for quoting. One problem with this method is if a very long message (perhaps with multiple pictures) is duplicated ABOVE the reply box, it pushes the reply box way down the screen. I think a better method is to duplicate the message below the reply box. The ForestryForum actually duplicates the entire thread or the end of a long thread below the reply box. However, that forum doesn't thread and allow replies to individual messages.

The method I currently use for WoodCentral works great for me, but does require some extra screen area - I simply open the reply box in a new window and move it to the second of my dual monitors. This lets me review the message (and the entire thread if needed) on the other screen and copy/paste as needed while composing. Admittedly, this is not as useful on a single montitor system. With limited screen area, I generally select and copy the entire message, paste it into the reply box, then delete or edit it down it before posting. Usually, just leaving one or two lines as a quote is sufficient to maintain continuity in even a convoluted thread.

For general use, I think Method C would be a useful compromise for WoodCentral - duplicate just the message being replied to at the bottom of the reply screen to allow review and copy/paste for manual quoting.

BTW, while on the subject, it would also be useful to duplicate the Preview and Post buttons above the reply box and header (and below any preview) to save having to scroll down so far after previewing or when replying in a small window.

JKJ

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#5

Re: Good question

Ron Hildreth

>Ellis,

In response to your question about which forum to copy -- NONE !!!!

Even though I'm always open to changes,I like it just the way it is!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#6

Good question - Reading

Jim Swank

>I don't post all that often to be troubled by the present system. I do read a lot and it would sure be nice to see the entire thread if you click on one message in it. It would also be helpful to be ble to edit a post you've made, but I realize that poses a whole new level of registration, log-in, authentication, etc. I'm thinking of the message boards on WOW or MyFamily as examples.

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#7

Re: Good question - Reading

Ron Hildreth

>Jim,

You can preview your message or response to a message, but only before actually posting it. I always preview my messages, simply because I don't trust my spelling. In order to change or add something after posting, you're required to just post again, but I've never minded that. It just makes me more careful of what I originally post!

Ron in Iowa

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#8

Ellis Walentine

Longwinded answer

Ellis Walentine

>I don't post all that often to be troubled by the present system.

...but if you did, what would trouble you? :-)

I do read a lot and it would sure be nice to see the entire thread if you click on one message in it.

Set your preferences to Guestbook style if you want to see all the text of all the messages in a thread. If you just want to see all the message headers in a thread, scroll down to the bottom of any given message.

It would also be helpful to be ble to edit a post you've made, but I realize that poses a whole new level of registration, log-in, authentication, etc. I'm thinking of the message boards on WOW or MyFamily as examples.

Actually, it is more involved than that, at least with our current system. WebBBS is a battleship of a forum application, designed back in the old Usenet days using Perl instead of the more current PHP and other scripting languages. I think there are pros and cons to both setups. Our board doesn't offer any editing options at all, and to provide it would be a major Perl proramming nightmare. The closest I can get to an editing feature would be to offer the ability for you to delete your own post. At least then you could start again, but I think there are some snags to this as well, so I have not enabled it.

The biggest con to the more modern boards is the lack of threading. If anyone knows of a forum package that allows us to show entire message threads, let me know. If I could offer the additional features of a modern board without losing the basic functionality of our current boards, I would be on it in a second. So far, I have not had any luck, although we're looking at some other possibilities. If we ever decide to try out a new setup -- our recent changes are mostly just minor variations of our previous setup, offering better navigation and readability (yes, I know there are differing opinions on this) -- you can be sure I will offer it in a beta version first, alongside our current board, so we can all try it out before we make any permanent changes.

One of the biggest advantages of the more modern boards, which may not be immediately obvious -- is the ability to search through the entire message history. WoodCentral has an enormous archive of really wonderful information, on every conceivable woodworking topic and a lot more, but access to this wealth of knowledge is limited, or at least hampered, by the way our scripts store the information. We do have the ability to search the archives, but it is too cumbersome to be inviting, and it places heavy processing demands on our server.

Another advantage of the more modern boards is the ability to have important topics remain "on top" and to be able to configure your viewing in many different ways. Individual messages are hard to find, and you can't tell at a glance who has posted to a particular thread, but topics don't merely scroll away into obscurity.

This last observation reflects a bias of mine, which is that messageboards are all about current thoughts -- quick answers to questions, clear visibility of all participants, and a lot of information in the index screen itself. Archives are nice to have, but they are a separate entity from the immediacy of the conversation. I feel that conversation breeds community and I think it has done so admirably on WoodCentral. "If it ain't broke..." as someone said, is a good way to sum it up. I don't think our recent fixes have broken this basic advantage of our messageboards.

Time will bring more changes here, as it does everywhere on the web and throughout our lives. Woodworkers are older and more resistant to change than other segments of the population, but that doesn't mean that they can't or won't buy into new paradigms and features, especially if they are relatively intuitive by nature and well explained. I will do my best to make sure that future changes here are well thought out and not merely change for the sake of change. For your part, I hope you will indulge any new developments that may appear in coming months, and at least give them the benefit of any doubt.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Thank YOU, Ellis!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>It warms my heart to hear someone (especially a site owner/admin/mod/etc.) say that they LIKE the conversational aspect of posting. I've been to too many forums where the regulars frequently all but run off new users by gruffly replying to a question with, "Do a search. It's all there." It would be like someone asking a question at a get-together and being told to go to the woodworking section of the library.

Jason

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#10

Re: A comprimise?

Brian in Brighton

>What about a compromise that just shows the individual post that you click "Reply" to?

I also detest how many other forums work and most of the long time posters on them. I could quote one of the previous guys who said that some long term posters are jerks about newbies and just tell them to go do a search. How many questions have we had relating to the following topics? Electrical, Heating, Band Saw Blades, Storage, etc, etc.

I like the way WC is set up and it is why I don't bother with other woodworking forums, they stink. I was just thinking that since some other forums show the post for the reply it would be nice to do the same.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#11

Other boards that look pretty good *LINK*

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>Ellis, I occasionally read and post over on the LumberJocks site (I'm still a WoodCentralian, though). I'm guessing they are using bought (and likely customized) software. The site has accommodations blogs, podcasts and videos as well as blogs. It's heavily focused on pictures as well (wonder what that kind of storage space costs). They also have RSS feeds for those of us that like to see updates easily. When reading a thread on that site, every reply is displayed chronologically below one another. No indenting to show sub threads, though. That's in interesting thing, though. I think sub-threads are useful to us programming geeky types, but non-techies don't seem to need them at all.

All in all, I like the enhanced video, picture and blog capabilities over there. I would thinks the blogs would be especially nice - consider Bill's multi-part post about making lumber.

Anyway, just some thought. These are the types of things I get into at my day job (building business intelligence systems). Oh, and there is certainly nothing wrong with old battleship systems. I wouldn't be surprised to hear that some of my old stuff is still running somewhere. We didn't have much to work with so simple and clean were requirements.

You can see this board here:


LumberJocks

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#12

Guestbook style question

wilbur

>When viewing messages in guestbook style, which I tend to do, everything is center justified. This is hard to read, especially in longer posts. Can this be set to left justified? I think the guestbook mode used left justification at one time.

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#13

Re: Guestbook style question

JohnKJordan in East TN

>wilber,

Have you tried it lately? For a short time things were center-justified but no longer, at least here, in any mode I've tried.

JKJ

Re: Posting question for Ellis

#14

Re: Guestbook style question

wilbur

>I'm looking at this thread right now in guestbook mode, and everything is center justified.

Using Safari / Mac OS X.