>The way I understand it (which could be completely wrong), radiant heat gets your shop warm by warming all of the metal areas in your shop. The heat then radiates off the metal and heats the air, and hopefully you. But do your tools ever get too hot for you to touch? Or are they kept below a certain point?
>Radiant Energy warms almost any surface it strikes, not just metal. Other than that you are correct. It basically does not warm the air directly but warms the surfaces, including your skin and clothes, and they in turn warm the air.
The broiler in your oven is designed to cook with radiant energy and it is clear that it could and does make surfaces too hot to touch. OTOH, it is easy to control the heat and not allow things to get out of hand. Radiant space heaters can have a thermostat like any other heater and can be set so that they are less intense and heat slower and faster.
The sun radiates its heat to the Earth. Virtualize the difference g=between a hot summer day and a cold winter day. In the summer you might be seeking a little shade to knock the direct gain off your skin, but in winter you and most of the cats in the world might be trying to find a nice sunny spot.
Dark surfaces heat up quickly, shiny reflective and white surfaces reflect the heat and do not heat up as readily.
Radiant heat heats objects, not air. That makes it more efficient because warm air rises to the ceiling, whereas warm objects don't. If you are cool sit on the floor-the higher you go the cooler you get. IIRC the temperature of the water in the tubing is about 80* so you can not get burned.
I had radiant in my last shop and will have it in my new shop. I usually kept the temperature at 55* and was plenty warm working. If you go this route, and I highly recommend it, be certain to have a moisture barrier and insulation under your slab. I think that if you search the archives, you will find many threads about radiant.
>Interesting...we seen to have two kinds in mind. I think the first couple of posts were thinking of the electric radiant "space heater", while the last was thinking about hot water in-floor radiant heat.
>I put an overhead radiant ( LV ) up. Thing was My BIG Dremel hangs right in front of it. I hung a peice of aluminum ( Tin ) foil just between the machine and the heater. Does a good job. Probably didn't need to but . . .
>Since I have been down this road with WC input Lynn, I'll let you know what I found out.
Some of my customers have radiant heaters in their shop floors with the tubes 20+ feet high. They leave a band of heat under them and you can tell the difference when you are in the shop. The tools under them are indeed warmer than the ones elsewhere. I went with a forced air unit from Mr. Heater and have been happy.
How high are your ceilings? You need to have pretty tall ones to be able to use radiant gas heaters. I think the tube ones require 12 foot minimum. I was able to mount my heater near the ceiling and it seems to be great.
Just my 2 cents. I would encourage you to dig in deeper with the makers of these units to see if you can put it into your shop.
>I have a one car uninsulated garage that's my shop. The entrance/exit is the door built for the car and it doesn't close tight. Probably the original door that was put there when the house was built in 1940. If I'm inside the overhead door closes very loosely, which is probably a good thing for ventilation but I imagine that there is a great loss of heat. During the summer, I leave the overhead door open. I have had a radiant heater put in up in the rafters and I imagine that most of the heat stays up high. Because of the cold, I have been very reluctant to work in there during the winter but I may be changing that. I am just a hobbiest (retired Fed)and I have enough things to keep me occupied inside the house but once in a while I want to make things like Christmas ornaments or B-Day presents and I want to work in the shop during the winter. Perhaps I have never given the heater a chance to do its work yet. There is no thermostat. It gets turned on and off at the circuit braker. The professionals did all of the installation.