Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

*** New E-mail Feature ***

Posts

*** New E-mail Feature ***

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** New E-mail Feature ***

Ellis Walentine

>Howdy, folks. There has been a lot of discussion in the past couple days about the vulnerabilities of our e-mail display mode, which allows other visitors to view and/or "harvest" the e-mail address you put into your message posts. We've discussed this in the past and the consensus has always been to leave the e-mails visible, but I think it is probably time for a change. Today I have reconfigured the messageboards to show only a blind link to someone's e-mail address. You can still e-mail that person, but it will be through a form that makes the process blind to your mail program. This is accepted Internet practice, so I'm not feeling too conflicted by this change.

What you need to keep in mind is that if you are using a decoy e-mail address (e.g., joeblowNOSPAM@yourisp.com) to thwart spam bots, you can now use your actual address with the knowledge that it will be safely hidden from intruders and harvesters. If you don't use your real address, other visitors and/or moderators will not be able to send you an e-mail from our forum.

One of the reasons we didn't adopt this regime earlier is the potential for abuse on a forum like ours that doesn't require visitors to register. We're now reconsidering the registration decision as well as we move ahead with our ambitious program of new initiatives that you will be seeing more and more of in coming weeks.

I hope you support the decision to go to blind e-mail display. If not, hit the suggestion box again. I really enjoy getting your excellent and candid feedback. All I ask is that you be constructive with your criticism. We're working round the clock here to create the most stable, intelligent, friendly environment for discussion we possibly can. Thanks!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#2

Great change.

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I'll now add an e-mail address to my profile.

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#3

Dale Lenz

Re:That's a good thing, Thanks!

Dale Lenz

>

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#4

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Ellis,

That is a welcome change.

George

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#5

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>To bad you had to do this but I agree with you.

You know that change generely comes with abuse.

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#6

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Bill Schreiber, Litchfield, NH

>not a bad idea at all. I like it...

Regards,

Bill

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#7

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Ray Binnicker

>Good job, Ellis. But, I'm sure someone will have a problem with the new way. Hey, I just thought of a great new phrase: "You can please some of the people some of the time, you can please all the ...... "Well I guess it wouldn't catch on, anyway. (:-)

Ray Binnicker

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#8

Please don't require registration

Rob Sandow

>That can kill forums. Some people are reluctant to sign up. Casual visitors who just want to ask one question get discouraged by the requirement to sign up. Etc. I do post on a couple of forums (non-woodworking) where registration is required, and it doesn't stop the trolls and spammers. If they get banned, they just come back under a new name. The only thing it stops is legit posters who don't want to bother signing up for occasional use.

Rob

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#9

Re: Please don't require registration

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I agree. I'm not in favor of registration, either.

Rod

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#10

Here's the problem I have…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I'm sorry to be among the minority (actually I'm not sorry for my position, I'm sorry that it seems to be a minority one), but I don't care for this feature. I've seen/used it at other sites and it's a serious aggravation for me.

There are at least a couple of reasons why I don't like it—I occasionally harvest an email addy when I want to send a mail to someone whose address I actually may have used but has timed out of the autofill feature of my email client. Okay, so I'm lazy, but it's sometimes a bit of a search to find it in my client (see below). Also, if someone's address is br549@hotmail.com instead of a saner ellisw@fast.net (for example) it can be pretty hard to ferret out, even if there weren't 11 years of data to comb through. So that's a legitimate need for copying an address off of a post.

Number two is whenever I send an email from my email client, it automatically copies the mail to the “Copy to Self” directory. I archive all of my email—in and out. Call me anal, but I have a copy of every email I've sent or received since I got on the internet in '96. That's neither here nor there, but the fact that I lose the ability to keep a copy of the email is a big negative for me.

