Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Posts

OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#1

OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Dan Mitchell

>I posted earlier & got some great feedback on sealing a sewer pipe to help keep rats out of the crawl space of our new house. I also touched on the topic of cleaning up the area once the little buggers have been eliminated. I'm hoping to get a bit more input on this, if the group will indulge me. If the assortment of insulation between the joists is any indication, some has been replaced at least once, likely from this problem, and a bunch of it is torn/pulled down/soiled now from the animals as well. Of course the goal is to permanently keep rodents out of the space, and I am working on that. However I plan to have ALL the fiberglass removed & replaced with new insulation. I am wondering if there is any type of insulation, maybe a rigid foam board material, or something sprayed on, which would be suitable for this application and that is resistant if not impervious to rodents getting into it, on top of it, pulling it down & nesting in it. Any ideas?

Thanks all,

Dan

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#2

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Edward in Vancouver

>Rats are damaging little critters, like all rodents, they HAVE to chew constantly or their front teeth will eventually grow too large and they will starve to death. Any farmer can tell you they will chew on anything, and have caused numerous fires (and electrocuted themselves in the process..)by chewing through the insulation on wiring. Seam free steel or aluminum plate thicker than 18 guage usually will keep them at bay, but it has to be seam free, they can and will chew/pull out rivets, I kid you not. They can chew through PVC plumbing and can scratch and wear away at ceramic tile and pipes as well The largest bone in the rat's body is his skull, so any hole larger than a quarter and most rats can squeeze through, mice and juvenile rats can get through holes as small as 1/2". Some people have had success with stuffing crevices with coarse steel wool, as most rodents do not like to chew on this, but steel rusts, copper (ie copper or s/s pot scrubbers) or other materials may work.

You don't want to know about the gestation period of rats, or the litter size, and keep in mind there is no such thing as rat incest or gay rats either....

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#3

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Barry Irby

>Dan, I would not assume that various brands on insulation in your crawl means some has been replaced. I often see more than one brand. Apparrently professional insulators are not brand sensitive and use what ever they have on had to get the job done.

There is spray on foam such as Urethane or Icynene (sp? Pronounce Icy-eene) Both are several times as expensive as fiberglass. Not sure either is rodent resistant. Rodents could tunnel into them if they got a notion.

There are some definite drawbacks. It can not be easily removed for inspection of the surrounding material. It might actually contribute to the problem by concealing leaks and not allowing the affected wood to dry before it rots.

The latest thing in crawl spaces is "the conditioned crawl space". I have to go to work now, so do some research on the idea. (Check Crawlspace.com) (I think). The idea is to insulate the walls of the CS and not the floor and to opening up some heat and AC vents under the house. Treating the CS as if it were part of the conditioned space. Its the coming "thing" in crawl spaces. (foundation vents would be sealed)

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#4

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Danarrowsmith

>We had a problem with an insulated lean-to shed that housed an ice builder, It was insulated with fiberglass batts and was 10 to 15 foot high. The rats nested at several different levels and made a mess of the whole thing. The solution was to close up holes with steel wool and expanding foam, add snap traps and bait stations and heavily bait around rat holes in the ground that was the original source. Since then it has been rat free but I do catch the ocasional rat in the rat traps outside. A very good bait for snap traps is sardines. Rats keep close to walls so bait as close to the wall as possible. Good Luck

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#5

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies & the interesting site reference. I had wondered about the feasibility of "paving" down there. Gotta be expensive, but the state of it now really is a bloody nightmare. I'll post a couple pics later. Just about the most unpleasant place I've ever spent time in my life. Plus we had torrential storms a few days back here in the pacific NW, and there's about 2" of standing water in places. 1st time I've seen that down there.

What makes me think the insulation has been replace is it's 2 different R-values.

I'm looking at the company below for clean up. Apparently all they do is clean up & especially insulation removal, which I think is a good approach; they won't be trying to "sell me" on anything else. Once all the crap is out of the way, it should be easier to see what's going on, rat-wise.

Dan


Rapid Vac

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#6

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Dan Mitchell

>Here're some pics of the Benighted Space. Bare earth, plastic and a variety of insulation all around, clearance of about 2' (at best) in spots. If anyone with experience in any aspect of this has any observations, I'm all ears.

TIA

Dan


img

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#7

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Barry Irby

>Dan, As a Home Inspector, this is by far not the nastiest crawl space I have ever seen. (Throw in a Chorus of "Nobody knows the Trouble I've seen...")

