Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Crown up or down on workbench top?

Posts

Crown up or down on workbench top?

#1

Crown up or down on workbench top?

pecker

>I made a woodworking bench top from 2 pieces of 3/4" plywood laminated around a core of 3/4" mdf. I used a vacuum press for this. It's 30" x 68".

Along it's length it came out very flat. Using a 6ft straitedge I can't get a .01" feeler gauge between it and the bench top. However, from the front to the back, there is a crown on top side, and a dip on bottom, amounting to about .02". I had hoped to use this as an assembly table, also, so I'm concerned about which side should face upward.

My inclination is to put the crown up in the hopes it will sag over time. But if it doesn't, I will forever have my workpieces rocking on this crown.

Since the next step is making an edge band from solid wood and adding a vise, I need to decide now. I will also be putting a layer of 1/4" tempered hardboard on the top, in case this makes any difference.

Any suggestions?

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#2

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>You're pulling our collective leg, right? The stuff I put together rocks on its own, regardless of where I assemble it.

Clint

DWBH

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#3

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

pecker

>Yeah, I've had stuff I built do that, too. And I'd like to try to avoid it in the future.

I realize that for about 80% of things this kind of imprecision doesn't matter. But there have been times where a gap of .01" or so in a joint I've made is quite visible...and annoying. And I have bad eyesight!

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#4

some ideas

Derek

>That is one reason I made a solid wood top for my current workbench. My old one had a top of 2 layers of PB laminated.

You need to have a rigid and strong undercarriage anyway if you want the top to be and remain flat. If you put a strong brace or two under it in the center, you may be able to pull it flat with some heavy screws. If not, perhaps you can put some strong steel under it (thick tubing or I-beam or similar. and bolt it to the steel in the center (assuming you put the crown up).

If all else fails, try hand-planing the center flat and cover the top with something like the hardboard, I think you mentioned, some baltic birch or perhaps even some thick veneer.

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#5

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

Barry Irby

>I would put it grown up. I would sand the crown a bit and then stick the Masonite down with double stick tape. I would use several thicknesses of tape along the edges and none in the center.

Or I might take it to someone with a Big drum sander or one of the industrial belt sanders and sand it flat. I have a friend with a 36" wide belt sander and it would make short work of .02". About one pass on each side.

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#6

Just build a torsion box under it.

Ron Hildreth

>

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#7

Re: A pic

pecker

>Just to give some reference, here is a pic of the bench so far. The top is currently 2 + 1/8" thick and weighs abot 80 pounds.

I like the idea of a giant drum sander, but don't have any connections in the woodworking biz.


img

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#8

Re: A pic

CJ McLaughlin

>You don't need connections in the woodworking business. Look up your local lumber outlets (not big box) and millwork shops. In my experience you'll get charged 20-30 to simply turn the sander on, and a few more dollars per hour on top of that. Come to think of it, this is where the connections come into play. ;) You'll likely pay no more than $35 to get it sanded.

CJ

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#9

don't worry about it

Thomas S Stockton

>Put the feeler gauges down and step away from the table. If it were a planer, jointer or another tool yeah it could cause problems but .02 over 30" is plenty good for an assembly table. I would put the crown up and it will probably lesson over time, a glob of finish left on the table will be more than .02 so will a chunk of sawdust. If your worried about it you could send it through a wide belt but you'll probably blow through the top veneer. Yeah it freaks you out because you spent a lot of time on it and want it to be perfect but I will guarantee you that you are the only one that will ever know and it's not going to cause problems with assembly.

Tom

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#10

I Agree. Its Already Flat as a Flounder

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Crown up or down on workbench top?

#11

Agreed

Chris Knob

>If you were assembling aluminum parts for aircraft components, maybe you might have an issue. Feeler gauges and woodworking dont mix. Yes, I hear your concerns about errors but the tolerences you are talking about are outside the daily movement parameters of most wood species.