Re: 8" Grizzly jointers - 490 vs 586/593
Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana
>"Thinking of putting a Grizzly 8" jointer on the Christmas list. Can anybody explain the advantages of the parallelogram bed design (G0490) vs. the dovetail-ways design (G0586 or G0593). Other than an extra inch or so of length, the only differences I can see are the bed design and 2HP vs 3HP. I have to believe that the 2HP motor is more than enough juice, so I don't see a huge need for 3HP. Is the parallelogram bed design that much better to justify the additional cost?"
I have the G0-593 (dovetailed ways with wheel adjustment). This machine is equipped with the Grizzly version of the Byrd cutterhead.
The Byrd is supposed to have some advantage due to the inserts being angled in the head and /or a radius. However I also have a 20" Planer with the Byrd cutterhead system and can see no difference in the cut quality - even with very gnarly woods. I have never had any issue with lack of horsepower, never heard the machine slow even with full width cuts on White oak. The parallelogram beds are supposed to be easier to align, but I have never found any reason to need to align my joiners. I used the Grizzly 6" for several years before replacing it with the 8" - sold it to a good friend - the beds were as straight, coplanar and flat as new after about 14 years. (and I lifted it by the beds several times.).
"Also, the spiral cutterheads available on each appear equivalent, yet there's a $330 premium on the G0593 vs a $470 premium on the G0490. And it actually appears about $100 cheaper after shipping to buy the G0490 with straight knives and purchase the spiral upgrade separately. Am I missing something?"
Didn't look into that, however Griz does sell both the actual Byrd head and their version made in China. Don't know if that is the issue or just a special price on the 593.
"One last question - a previous post on this topic stated that the spiral cutterheads on the grizzly weren't Boyd. The replacements on the Grizzly website are boyd, but it's unclear about the spiral heads shipped pre-installed. can anybody confirm whether they're Boyd also?"
As I said, Grizzly sells both the Byrd and their Chinese version of the segmented spiral cutter head (and replacement inserts for both). The G0593 does come with the Grizzly version - per the above info, I can't see any performance difference, although the Grizzly heads and inserts are quite a bit cheaper.