Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Shop electical question

Posts

Shop electical question

#1

Shop electical question

Robert Henderson

>I am moving my woodworking equipment from the gararage to the basement. Since the main electical panel is much closer an more accessable, I'm going to add a bunch of outlets for my power tools.

Some of my equipment (table saw, band saw, jointer) has motors that will run on 115V or 230V.

Is there any benifit to running them at 230V as opposed to 115V?

Re: Shop electical question

#2

Re: Shop electical question

Rick Christopherson

>No, there is not a benefit. As long as you are running new circuits to the tools, they will not know the difference. The only time this should ever be an issue is if the house wiring was substandard. The internal windings on the motors see 120 volts regardless how they are configured.

Re: Shop electical question

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Shop electical question

Jesper, Denmark

>Yes, lower voltage drop on 220 Volt - and you need smaller wire gauge for the same power on 220 than you do on 110 Volt.

Re: Shop electical question

#4

I like it! A No and a Yes. I vote......

Barry Irby

>No. Assuming the runs are pretty short, less than forty/fifty feet or so, and the wires are the proper size, there will be very little voltage drop and essentially no difference. Yes, a tool that draws 14 amps at 110/120 with draw 7 amps at 220/240, and you could use a smaller wire, you would have to have an additional conductor and a double pole breaker. You can check, but there is likely not to be enough savings on the wire (size) to justify the addition conductor. You should also check and be sure your machines would not need new switches if you change them over to 220. They would certainly need new plugs or cords unless they are hard wired. Just be sure the wire in the circuits is big enough to offset any voltage drop and go ahead with the 120.

Re: Shop electical question

#5

Um, Conductor?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Barry,

Did you say "additional" conductor? We had an issue here not long ago about using 3-wire (B/W/R) + ground for 220 circuits, but that extra "conductor" is useless in a 220 circuit unless a 110 branch is taken off. Otherwise, every 220 I've seen is always wired with 2 hots and a bare ground with the white conductor reflagged to a black with tape.

This something new coming out under the NEC?

mm

Re: Shop electical question

#6

Re: Shop electical question

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>What has not been mentioned yet is load balancing. A 220 circuit draws from both legs of the service equally. This helps to avoid voltage drops when you power on the equipment.

Re: Shop electical question

#7

Response to Several Replies

Rick Christopherson

>Regarding the issue of voltage drop, this is mentioned frequently when this topic comes up, but no one ever bothers to research the proper answer.

The voltage drop on a 50 foot, 120 volt, 20 amp circuit with #12 wire is 3.176 volts.

The voltage drop on a 50 foot, 240 volt, 15 amp circuit with #14 wire is 3.789 volts.

Even though this is a lesser percentage of the total voltage at 240 volts, it is still trivial in the overall operation of the motor. The power from your utility company will fluctuate more than this throughout the day.

By the way, the figures above are based on taking 100% of the available current in a circuit. Most of these dual voltage motors are not drawing the full power of the circuit.

======================================

Even though people frequently say that a good reason for making the change is because you can use smaller wire, virtually none of them actually practice this advice. As a matter of fact, most people do the opposite, and install #10 wire for all of their 240 volt circuits (but that's a different discussion).

====================================

It is not necessary to replace the tool's power switch when converting the motor to 240 volts. This is a common misconception because people know that you need a 2-pole circuit breaker, but don't realize that the existing single-pole switch is all that is required to be safe, and to meet the NEC. Because the switch is integral to the tool, it is not required to disconnect both hot conductors. Furthermore, it is not a safety concern unless you are in the habit of opening the motor's junction box with the power turned on, and if you do practice this, then you deserved to get zapped. :)

====================================

The issue of load balancing is correct, but this is only applicable to situations where the subpanel feeding the work area is very small, and you are operating it near capacity. in terms of a main load center or normal sized subpanel, load balancing is not an issue of concern.

Re: Shop electical question

#8

Huh??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rick,

Are you truly saying that it is proper to switch a 220 circuit with a single-pole switch? Doesn't that leave one side hot and feeding the motor. EVERYONE I've EVER spoken to, Ordinary Sparky or EE, has always said double pole switch required. JET uses 2-pole switches for just this reason, but many manufacturers do not and state that if you convert the tool to 220, you need a new switch.

mm

Re: Shop electical question

#9

WOW! GREAT ANSWER!

geary from nj

>

Re: Shop electical question

#10

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>And what's zup with this 4-wire circuit (3 conductor + ground) I'm hearing about? Is this a new NEC thing?

Thanks

mm

Re: Shop electical question

#11

Not trying to be argumentative...

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Not trying to start an argument, since you probably are right, but if it's true you don't need to switch both conductors on a 220 feed to the tool, please explain how NEC (2005) section 404.15 (B) does not apply here. I just want to understand this.

