Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Soundproofing Dust Collector

Posts

Soundproofing Dust Collector

#1

Soundproofing Dust Collector

Stephen Roth, Chatham NJ

>A put a 3 HP Oneida Dust Gorilla in my basement shop. The thing really SUCKS (That is a compliment!) It is, however, a bit noisy. I can't put the collector in a side room because of spacing, and I was wondering if anyone had experience building a sound proofing closet around a large collector like this. I understand the mechanics of building the whole thing, but I would like to hear from someone who actually tried to put in some soundproofing. Does it work? I am especially concerned about the higher frequency noises, which seems to be getting into a stange harmonic with the planer and routers, causing a really annoying noise.

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#2

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

Paul Woolson

>If you extend the exhaust with insulated heat pipe, that seams to help a bit. You also want to make sure your exhaust filter isn't in contact with a wall or joist or your shop will become a big resonance box (think guitar)

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#3

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

David Hay @ Denver

>The most recent Fine Woodoworking issue (Tools & Shops) had an article about building a box for a shop vac to help keep the noise down. Used particle board and sound absorbent fabric with baffles for the exhaust. Seems to me that the same idea could be applied to a dust collector as well (obviously a bigger box ;)

David

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#4

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I designed my shop with a "soundproof" closet for the DC. It helps quite a bit. But, honestly, the closet makes the DC take up a bunch more space. Plus, the air in the ducting still makes enough noise that I tend to turn it off between uses. I'm not sure the quieter operation really does me any good. I'm not sure if you have a remote control for it, but that to me is more useful than the closet. Since there are some other things in the closet, I leave the door open on the closet sometimes. I eventually realize that the DC is extra loud and close it. But, if I didn't have the door to close I don't think I'd be that upset.

Jay

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#5

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

David Charters (Durham, NC)

>I am taking a class in Acoustics, didn't expect to ever actually use it. Well, what we learned is that the high frequency noise should be the easy part to get rid of with a barrier. It's the lower frequency sound that is tough to stop.

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#6

DC Muffler *LINK*

Ken Krawford

>Steven,

Here's a link to Bill Penz's web site that has plans for a dust collector muffler. I made one for my cyclone and I think it helps.


Dust Collector Muffler

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#7

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

jeff

>Stephen

I had the same problem with my Penn State cyclone.

I eventually moved it out of the shop. (for the space actually)

But, I tried an experiment that worked well till I moved it.

I built sound barriers out of old pieces of carpet. I hung them from the ceiling and it worked great.

If you want more info, just ask and I'll explain more.

Jeff

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#8

The Oneida cyclones come standard with ...........

Art Silva

>a silencer and filter that drop to decibels to 80 to 82 at 10 ft. If you are complaining about the motor, which you did not mention, then you have to install some soundproofing around the top of the cyclone. The motor is totaly-enclosed-fan-cooled, the enclosure does not have to be airtight. Art

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

#9

Re: Soundproofing Dust Collector

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I did a lot of research on soundproofing before building my basement shop and designing the DC closet. The DC itself is isolated from the shop structure completely. If it weren't for the ductwork, the DC would be very quiet. Even closing all blast gates helps significantly. Once a blast gate is open, there is a certain sound level from the airflow within. The airflow through many of the tools also whistles and makes noise itself. But, the running of tool I'm using is the bigger problem. There's no real getting around that one. Since I turn off the DC between operations anyway, I don't really see the purpose of the soundproof closet. Too bad that's in hindsight as I'd like to have the extra space around the DC.

It might be worth taking some steps to try and quiet it a bit, but I wouldn't go crazy with it again. I've been thinking about tearing down my closet and building a plywood rack instead. That would block some of the sound from the main shop, but significantly less than the closet. Since that involves drywall and insulation, my motivation is low.

Jay