Aren't you in Seattle, in Washington? I'm in Va and not really familiar with your climate. I think it is milder than mine because of a warm water current off the coast, but that's about all I know. What I am getting at is that you crawl space insulation is upside down for a heating climate. In a Heating climate, the vapor barrier on the insulation goes against the floor, on the "warm" side of the insulation. Also it appears you have four inch ducts wrapped with fiberglass, without a external vapor barrier. Generally, four inch ducts are considered small for Air Conditioning. AC usually has more air flow than heat and to keep the noise and velocity down, they use six inch ducts. Also, AC ducts get chilled when the AC runs and they sweat or produce condensation unless they are wrapped with an external vapor barrier.

You also have what we would call "temporary supports". Short vertical posts resting on block, resting on the surface of the grade. They appear to have been added in later, often to stiffen a floor to stop the glassware from tinkling.

The Vapor barrier on the grade appears incomplete. This sometimes allows enough moisture to bypass it to wet the Crawlspace. The good news is, I don't see a bunch of mold growing on Joists, and believe me, I have seen a bunch around here.

The standing water you mentioned is a concern. You need to examine the exterior perimeter of the foundation and see if you have any "negative slope". Don't allow water to run against the foundation. You want Positive slope or be sure the soil slopes away from the house all the way around. (If the standing water was truly a freak event, it is less of a concern than if it happens after most heavy rains, but once the water establishes a path into the house, it may happen more frequently.)

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#8

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>Barry - Thanks for the reply. Your responses are very helpful. Glad to hear it's not the worst, I can say it's the worst I'VE seen, but since that's only about 3 such spaces, I guess that doesn't mean much! I did have the home inspected prior to sale, the inspector didn't seem to think it was a big deal, either.

Most houses in Seattle don't have AC. We have a heat pump & being heat intolerant I do run the AC, though not nearly as much as I did in Ohio. Summers are much cooler & much less humid. Interesting about the insulation vapor barrier. I wonder if, given the possibility of moisture from the ground & moisture from a heated space above, vapor barrier on BOTH SIDES might not be good. If there is such a thing. The ducts are 6", a bit hard to tell in the pics. I had never seen the bare insulation wrap before, I can tell you it's a royal PITA when you bump your head into it while working in the dungeon!

I know the plastic ground cover needs to be replaced.

I haven't noticed mold either. The space smells a bit "earthy", but not really bad. But I generally wear a respirator down there. I imagine in Virginia mold could be a real issue. People talk about Seattle being rainy, in fact it ranks about 40th as a city in total annual rainfall nation wide. I do think the standing water was unusual, though the front grade definitely slopes toward the house, with a 2' depression near a fireplace that juts out, bay-window style. Looking at the terrain, I'm thinking you'd have to install a drain in this depression, since the road is actually higher than the floor of the house at that point. Plus amazingly, the wall has siding on it as it goes down in the depression, so you couldn't just fill it in (who designs this stuff?).

On the rodent front, when I took the pics & walked (crawled) about 2/3 of the perimeter, only say maybe 15 droppings, all hard. I have 2 bait boxes outside with single feed commercial poison (link below). They are getting more hits, with the colder weather. 4 traps in the space are thus far undisturbed (except by me, I put my hand in one yesterday while down there. Good thing I was wearing a glove! Still hurt like hell...

Your observations are invaluable Barry. When you're paying someone, it's so hard to tell what their true motives are. I really appreciate it!

Dan


Final blox

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#9

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>Dan, I have a similar space and a similar problem, although I think my rodents are mice rather than rats.

I had posted a question regarding how to fix/protect the insulation over at Fine Homebuilding, and was advised to put hardware cloth at the bottom of the joists after I'd replaced the insulation.

I got a couple of rolls of the hardware cloth (seems like an odd name for a metal mesh) at HD, but haven't got around to installing as yet. I assume a really determined rodent could chew through but I'd think they'd be more likely to go elsewhere.

Maybe this helps.

Ken

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

#10

Re: OT Rats in crawl space/insulation follow up

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Ken. I recently installed some hardware cloth over the soffit vents in one area of the eaves where a bird was getting in & snatching bits of blown in insulation, apparently for nesting material (I'm REALLY feeling besieged here... ;-) I think putting it over the fiberglass in the crawl space would be a great approach, I bet it would discourage much it not all of the nesting there. I'd need about 1400 sq', probably fairly expensive. My main problem though with this whole area is you can't reasonably GET TO at least 1/3 of it. I'd do the insulation and hardware cloth myself, if it weren't for the miserable clearance.

Dan