Re: Shop electical question

#12

My Bad, OOP's.

Barry Irby

>I was thinking of a dryer. They have four wire circuits on them now. Probably because they have electronic controls that require a neutral. At least that is what a Sparky told me today. But you are right, a TS would not require an additional wire.

I am still concerned about the switch though. When I converted my lathe, Nova/Technatool instructed me to change the switch.

It is true, that every 220 device I know of stops operating when you turn off one leg, bot the other leg is still energised.

Re: Shop electical question

#13

Ahhhh, HA!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>THAT's what I thought the 4-wire deal was! Glad I have some 4-wire stock; SWMBO's looking at a new set so I GET to rewire. Lucky for me the main panel's in the basement directly under the dryer. 6' of wire out of the box will do the whole job.

[Ain't your bad.]

|;-}}}

Re: Shop electical question

#14

Okay, I'm confused.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"....It is not necessary to replace the tool's power switch when converting the motor to 240 volts. This is a common misconception because people know that you need a 2-pole circuit breaker, but don't realize that the existing single-pole switch is all that is required to be safe, and to meet the NEC. Because the switch is integral to the tool, it is not required to disconnect both hot conductors. Furthermore, it is not a safety concern unless you are in the habit of opening the motor's junction box with the power turned on, and if you do practice this, then you deserved to get zapped. :) ..."

Here's a stupid question or two:

If you've got two hots going to a 240V motor, and you only have a SPST switch, do that mean one of the hots is always connected (ie, there's no switch to turn it off)?

Will a 220V motor stop if you disconnect one of the hots, but leave the other hot connected?

Does Delta/Jet/etc tell you you need to use a DPST switch when you change from 120V to 240V simply to sell you a switch to make money?

I know that you sometime don't need to replace the switch when going from 120V to 240V, because they supply a DPST switch to begin with, but apparently I was one of those with the misconception that a switch on a 240V tool or appliance had to disconnect both hots.

Happy Woodowkring!

Re: Shop electical question

#15

Re: Response to Several Replies

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Actually the issue of load balancing really does not apply as much to the shop area but to keeping the rest of the house happy. Most power tools can tolerate that momentary drop. But. If the UPS on SWMBO's computer switches to battery every time you start the table saw or the monitor goes squiggly..... the issue will visit the shop. Then there are the game consoles that often don't like the power sages either and in general, the dimming of lights tends to bother people.

If you use 220v your brother-in-law won't be able to borrow the table saw the next time he needs to cut some sheetrock.

One also must take the Tim Taylor factor in to consideration.

Bill on the windy Oregon coast, we're sending the next storm your way.

Re: Shop electical question

#16

Re: NEC (2005) Article 404

Rick Christopherson

>No, I didn't consider your posting to be argumentative. I liked the fact that you provided an NEC reference for your thoughts. Unfortunately, the most common cause for NEC misinterpretations is that someone will extract a piece of information from code and not realize that it is a subset to a senior, or parent section of code.

The NEC Article 404 information is pertaining to facility switches used within a building or dwelling. This section is not applicable to the switches integral to the piece of equipment. If you scroll up a few sections you will notice this.

Yes, for switches located within the building (facility switches), the switch must break all non-grounded conductors.

The power switch on a tool is not in this same classification because it is integral to the tool.

Re: Shop electical question

#17

Re: Huh??

Rick Christopherson

>Are you truly saying that it is proper to switch a 220 circuit with a single-pole switch?

No, I am not saying it is permitted to switch a "circuit" in this manner, at least not the way we typically use the term "circuit" as being part of the facility power system.

This is strictly relating to the integral control circuit within the piece of equipment.

Re: Shop electical question

#18

Re: Okay, I'm confused.....

Rick Christopherson

>


Will a 220V motor stop if you disconnect one of the hots, but leave the other hot connected?
Yes, a motor, any motor will cease to operate if you break the circuit in any way. It doesn't matter if the motor is 120 volts or 240 volts, both wires going to the motor are "current carrying conductors". If you stop the current, you stop the motor.

What is confusing you is that we choose to anchor one of the wires to ground. Aside from this relationship, there is no difference between a hot conductor and a grounded (Neutral) conductor.


Does Delta/Jet/etc tell you you need to use a DPST switch when you change from 120V to 240V simply to sell you a switch to make money?
When you say "Delta/Jet/etc. tells you..." aren't you just referring to technical phone support? These people are trained to troubleshoot and service their equipment, but you shouldn't assume that they are fully knowledgeable in electrical wiring or the National Electrical Code. Afterall, it was technical phone support that was telling many people that they needed a 30-amp circuit for a 3 hp motor (as reported on this and many other forums).

Re: Shop electical question

#19

Ah, The Can/Should Conflict

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Now I understand.

