Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Posts

Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#1

Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Karen in Dunrobin

>I recently broke 3 new aluminum Universal clamps (see attached pictures). The store that I bought them from is replacing them but I have some questions about the clamps. I am wondering if I am applying too much force when using the clamps? When I use my Bessy clamps, I tighten them until I can't tighten them anymore. When I broke the aluminum clamps I was tightening them with both hands and the screw seemed to be advancing without too much resistance right until the breaking point. I guess my question is how do I know when to stop tightening the clamps? I am a 135 lb woman so it is hard for me to believe that I have the strength to break a clamp. I bought a set of 10 clamps and I am worried about breaking more of them if I am not using them correctly. Anyone else ever broken any?

Karen


img

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#2

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Karen,

I have a couple thoughts. First, I wonder what you were clamping which required so much pressure. I clamp my boards tightly enough to cause some glue to squeeze out. With well jointed boards, it takes only a little pressure to achieve this. Further, the joint is not starved for glue. Your smaller stature still should let you achieve good and effective clamping pressure easily, and without using both hands.

I do not use aluminum clamps, preferring the stronger iron pipe or bar clamp designs from Pony. They are heavier and probably more difficult to manage than lighter weight aluminum. I have yet to break one, and they are decades old. So, if I needed more clamps, I would favor buying the iron pipe/bar clamps which have proved successful in my shop. You may want to consider replacing the broken ones with Besseys or Ponys.

George

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#3

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Karen,

Your post and pictures gave me a couple thoughts. First, I wonder if you actually needed all the pressure you were generating with both hands. Normally, well jointed boards come together easily and provide even glue squeeze out over their length. Clamping too tight will result in a joint which is starved for glue. The aluminum clamps, while not as strong as the iron Pony pipe and bar clamps I use, are certainly strong enough to do the job in all cases I can envision.

Aluminum isn't as strong a material as iron or steel, and that may be why your Universal clamps failed when you kept cranking them tighter. Since they are somewhat lighter, you may find them easier to manage. As replacements, you could try some Pony or Jorgensen pipe or bar clamps. I find them no more cumbersome than similar sized Besseys. And, in my opinion, they work more easily than Besseys.

George

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#4

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Karen,

Your post and pictures gave me a couple thoughts. First, I wonder if you actually needed all the pressure you were generating with both hands. Normally, well jointed boards come together easily and provide even glue squeeze out over their length. Clamping too tight will result in a joint which is starved for glue. The aluminum clamps, while not as strong as the iron Pony or Jorgensen pipe and bar clamps I use, are certainly strong enough to do the job in all cases I can envision.

Aluminum isn't as strong a material as iron or steel, and that may be why your Universal clamps failed when you kept cranking them tighter. Since they are somewhat lighter, you may find them easier to manage. As replacements, you could try some Pony or Jorgensen pipe or bar clamps. I find them no more cumbersome than similar sized Besseys. And, in my opinion, they work more easily than Besseys.

George

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#5

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Karen,

Your post and pictures gave me a couple thoughts. First, I wonder if you actually needed all the pressure you were generating with both hands. Normally, well jointed boards come together easily and provide even glue squeeze out over their length. Clamping too tight will result in a joint which is starved for glue. The aluminum clamps, while not as strong as the iron Pony pipe and bar clamps I use, are certainly strong enough to do the job in all cases I can envision.

Aluminum isn't as strong a material as iron or steel, and that may be why your Universal clamps failed when you kept cranking them tighter. Since they are somewhat lighter, you may find them easier to manage. As replacements, you could try some Pony or Jorgensen pipe or bar clamps. I find them no more cumbersome than similar sized Besseys. And, in my opinion, they work more easily than Besseys.

George

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#6

test

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#7

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Bill Hale / The Wood Spinner

>I don't know but looking at the pic they look like cheap aluminum. I don't think I wouls have purchased them in the first place. Take them back where you bought them and buy a good name tool.

Remember in tools price does make a difference. Quality is never cheap.

Bill in CG, AZ.

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#8

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Karen,

Well jointed boards should come together easily with only moderate pressure on the clamps. It seems to me that the aluminum clamps you are using should be fully capable of performing that task. Too much pressure would cause excessive squeeze out and glue-starved joints, as well as clamping failure.