Now, there are a couple of things which might make all of this palatable to me (not that you need to make it palatable in any event). One, would be to allow me to insert an address for a bcc (which I can fill out to go to myself or anyone else, for that matter). The other (which you can see for yourself at QRZ.com, a ham radio call sign database) involves the email address being displayed as a jpg, which obviously has no textual base which a harvester could use. In the small box in the upper left corner, under the globe logo, type “k4qg” (case doesn't matter), which is my call sign, and click or Enter.

About a quarter of the way down on the resultant page is a line that says, “Email: Show K4QG's email address” Click on that and you will get a popup with my email address (one of them) clearly and legibly displayed, but is a jpg and is unclickable. I don't know how they generate the graphic but it must be automated (there are hundreds of thousands of call signs in the database, so I'm sure they're not doing it manually).

Anyway, put me down for a no.

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#11

No problem here!Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I've registered a one other woodworking forum and it didn't hurt a bit. The usual concern when registering is some sites sign you up for all sorts of advertiser emailings and you get lots of junk mail. Registration shouldn't be necessary and as others have stated, may stop a few casual visitors from posting questions, but if they are assured of personal info security and no spam rule it shouldn't be a problem. In my case I don't care one way or the other. If registration is reuired, it won't chase me away.

The other website incidently has many more users than this one (Members: 25,349, Active Members: 10,077)

just my 2 cents worth.

Lee

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#12

KIS-

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I use Wood Central because you have Kept It Simple. I have gone to the other sites and when I hit the registration process I say to hell with it and return to WC.

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#13

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Howard Norman

>I have no problem with the new email feature. I do have a problem with forum registration. I am not sure that it really accomplishes anything worthwhile.

Howard

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#14

Re: KIS-

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>I could not agree more. The easy access, the straightforward system, the openness, these are the strengths here and the reasons that I use this forum and none of the others. I really don't want log ins and passwords, registrations and memberships, and hidden information.

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#15

Gotta Problem

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Ellis

When I tried to send an email earlier, I noticed that the Google Ads on the right margin hid my text, and I couldn't see what I had typed "under" one of them. That drives me crazy because I try to proof read my text before launching it. What to do, what to do?

George

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#16

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Stuart Hough

>I'm okay with it for now. I understand all the negative posts about registration, though. It seems as though we could come up with a process that would be near painless if we tried. JMHO

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#17

Re: Please don't require registration

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I agree - I am still trying to get used to this format - can't say I like it yet. Registration is just another hassle. I often quite sites as I loose the password when cookies are lost or corrupted. I am sure a lot of others are the same.

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#18

Re: Please don't require registration

Howard Norman

>>Registration is just another hassle. I often quite sites as I loose the password when cookies are lost or corrupted. I am sure a lot of others are the same.<

I agree completely. I have probable quite a dozen or so forums because of password problems.

Howard

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#19

Re: Please don't require registration

Barry Irby

>I agree, completely.

I am sort of a member of the discussion groups that is bout the Nova DVR lathe I own. I say "sort of" because They E-mail me and I go there, but I can't post because I have forgotten my password or what ever it is I need to post. I don't understand why they would want to E-mail me but not allow me to post. Just because I forgot the secret handshake.

This password business has gotten out of hand. Different passwords for different things and some have different requirements. Numbers, not numbers, case sensitive or not.

I have to sign in to order parts from Delta. Bunch of Crap. Do they want the magic card number or the secret handshake? Not clear on what the problem is?

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#20

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Ned Bulken

>Ellis,

Works for me, I still will use a 'disposable' email address for my published forums. Even Aol is a 'disposable' anymore, since they hand out free email addresses.

P.S. I like the recent changes to the forums, and am looking forward to the continuing changes in the coming months.

Ned

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#21

Ellis Walentine

Very interesting....

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#22

Bill Blasic

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

Bill Blasic

>Greta idea!

Re: *** New E-mail Feature ***

#23

Ellis Walentine

Not ready for prime time

Ellis Walentine

>Next week we'll see if we can solve the mysteries of this new feature. Apparently there are browser issues that are preventing people from posting messages. Stay tuned.

Ellis