"Code" allows one leg to be hot and the unit won't run on one hot leg (Robert Klein aside) from the device switch, so a single pole switch is "sufficient" to take a 220 motor between "run" and "stop."

Notwithstanding the "Can", I will make a value judgment ("Should") to interrupt both hot conductors at the switch, so that no power can flow through the machine wires in any event. It will not suffice for me to look at the person who gets zapped and say "Your own fault, fool" when I can take a simple step toward Idiot-proof merely by using a double pole switch on the machine.

Thanks for the explanation, Rick.

mm

Re: Shop electical question

#20

the question of flow

John in New Mexico

>"Notwithstanding the "Can", I will make a value judgment ("Should") to interrupt both hot conductors at the switch, so that no power can flow through the machine wires in any event."

interrupting one hot will suffice to halt the flow of electrons in a 220V circuit, as the return path is the alternate hot wire. Using a double pole switch is no more safe when working on a hot box, there are still hot wires in there whether they're switched or not!

Re: Shop electical question

#21

Re: Ah, The Can/Should Conflict

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> Notwithstanding the "Can", I will make a value judgment ("Should") to interrupt both hot conductors at the switch, so that no power can flow through the machine wires in any event. It will not suffice for me to look at the person who gets zapped and say "Your own fault, fool" when I can take a simple step toward Idiot-proof merely by using a double pole switch on the machine.

I detect more Blackstone in your response than, say, Edison. If you think about this electrically, there is absolutely no difference in switching your 120V table lamp at the socket (with a non polarized plug) than there is in switching only one leg in a 240V circuit. In that table lamp (non polarized plug) there is a 50/50 chance that 120V can exist at the socket even with the switch in the off position. To be consistent in your idiot proofing, you should go around your house and replace every legacy non-polarized plug device with one that does have a polarized plug.

The switch is intended as an on/off device, not a circuit cut off device. A SPST switch on a 240V device will certainly accomplish the on/off. By all means use a DPST switch if it makes you feel better, but I have to ask—what's the difference between having a motor shut off with only one hot leg disconnected and having it shut off with both hot legs disconnected, but with full voltage still present at the switch, typically less than three feet away from the motor? On/off and circuit disconnect are two different things. Use the circuit breaker if you don't want any voltage at the device when it's not running.

So many people equate “ground” (zero volts with respect to ground—and carrying no current) with “neutral” (sometimes zero volts with respect to ground but carrying current) in residential wiring, and nothing could be further from the truth. In 240V systems, both leads are current carrying conductors. In 120V systems, both leads are current carrying conductors.

Rod

Re: Shop electical question

#22

One thing to Stress

Rick Christopherson

>Because there seems to be so much confusion regarding what I stated yesterday, I want to make sure that one thing is perfectly clear.

This does not apply to facility wiring!

If you install a wall switch to control a 240 volt load, such as lights or an outlet, then you Must break all non-grounded conductors. If you install a service disconnect at a tool (not the control-type) then you Must break all grounded and non-grounded conductors. If the control switch is not integral with the equipment it is controlling, then I think you are still required to break all non-grounded conductors.

People are reacting to this much stronger than I was expecting. If you open up the control panel on a piece of equipment, you will have live power present regardless what state the switch is in. It is for this reason that all equipment must have a service disconnect for the equipment (a plug is considered a service disconnect).

You cannot "Idiot-Proof" a piece of equipment if the idiot in question does not utilize the mandatory service disconnect before servicing the internal components of the equipment.

Re: Shop electical question

#23

Re: Shop electical question

Rich Egan

>Since I re-wired my tablesaw to 220V it seems to spin up faster and have more power under load. Maybe just my perception?

Re: Shop electical question

#24

Re: One thing to Stress

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Rick - I understand where you're coming from with the interpretation of what and what not to do, and by code, you may well be right. But code is a bare minimum and at times, not the best thing to do. This may be one of those situations.

I do agree that folks should not open a motor access panel without disconnecting ALL power from the source, but that's no excuse for not taking advantage of a safety opportunity just to prove correctness.

Any hot line feeding any piece of equipment needs to be broken any and every time it's switched. This is applicable at the breaker, the disconnect and the switch.

This means a 110VAC circuit must have the single hot leg broken, a 220 VAC circuit must have both legs broken and a 3-phase circuit must have all three legs broken. As you've pointed out, the ground is not switched nor is the neutral on a 110VAC circuit.

Doing anything else is simply not responsible.

Rob

Re: Shop electical question

#25

Re: Shop electical question

Howard Norman

>No, it may well be true that your motor spins up faster on 220. Depending on the distance from the breaker the lower current draw during start up could make the motor get to speed faster. I would not expect it to run any better under load unless the wiring was marginal to begin with.

Howard