You should not have to use both hands to crank your clamps closed. Try moderate pressure--just enough for even squeeze out over the length of the joint.

I use Pony and Jorgensen pipe and bar clamps and have never had a failure as you describe. Iron and steel clamps are more robust and weigh less than aluminum for a given size. I doubt you could break them--but you wouldn't ever need to crank them as tightly either.

George

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#9

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Ralph Turney

>Hey Karen,

Just what were you clamping that you needed that much pressure? Do the Bessey clamps have the straight handles or are they like the UC's with the wings?

Ralph

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#10

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Ralph Turney

>Hey Karen,

What are you clamping that needs that much clamping pressure? Do the Bessey clamps you are referring to have the straight handles, or are they something like the UC's, with wings?

Ralph

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#11

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Ralph

>Hey Karen,

What are you clamping that needs that much clamping pressure? Do the Bessey clamps you are referring to have the straight handles, or are they something like the UC's, with wings?

Ralph

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#12

Re: Contact the manufacturer

Brian in Brighton

>Karen, I would contact the manufacturer. I am sure that you are not alone. The castings are inferior and probably do not meet the specification. A person should not be able to break the casting there by using only hand force, even with 2 hands. I would push to get a 100% refund and have them pick up the shipping. If they care about their product, they should accept them back.

The place where you bought them will not go thru the same hoops to let the manufacturer know the problems unless they have a bunch come back.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#13

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Wow! I've used those clamps for years and I have never broken one. And I weight more than you do. Never mind how much more. :)

It is not necessary to clamp them that tight. You are squeezing all the glue out of the joint. If you have gaps that you are trying to close, then your joinery needs more practice.

I close the clamp until I have a firm connection and then add a quarter turn more. That is enough.

Or at least it always has been. :)

Incidentally, these clamps are used by cabinet shops all over, because they are lightweight and strong enough. If they had an inherent flaw, it would long ago have been addressed.

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#14

Universal Clamps story

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>These clamps used to be made by a family in CA. Great folks. Their clamps were used in woodworking factories were they were tightened with air wrenches. I have several dozen of these clamps and as a club project we have bought hundreds from the CA folks and none have failed to my knowledge.

A couple of years ago the CA folks encountered delivery problems with casting subcontractor that suddenly dumped them and they threw in the towel and sold out to a larger manufacturer.

Clearly there is a manufacturing problem with you clamps. Maybe the new place doesn't have adequate QC or they may have just had bad luck. Let us know if replacements are fine. Tighten the replacements as much as you can. The failure should be at the thread. At extreme pressure the threaded part will deform and then the screw won't work as smoothly (now how do I know that...).

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#15

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Rick in WNC

>If made in USA is to mean what it used to we will have to produce superior products to the "Made in China". When I first viewed your post my response would have been "Buy from China and see what you get", then I saw the "Made in USA". I am with out words.

Rick

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#16

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Rick in WNC

>When I first saw this post my first response would have been "Buy from China and see what you get", then I saw the "Made in USA". If we as a nation are to compete in producing above average product, we will have to produce good quality product and not junk and find how to be competitive with the new world market.

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#17

Test response

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#18

Ellis Walentine

Not me...

Ellis Walentine

>...but it wouldn't hurt to see if it has affected anyone else.

Ellis Walentine

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#19

Ellis Walentine

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Ellis Walentine

>Test.

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

#20

Re: Anyone broken Universal Clamps?

Charles Wiggins

>I'm not familiar with Universal clamps, but it's hard for me to imagine that you'd have this problem if you weren't over-stressing them. If they've been on the market for any length of time and it was a design flaw it would have been addressed. I suppose there's the remote possibility of a bad lot of castings - bad alloying or something.

I guess my question would be, "What were you clamping that required so much force to bring together?" I use Rockler aluminum clamps and have never have any problems. If your stock is straight and true you only need enough clamping force to close the joint so all of your mating surfaces are good and flush to each other. As Norm says, "Just enough pressure so some glue oozes out, but not so much that I squeeze all of the glue out."